First published September 12, 2021.
In September 2021 lawyers for Virginia Giuffre told a federal court in Manhattan that Prince Andrew had been served with her civil lawsuit. The suit, filed on 9 August 2021, accused the Queen’s second son of sexually abusing her in 2001, when she was 17 and, she said, being trafficked by the financier Jeffrey Epstein. Andrew denied the allegations then and has continued to deny them.
The question of service mattered because a civil case cannot move forward until the defendant has been formally notified. What followed was a short legal tussle over paperwork, a ruling that let the case proceed, and in February 2022 a settlement that ended it without a trial. The story did not stop there: Giuffre’s death in 2025, the loss of Andrew’s royal titles and a police investigation in 2026 have all kept it in the news. Here is what happened, in order, and what each step did and did not establish.
What the September 2021 court filing said
The filing was an affidavit from Cesar Sepulveda, a London-based process server. According to Reuters, he said that on 27 August 2021 he left a copy of the lawsuit with a Metropolitan Police officer on duty at Royal Lodge, the Windsor Great Park house where Andrew lived. Officers had told him the day before that they had been instructed not to accept court documents. When he returned, he was told the papers would be passed on to the prince’s lawyers. Police would not say where Andrew was or let Sepulveda see him.
A source close to Andrew’s legal team told reporters he had not been personally served. Buckingham Palace and his spokespeople declined to comment. At a hearing on 13 September, his US lawyer, Andrew Brettler, told Judge Lewis A. Kaplan that service had not been done properly, and argued that an earlier, sealed settlement between Giuffre and Epstein released Andrew from liability. Kaplan gave Giuffre’s lawyers a week to sort out the service issue.
That was resolved within days. The High Court in London, which had at first turned down a request on a technicality, agreed to formally notify Andrew under the Hague Service Convention, an international treaty for delivering court papers across borders. From then on, the dispute was about the substance of the claims rather than the envelope they came in.
What Giuffre alleged, and what Andrew said
Giuffre’s complaint said Andrew sexually abused her in 2001 in three places: at Ghislaine Maxwell’s home in London, at Epstein’s mansion on Manhattan’s Upper East Side and on Epstein’s private island in the US Virgin Islands. It used the legal terms “sexual assault and battery” and “intentional infliction of emotional distress”. In US civil law, battery means unwanted physical contact; it is not a separate claim that she was beaten. The case was brought under New York’s Child Victims Act, which temporarily reopened the window for civil claims about abuse suffered as a minor.
Andrew’s position never changed. In his November 2019 BBC Newsnight interview with Emily Maitlis he said he did not recall meeting Giuffre and that the encounters did not happen. In court papers filed in October 2021 his lawyers said he unequivocally denies Giuffre’s false allegations
. A widely published photograph shows him with his arm around Giuffre’s waist, with Maxwell in the background; his supporters questioned whether it was genuine, while most experts who have examined it consider it authentic.
The interview itself had already cost him. Within days of its broadcast in 2019 the palace announced that Andrew was stepping back from public duties, and several charities and businesses cut ties with him.
Epstein, Maxwell and the wider case
Epstein was a wealthy financier with friends in politics, business and royalty. In 2008 he pleaded guilty in Florida to state charges that included procuring a girl under 18 for prostitution, under a deal that critics later called extraordinarily lenient: he served about 13 months, much of it on work release from a county jail, and avoided federal charges. Andrew stayed in touch with him after that conviction and was photographed walking with him in Central Park in December 2010, a picture that would haunt him.
Federal prosecutors in New York charged Epstein with sex trafficking in July 2019. He was found dead in his Manhattan jail cell on 10 August 2019. The New York City medical examiner ruled the death a suicide by hanging; staffing failures at the jail and broken cameras fuelled theories that he was killed, but official investigations have not found evidence of that.
Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein’s long-time companion and the daughter of the publisher Robert Maxwell, was arrested in 2020. At the time of the 2021 filing she was awaiting trial and had pleaded not guilty. In December 2021 a jury convicted her of sex trafficking and related offences, and in June 2022 she was sentenced to 20 years in prison. Giuffre had also sued Maxwell for defamation in 2015, seeking $50 million; that case settled in 2017 for an undisclosed sum.
The 2022 ruling and settlement
On 12 January 2022 Judge Kaplan rejected Andrew’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit. He did not rule on whether the allegations were true; he decided that the 2009 Giuffre–Epstein settlement did not clearly protect Andrew and that the case could go ahead toward trial. The next day Buckingham Palace announced that Andrew’s military affiliations and royal patronages had been returned to the Queen and that he would no longer use the style “His Royal Highness” in any official capacity.
On 15 February 2022 the two sides filed notice of an out-of-court settlement. Andrew paid an undisclosed sum, reported in the British press to be up to £12 million, and made a donation to Giuffre’s charity, SOAR, which supports abuse survivors. The joint statement did not include any admission of liability. Andrew said he regretted his association with Epstein and recognised that Giuffre had suffered as a victim of abuse. Because the case was settled, no court ever tested the evidence or made a finding either way.
Giuffre’s death, a memoir and the loss of titles
Virginia Giuffre died on 25 April 2025 at her home in Western Australia, aged 41. Police said early indications were that the death was not suspicious, and her family said she had died by suicide. Her memoir, Nobody’s Girl, written with the journalist Amy Wallace and finished before her death, was published by Alfred A. Knopf in October 2025.
That month Andrew said he would stop using the title Duke of York. At the end of October King Charles III began the formal process of removing his title and style of prince, which letters patent completed in early November. The palace described the steps as necessary censures, and he is now known as Andrew Mountbatten Windsor. He was also required to give up the lease on Royal Lodge, his home for more than two decades, and moved to the Sandringham estate in Norfolk in early 2026. Giuffre’s family said she had brought down a British prince with her truth and courage.
The 2026 police investigation
Further releases of Epstein-related documents in the United States in late 2025 and early 2026 included emails suggesting that Andrew may have passed confidential information from his time as the UK’s trade envoy to Epstein. In February 2026 Thames Valley Police said they were assessing the material, and on 19 February he was arrested on suspicion of misconduct in public office and released under investigation the same day.
Being arrested and released under investigation in England is not a charge and is not a finding of guilt. Andrew has since challenged the warrants used in the investigation through the courts. Any further developments, including whether prosecutors bring charges, should be read as separate, dated news rather than inferred from the earlier civil case.
How to read this story today
Four things are easy to blur together and worth keeping apart. The 2021 report was about the delivery of court papers, a procedural step. The 2022 ruling said the case could proceed, not that it was proven. The settlement ended the civil claim without any admission or verdict. The 2026 arrest concerns a different allegation about official information, not the abuse claims. Giuffre’s account, Andrew’s denials and the documented facts of Epstein’s crimes can all be stated plainly without merging them into one conclusion.
If you or someone you know has been affected by sexual abuse, support is available. In the UK, Rape Crisis offers free help; in the US, RAINN runs a 24-hour national hotline.
Sources: Reuters, 10 September 2021 (via Aaj News): Prince Andrew has been served with Giuffre’s lawsuit, court filing says; AP, 15 September 2021: US lawyers ask British courts to tell Prince Andrew of suit; Wikipedia: Virginia Giuffre; Wikipedia: Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor; Wikipedia: Jeffrey Epstein; ABC30 / AP, 31 October 2025: Giuffre family welcomes Andrew’s fall from royal status.
COMMENTS