Originally published 2021-12-28.
In December 2021 China formally complained to the United Nations that its Tiangong space station had been forced to dodge SpaceX Starlink satellites twice that year, on 1 July and 21 October 2021. The complaint, filed with the UN body that oversees the 1967 Outer Space Treaty, set off a wave of criticism of Elon Musk on Chinese social media. No collision happened. What the episode did reveal is how crowded low Earth orbit has become, and how unclear the rules are when a private company's satellites share space with a crewed station.
What China told the UN
China set out its case in a note verbale, a formal diplomatic letter, dated 3 December 2021 and addressed to the UN Secretary-General through the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space. The document, published by the UN Office for Outer Space Affairs, describes two incidents.
In the first, the satellite Starlink-1095 had flown at about 555 kilometres for more than a year before steadily lowering its orbit between mid-May and late June 2021 to around 382 kilometres, close to the station's altitude of roughly 390 kilometres. On 1 July the station carried out what China called a precautionary evasive manoeuvre.
The second involved Starlink-2305 on 21 October. China said that the satellite was manoeuvring continuously, its strategy was unknown and orbital errors were hard to assess, so "a collision risk" existed. The station again moved out of the way.
China did not ask the UN to punish anyone. It asked that the information be passed to every party to the Outer Space Treaty and drew attention to Article VI, under which states bear international responsibility for the space activities of their companies as well as their government agencies. In other words, Beijing was pointing out that the United States answers for SpaceX.
Who was aboard Tiangong
These were not abstract risks. Tiangong's core module, Tianhe, was launched on 29 April 2021. The first crew, Nie Haisheng, Liu Boming and Tang Hongbo of the Shenzhou 12 mission, lived aboard from June to September 2021, so they were on the station during the July encounter. The Shenzhou 13 crew of Zhai Zhigang, Wang Yaping and Ye Guangfu had arrived just days before the October incident. Avoiding debris and satellites is routine for crewed stations, but any manoeuvre uses fuel and requires careful planning.
The backlash against Musk in China
News of the filing spread quickly on Weibo, where many users attacked Musk and SpaceX. One widely shared comment, reported by The Independent, mocked the irony of Chinese drivers buying Teslas and so helping fund the satellites that had threatened their own space station. Others called for a boycott of Tesla in favour of Chinese electric-car makers.
It is hard to know how much of this anger was spontaneous and how much was encouraged. Chinese state media also amplified the story. Tesla's business in China, then one of its largest markets, was not visibly affected in the long run.
How crowded orbit has become
Starlink is a constellation of internet satellites in low Earth orbit. By December 2021 SpaceX had launched nearly 2,000 of them, and US regulators had authorised about 12,000. Since then the number in orbit has grown into the thousands more, making SpaceX by far the largest satellite operator in history.
Starlink satellites are designed to manoeuvre automatically to avoid known objects, and SpaceX shares orbital data with other operators and the US military's tracking network. Critics point out that automated avoidance only works well when both sides share accurate, timely information, and there was no regular channel for that between SpaceX and China's space agency. The incidents China described involved satellites that were actively changing orbit, which makes prediction harder for everyone.
More satellites mean more close approaches. Collisions are still rare, but a single crash can create thousands of fragments that remain in orbit for years and threaten other spacecraft. Scientists call the risk of a chain reaction the Kessler syndrome.
China's own debris record
Western experts quickly noted that China's record is far from spotless. Astronomer Jonathan McDowell of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics told The Guardian that the International Space Station had repeatedly had to dodge pieces from China's 2007 anti-satellite test, calling it "the biggest debris event ever." In that test, on 11 January 2007, China destroyed its own Fengyun-1C weather satellite with a missile, creating thousands of trackable fragments.
Russia added to the problem just weeks before China's UN complaint. On 15 November 2021 it destroyed an old satellite, Kosmos 1408, with a missile, and the crew of the International Space Station had to shelter in their docked spacecraft as a precaution. Both events show that the biggest single sources of dangerous debris have been deliberate weapons tests, not commercial satellites.
What the dispute means for space safety
The Outer Space Treaty treats space as a domain open to all and used for peaceful purposes, with no national claims of sovereignty. It was written in 1967, long before private companies operated thousands of satellites. There is still no binding international traffic-management system, only national licensing rules, voluntary guidelines and informal data sharing.
China's note, whatever its political motives, highlighted a real gap. As more countries and companies launch large constellations, including China's own planned megaconstellations, clear rules for sharing orbital data and coordinating manoeuvres will matter more each year. For now, safety depends heavily on operators choosing to talk to each other.
Sources: UNOOSA: Note verbale from China, 3 December 2021 (A/AC.105/1262); The Independent: China complains to UN about Starlink satellites; Wikipedia: Tiangong space station.

COMMENTS