Originally published 2021-10-16.
A study led by researchers at NYU Grossman School of Medicine, published in the journal Environmental Pollution on 12 October 2021, estimated that exposure to phthalates, a family of chemicals used to soften plastics and carry fragrances, may contribute to roughly 91,000 to 107,000 premature deaths a year among Americans aged 55 to 64. Headlines rounded this to "100,000 deaths a year". The figure is a statistical estimate based on an association, not a count of people proven to have died from phthalates, but it added weight to long-running concerns about these everyday chemicals.
Here is what phthalates are, what the study actually did, how much its findings can tell us, and sensible ways to cut your own exposure.
What are phthalates?
Phthalates are colourless, oily compounds made from phthalic acid. Their main job is to make hard plastics, especially PVC, flexible: around 90 to 95% of phthalate production goes into soft PVC used in flooring, tubing, cables, shower curtains and packaging. Smaller amounts appear in paints and varnishes, in the coatings of some tablets, and in personal care products such as nail polish, hair spray and perfumes, where low-weight phthalates help scents last longer.
Because they are not chemically bound to the plastic, phthalates can leach out over time, particularly into fatty foods and when containers are heated. Diet is thought to be the main route into the body, and people who eat a lot of fast food tend to have higher levels in their urine. Phthalates break down quickly, with a half-life of only a few hours, so the fact that nearly everyone tested has them shows that exposure is constant rather than a one-off.
What the NYU study did
The team, led by paediatrician and environmental health researcher Leonardo Trasande with Buyun Liu of NYU and senior author Wei Bao of the University of Iowa, used data from the US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). They looked at more than 5,000 adults aged 55 to 64 whose urine was tested for phthalate breakdown products between 2001 and 2010, then checked death records through 2015.
People with the highest phthalate levels were more likely to die during the follow-up period than those with lower levels, from any cause and especially from heart disease. Notably, high exposure did not appear to raise the risk of dying from cancer. Earlier coverage sometimes garbled this point; the study did look at cancer deaths and found no clear link.
The researchers then scaled up their results to the US population of that age to estimate how many deaths might be attributable to phthalates each year, arriving at 91,000 to 107,000. They also estimated the lost economic productivity from those early deaths at $40 billion to $47 billion a year, more than four times earlier estimates. A previous study had linked phthalate-related drops in testosterone to more than 10,000 deaths a year among men.
Trasande summed it up plainly: "Our findings reveal that increased phthalate exposure is linked to early death, particularly due to heart disease."
How much weight should the number carry?
The study is observational. It shows that higher phthalate levels go together with higher death rates, but it cannot prove that the chemicals caused those deaths. The authors said so themselves in their release, noting that the biological mechanism is not yet clear.
Several things could muddy the picture. A single urine test captures only recent exposure, which may not reflect a lifetime. People with higher phthalate levels may also eat more processed food or have other habits that affect their health, and statistical adjustment cannot remove every such factor. And extrapolating from one age group to a national death toll multiplies any uncertainty in the original estimate.
None of that makes the finding meaningless. It fits a broader body of laboratory and human research linking phthalates to hormone disruption, and it is a reasonable basis for caution. It simply means the "100,000 deaths" figure is best read as a warning sign, not a precise body count.
Why hormone disruption matters
Phthalates are classed as endocrine disruptors: substances that interfere with the body's hormone system, which regulates growth, metabolism, reproduction and much more. Some phthalates have long been known to lower testosterone production. Reviews of the research have linked exposure during pregnancy to adverse birth outcomes, and childhood exposure to small reductions in lung function and a possible higher risk of asthma and obesity.
In adults, researchers suspect phthalates may promote inflammation and metabolic changes that raise the risk of obesity, diabetes and heart disease, which would fit the NYU findings on cardiovascular deaths. The NYU team said they planned further work on hormone regulation and inflammation to test that idea.
Some popular reports have tied phthalates to falling sperm counts and changes in genital development in boys. Research on falling sperm counts in Western countries is real, but the causes are debated, and scientists also point to obesity, smoking, diet and inactivity. Phthalates are one suspect among several, not a settled explanation.
How phthalates are regulated
Rules differ widely. The European Union has restricted phthalates in children's toys since 1999, limits four common ones (DEHP, BBP, DBP and DIBP) in many consumer goods under its REACH chemicals law, and in 2021 formally recognised DEHP and several others as endocrine disruptors. In the United States, the 2008 Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act caps certain phthalates at 0.1% in toys and child care products, and California lists DINP as a carcinogen under Proposition 65. Many other uses, including food packaging and equipment, remain lightly regulated in the US and elsewhere because regulators have judged typical exposure levels acceptable.
Trasande has argued that the evidence is "undeniably clear that limiting exposure to toxic phthalates can help safeguard Americans' physical and financial well-being."
Practical ways to reduce your exposure
You cannot avoid phthalates completely, but because they leave the body within hours, small changes can lower your levels quickly. Steps that reviews and health agencies commonly suggest include:
- Eat more fresh, home-cooked food and less fast food and heavily packaged or canned food.
- Do not microwave food in plastic containers or cover it with cling film; use glass or ceramic instead.
- Avoid putting plastic containers in the dishwasher, where heat speeds up leaching.
- Choose personal care products labelled phthalate-free, and be cautious with products listing only "fragrance" or "parfum", which can hide phthalates.
- Look for soft toys and teethers that state they are phthalate-free, especially for young children.
- Ventilate your home and dust with a damp cloth, since phthalates also collect in household dust.
If you are pregnant, planning a pregnancy or worried about a specific health condition, talk to a doctor about your concerns rather than relying on general advice.
Sources: NYU Langone Health news release via EurekAlert!, 12 October 2021; Trasande, Liu and Bao, Environmental Pollution (2021): Phthalates and attributable mortality; Wikipedia: Phthalates. Story first shared via ScienceAlert.

COMMENTS