Originally published 2021-08-28.
When the Taliban took Kabul on 15 August 2021, Afghanistan's small, hidden Christian community was among the groups with the most to fear. Almost all Afghan Christians are converts from Islam, and under the Taliban's interpretation of Islamic law, leaving Islam can be punished by death. Days after the takeover, an Afghan church leader told the US-based charity International Christian Concern (ICC) that believers expected some known Christians to be killed and were bracing for persecution.
This article explains who Afghanistan's Christians are, what the church leader described, why converts face such danger, and what has happened since.
What the church leader told ICC
ICC, a watchdog that monitors the persecution of Christians, recorded a two-part interview with an Afghan church leader whose name was withheld for his safety. CBN News reported his comments on 16 August 2021, the day after Kabul fell.
He described an atmosphere of suspicion. In areas the Taliban already controlled, he said, fighters went door to door, asked for food and money, and recorded the names of everyone living in each household, often working through the local mosque. Neighbours, frightened for their own families, might give away whatever they knew in the hope of being spared. In parts of the north, he added, growing a beard had already been made compulsory for men.
His fears for converts were stark:
“Definitely, they're going to kill some of the Christians that have been known.” — Afghan church leader, interviewed by International Christian Concern
He also worried that Christian children would be taken: girls forced into marriage with Taliban fighters and boys sent to madrassas to be re-educated and trained as soldiers. These were his fears and expectations at the time, not documented events, but they reflected the experience of Afghans who remembered the first Taliban era.
Despite this, he spoke of faith rather than despair. As a convert from Islam himself, he said every believer from a Muslim background understood the cost of conversion. His closing words were a statement of trust:
“God has a purpose and a plan. He knows what's best for His children in Afghanistan.”
Who are Afghanistan's Christians?
No one knows exactly how many Christians live in Afghanistan, because almost all of them worship in secret. Estimates vary widely. ICC has suggested 15,000 to 20,000, Pew Research Center estimated about 40,000 in 2010, and the US State Department has given a far lower range of a few hundred to several thousand. All of these figures are uncertain.
What is clear is that the community is made up almost entirely of converts and that it has no public church. Until 2021, the only legally recognised place of Christian worship in the country was a small chapel inside the Italian embassy compound in Kabul, permitted under a 1921 treaty between Italy and Afghanistan. A Protestant church built in Kabul in 1970 was demolished just three years later.
Christianity in the region is not new, however. The Church of the East had bishops in cities such as Herat, Balkh and Kandahar between roughly the 4th and 14th centuries, and an Armenian Christian community lived in Kabul from at least the 17th century until its last members were expelled in 1897.
Why converts face the greatest danger
The core of the danger is apostasy, the act of leaving Islam. Many traditional schools of Islamic jurisprudence, including the strict reading followed by the Taliban, treat apostasy as a crime that can carry the death penalty. Even before the Taliban returned, converts faced pressure from family, community and the state.
A well-known example came in 2006, when an Afghan man named Abdul Rahman was arrested for converting to Christianity and threatened with execution. After international outcry, a court sent his case back to prosecutors, citing gaps in the investigation and doubts about his mental state. He was released and given asylum in Italy.
That case happened under an internationally backed government with a constitution that, at least on paper, allowed followers of other religions to practise their faith. Under the Taliban, converts had far fewer protections. For many, the main risks came not only from officials but from relatives and neighbours who might report them.
Lessons from the first Taliban era, 1996–2001
The fears of 2021 were rooted in memory. During their first period in power, the Taliban ran a strict theocratic state under Mullah Omar. Women were barred from most jobs and girls from school, and women had to wear the burqa and be accompanied by a male relative outside the home. Music, television, cinema and even kite flying were banned. Men were required to grow beards and attend prayers, and punishments such as public beatings and amputations were carried out.
The regime was also responsible for mass killings. In 1998, after taking the northern city of Mazar-i-Sharif, Taliban forces killed thousands of people, many of them Hazaras; estimates of the death toll run into the thousands. In March 2001 they blew up the giant Buddha statues of Bamiyan, calling them idols, drawing worldwide condemnation.
Only three countries, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, ever recognised that government. It was overthrown after the US-led invasion that began on 7 October 2001, following the September 11 attacks.
What happened after August 2021
In the months after the takeover, many of the fears expressed by the church leader and others proved well founded. The US Commission on International Religious Freedom warned that Christians in Afghanistan were in extreme danger. Many fled the country. Those who stayed reported hiding from Taliban searches, and religious minority institutions lost any official recognition they had.
The Open Doors World Watch List, an annual ranking of the countries where Christians face the most severe persecution, placed Afghanistan first in 2022, ahead of North Korea. It dropped to ninth in 2023. That fall was attributed mainly to the Taliban's focus on consolidating political control rather than on hunting non-Muslims, and to how few known Christians remained, not to any new protection of religious freedom.
The wider picture also matched the warnings. Within weeks, early Taliban statements about music and public life were followed by restrictions on women's work and girls' secondary education, which were expanded in later years.
Why this story matters
Religious freedom in Afghanistan is not only about Christians. Shia Hazaras, Sikhs, Hindus, Ahmadis and secular Afghans have all faced threats, and many Sikh and Hindu families left the country after 2021. The experience of converts is an especially clear test of whether a state allows people to choose their own beliefs.
The church leader's testimony is one person's account, given under great stress, and it cannot speak for every Afghan Christian. But it offers a rare first-hand glimpse into a community that, by necessity, almost never speaks publicly. For readers who want to help, reputable refugee and human rights organisations continue to support Afghans of all faiths who have been forced to flee.
Sources: CBN News, 16 August 2021: Afghan Christians face terrifying future under Taliban; Wikipedia: Christianity in Afghanistan; Wikipedia: Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (1996–2001).
COMMENTS