Belgium's Métis Children Case: Five Women Who Sued and Won

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-10-17.

Five Women Challenged Belgium Over Colonial-Era Family Separations

The five women born in the Belgian Congo who sued the Belgian state over their removal as children. Photo: AP Photo/Francisco Seco.

In 2020, five women in their seventies who had been born in the Belgian Congo to Congolese mothers and white fathers took Belgium to court for crimes against humanity. As small children, they had been taken from their mothers and placed in a Catholic mission far from home, under a colonial policy aimed at mixed-race, or "métis", children. They lost at first instance in December 2021. On 2 December 2024 the Brussels Court of Appeal reversed that ruling, found that their removal was a crime against humanity, and ordered the Belgian state to compensate them.

Here is who the women are, what was done to them, how Belgium has responded to its colonial past, and why the appeal ruling matters well beyond their own case.

Who brought the case

The plaintiffs are Léa Tavares Mujinga, Monique Bintu Bingi, Noëlle Verbeken, Simone Ngalula and Marie-José Loshi. They were born between 1945 and 1950 in what is now the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), then a Belgian colony. According to their lawyers, each was between two and four years old when she was taken from her mother.

All five were sent to the same Catholic mission at Katende, in Kasai province, run by the Sisters of Saint Vincent de Paul. About twenty other mixed-race girls and Congolese orphans lived there, in what the legal filings describe as very hard conditions. The women later settled in France and Belgium, and they have described their lawsuit as a way of getting the state to name what happened, not only to them but to thousands of others. Their lawyer Michèle Hirsch put it bluntly when the case reached court in October 2021: "This is not for the money."

Each woman asked for 50,000 euros in damages. They also asked the state to hand over the documents it holds about their origins, records that many métis people have never been able to see.

What the métis policy was

During colonial rule, relationships between white men and Congolese women were common, but the children born from them were treated as a problem. Their very existence undermined the racial hierarchy that colonial rule depended on. Historians such as Delphine Lauwers of the Belgian State Archives have explained that these children were seen as a threat precisely because they blurred the line between colonisers and colonised.

The answer of the authorities was separation. A colonial-era law allowed mixed-race children to be placed in state or religious institutions, and Catholic missions became central to the system. Many fathers never acknowledged paternity, so children were often registered as orphans; names were changed, cutting the link with mothers and villages. The women's lawyers say families were threatened with reprisals if they refused to hand children over, and that the state's goal was to discourage mixed relationships and to stop these "children of shame" from later claiming any tie to Belgium.

Estimates of how many children were affected range from about 5,000 to 20,000 across the Belgian Congo and the neighbouring territory of Ruanda-Urundi (today Rwanda and Burundi). Some were sent to Belgium and adopted. Many have never been able to trace their parents or obtain their birth records, and some ended up stateless.

Abandoned at independence

When unrest broke out in Kasai as the Congo moved to independence in 1960, the missionaries left for Belgium, leaving the girls and dozens of other children behind. Militia fighters put in charge of guarding them sexually abused several of the girls. The women said in their case that both the state and the Church had abandoned them at the moment they were most vulnerable.

Belgium's colonial past, briefly

The Congo became Belgian in two stages. From 1885 to 1908 it was the Congo Free State, a territory personally owned by King Leopold II, who never visited it. His regime forced Congolese villagers to collect wild rubber and ivory, enforced by a private army, the Force Publique, which used killings, hostage-taking and mutilation, including the cutting off of hands. Reports by the British consul Roger Casement and others caused an international scandal, and in 1908 the Belgian parliament annexed the territory as the Belgian Congo. It remained a colony until independence on 30 June 1960.

How many people died under Leopold is still debated. The writer Adam Hochschild cited a figure of about 10 million; other historians and demographers argue the number is impossible to establish because no census was held before 1924, and some lower estimates are in the low millions. What is not in dispute is that the system was extraordinarily violent even by the standards of its time.

How Belgium has responded

Acknowledgement came slowly, and mostly in the last decade:

  • 2018: the Belgian parliament adopted a resolution recognising a policy of targeted segregation and forced removal of métis children and calling for redress.
  • 2019: Prime Minister Charles Michel formally apologised in parliament for the segregation of métis children and the separation of families, though he did not call it a crime.
  • June 2020: on the 60th anniversary of Congolese independence, King Philippe wrote to the DRC's president expressing his "deepest regrets" for the wounds of the colonial past, the first such statement by a reigning Belgian monarch.

The same year, inspired partly by the Black Lives Matter protests in the United States, demonstrators defaced statues of Leopold II in several Belgian cities, and some were removed by local authorities. Many others remain.

The court rulings

The hearing opened in Brussels on 14 October 2021. The state argued that the removals were lawful at the time and that the claims came far too late. Lawyers for the women countered that crimes against humanity are not subject to a time limit and that the harm had passed down through generations.

In December 2021 the court of first instance rejected the claims, placing the policy in the wider context of European colonialism rather than treating it as a crime. The women appealed.

On 2 December 2024 the Brussels Court of Appeal ruled in their favour. It held that the Belgian state was responsible for the abduction of the children and their systematic racial segregation, that this amounted to a crime against humanity, and that Belgium must pay the five women a combined 250,000 euros for moral damage, including the loss of their bond with their mothers and of their identity. After the ruling, Léa Tavares Mujinga said: "The Belgian state uprooted us, cut us off from our people." Belgium could still take the case to the Court of Cassation, the country's highest court.

Why the ruling matters

The judgment was widely reported as the first time a Belgian court had held the state liable for a crime against humanity committed under colonial rule. Its practical effects are still unfolding. Lawyers for the women said it could encourage other métis people to come forward, and suggested a settlement for others might save years of litigation.

For anyone researching family history linked to the Belgian Congo, the case also highlights how much depends on archives. Records of placements, name changes and adoptions are held by the Belgian State Archives, religious orders and former colonial administrations, and access to them has been one of the main demands of métis associations. For the five women, the ruling came late in life, but it gave official weight to what they had said for decades: that being taken from their mothers was not a private misfortune but a state policy.

Sources: Euronews/AP: Women taken from African mothers sue Belgium for crimes against humanity (14 October 2021); Al Jazeera: Why has a court found Belgium guilty of kidnapping? (3 December 2024); Wikipedia: Congo Free State. Photo: AP Photo/Francisco Seco.

COMMENTS