First published September 29, 2022.
In August 2015, Nicole Barr, a 12-year-old pupil from Harlow in Essex, England, scored 162 on a supervised Mensa IQ test. That is the highest score the test can report for anyone under 18, and it placed her in the top 1% of people who sit it. Headlines at the time claimed she was “smarter than Einstein and Hawking”, but neither man ever took a comparable test, so that comparison does not hold up. What the result does show is that a bright, hard-working child reached the very ceiling of a well-established exam.
Here is who she is, what a score of 162 actually means, and why IQ numbers deserve a little caution.
Who is Nicole Barr?
Nicole was a Year 7 student at Burnt Mill Academy in Harlow when she took the test. Her family belongs to the Roma travelling community, and it was her father, James Barr, who encouraged her to sit it. He said he had long suspected she was exceptionally able and wanted that confirmed.
By his account, Nicole had always loved puzzles and numbers and was working several years ahead of her age group in maths. She told reporters she was shocked by the result, calling it “so unexpected”. At the time she said she hoped to become a doctor.
Her school praised her effort as much as her ability, describing a pupil who threw herself into a wide range of activities in her first year there. Her father added that it was a pleasure for the family to be in the news for a positive reason, and that the result showed brilliance can come from any background.
Mensa accepted her as a member that same month. Within weeks, another 12-year-old from Essex, Lydia Sebastian, also reached the maximum score of 162.
What a score of 162 means on the Mensa test
IQ scores are not percentages. They show how a person performed compared with others of the same age who took the same test. Most modern tests set the average at 100, and about two-thirds of people score between 85 and 115.
- The ceiling. On the test British Mensa used, the maximum reportable score was 162 for under-18s and 161 for adults. A top score means a test-taker answered well enough to hit the limit; it cannot show how far above that limit they might be.
- Rarity. According to reports at the time, only about 1% of people who take the Mensa test reach that maximum.
- Different scales. Not every test uses the same spread of scores. Mensa’s minimum qualifying scores are 130 on Wechsler tests, 132 on the Stanford–Binet and 148 on the Cattell scale. A “162” on one scale is not the same as 162 on another, which is why numbers from different tests are hard to compare.
Popular articles often describe 140 as “genius level”. There is no official genius threshold; that label is a media shorthand rather than a scientific category.
Did she really beat Einstein and Hawking?
No one can say, because there is nothing to compare. Albert Einstein died in 1955 and never sat a modern IQ test. The figure of about 160 often quoted for him is a guess. Stephen Hawking also said he did not know his IQ, and when asked about it in a 2004 interview with The New York Times he reportedly dismissed people who boast about their scores.
Very high scores are also the least precise part of any IQ scale. Measurements near the middle of the distribution are the most reliable, and claims of scores far above 160 are widely regarded as dubious. Putting Nicole in a ranking with two dead physicists made for catchy headlines but tells us very little about any of them.
What IQ tests can and cannot tell us
IQ tests are among the most studied tools in psychology, and they do predict some things reasonably well. Scores correlate with school grades at around 0.5, meaning they explain about a quarter of the differences between pupils. Links with job performance and income are real but weaker.
They also have clear limits:
- They capture reasoning, memory, verbal and numerical skill, but not creativity, practical wisdom or social and emotional intelligence.
- Anxiety, tiredness or low motivation on the day can pull a score down.
- Average scores rose by about three points per decade through much of the 20th century (the Flynn effect), a reminder that environment and schooling matter.
So a top score is a genuine achievement, but it is a snapshot of certain abilities, not a forecast of a whole life.
About Mensa
Mensa was founded in 1946 at Lincoln College, Oxford, by Roland Berrill and Lancelot Ware. Membership is open to anyone who scores in the top 2% of the population on an approved intelligence test. In 2015 a Mensa spokeswoman put worldwide membership at around 110,000, with about 20,000 in Britain and Ireland, and said roughly a third of members were female and fewer than one in ten were under 16. Today the society reports about 150,000 members in more than 90 countries, including around 17,000 in the UK and Ireland.
Supporting a highly able child
Nicole’s story is a good reminder that talent turns up everywhere. For parents and teachers of a child who seems far ahead:
- Feed curiosity rather than labels. Puzzles, books, maths challenges and clubs matter more than a number.
- Keep challenge high. Bored able children can disengage; ask the school about stretch work or acceleration.
- Praise effort. Children who think success is purely innate can become afraid of failing.
- Look after the whole child. Friendships, play and wellbeing count as much as test results.
Nicole Barr reached the top of the scale at 12 through a mix of ability, enthusiasm and family support. That is worth celebrating on its own terms, without needing famous names to make it impressive.
Sources: ScienceAlert, September 2015: second 12-year-old achieves maximum Mensa score; Wikipedia: Mensa International; Wikipedia: Intelligence quotient. The story was also reported by Truth Theory.

COMMENTS