The Orangutan's Outstretched Hand: The Story Behind the Photo

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-10-07.

An Orangutan Reaches Toward a Man in Anil Prabhakar's Photograph

The photo of an orangutan stretching her arm toward a man standing waist-deep in muddy water was taken by Anil Prabhakar, an amateur photographer and geologist from Kerala, India, at a Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation (BOS) forest in Indonesian Borneo. It went viral in early 2020 as a picture of an ape "rescuing" a stranger. The real story is quieter and, in some ways, more interesting: the man was a long-time foundation employee clearing snakes, he was not drowning, and the orangutan may have been asking for food rather than offering help.

None of that makes the moment less striking. It does show why a single frame needs context before we decide what an animal was thinking.

What the photograph shows

A female orangutan sits on the riverbank, steadying herself with one hand on the ground while she reaches the other out over the water. A few metres away, a man in work clothes is standing in a brown, slow-moving channel, looking back at her. Prabhakar posted the image to Instagram on 22 January 2020, and CNN and many other outlets picked it up the following month.

Prabhakar described the scene to CNN in simple terms: "I saw an orangutan come very close to him and just offer him his hand." He said the encounter lasted three or four minutes and that he was so moved he almost forgot to take the picture.

Who was in the water

Early versions of the story said the man was a member of Prabhakar's team, or even a geologist who had fallen into a mud pool. According to a fact check by Lead Stories, which spoke to the foundation, he was Syahrul, a BOS worker doing maintenance in a moat around one of the islands where orangutans live at the Samboja Lestari rehabilitation centre in East Kalimantan. He had gone in because snakes had been reported in the area; venomous snakes are a real threat to orangutans.

He was not stuck and did not need rescuing. He moved away from the ape and climbed out by himself. Prabhakar was not working for the foundation either: he was visiting with friends.

The orangutan was identified as Anih, a female of about 25 who had been in the foundation's care since the 1990s, after she was separated from her mother as a youngster. She and Syahrul had known each other for decades.

A helping hand, or a request?

This is where the viral captions and the people who know Anih part ways. BOS chief executive Jamartin Sihite told fact-checkers that "she could have been asking for food from Syahrul." An outstretched, open palm is a common begging gesture among apes that have grown up around humans who feed them.

That does not rule out curiosity or a social impulse. Great apes are capable of reading the intentions of others, and researchers have documented consoling and helping behaviour in chimpanzees and bonobos. But a still photograph cannot tell us which motive was at work, and a gesture we read as kindness can mean something else to the animal making it. The honest answer is: we do not know, and both readings fit the picture.

Why the warden kept his distance

Asked why he did not take the outstretched hand, the warden reportedly told Prabhakar: "they're completely wild, we don't know how they'll react." An adult orangutan is several times stronger than a person, and even a playful pull could have dragged him off balance or hurt the animal.

There is a second reason. Rehabilitation centres try to limit close contact so that orangutans can eventually live without depending on people. Diseases also pass easily between humans and apes, from colds to more serious infections. Keeping a respectful gap protects both sides, which is exactly what Syahrul did.

The Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation

BOS takes in orangutans that have been injured, orphaned, kept as pets or displaced by forest clearance. Animals are treated, then moved to forest "school" areas and pre-release islands where they learn to find food and build nests, before being released into protected forest when they are ready. Older animals that cannot cope in the wild, as may be the case for Anih after so many years in care, can spend their lives on sanctuary islands.

The slow pace is unavoidable. A wild female orangutan gives birth only every six to eight years, and young orangutans stay with their mothers for years, learning how to survive. When a mother is killed, that knowledge has to be taught by people instead.

Bornean orangutans today

The Bornean orangutan is listed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List. Roughly 104,700 remain in the wild, a fraction of their historic numbers, and most of the decline has happened in the past few decades. The main threats are:

  • Forest loss from logging, fire and the expansion of oil-palm plantations;
  • Hunting, including killings during crop conflicts; a 2008–2009 survey estimated that 750 to 1,800 orangutans had been killed in a single year;
  • Capture of infants for the illegal pet trade, usually after the mother is killed;
  • Weak enforcement, with prosecutions still rare.

Orangutans can live 35 to 45 years in the wild. Because they breed so slowly, every lost adult female sets a population back by decades.

How to help orangutans in a practical way

If the photo moved you, there are useful things to do with that feeling. Support established rescue and habitat groups that report openly on their work. When buying products containing palm oil, look for credible certification, since a total boycott can simply shift demand to less regulated producers. And if you visit Borneo, choose operators that keep their distance from wildlife and never offer photos holding or feeding apes.

Anih's outstretched hand became a symbol of empathy between species. Whatever she meant by it, the more lasting lesson is about the people who spend their working lives in muddy moats so that orangutans like her have somewhere safe to live.

Sources: photograph by Anil Prabhakar; CNN, February 2020: orangutan offers a helping hand; Lead Stories fact check, October 2021; The Dodo; Wikipedia: Bornean orangutan.

COMMENTS