Teen Pushes a Black Bear Off Her Wall to Save Her Dogs

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published June 2, 2021.

Video Shows Woman Pushing Bear Off Her Fence To Save Her Dogs

In late May 2021, a home security camera in Bradbury, a small foothill city in California's San Gabriel Valley east of Los Angeles, caught a teenager named Hailey Morinico running at a mother black bear and shoving it off the top of her family's garden wall. The bear had been swatting at the family's dogs, with two cubs beside her. Hailey grabbed one of the small dogs and retreated, the bears left, and nobody was seriously hurt.

The clip spread around the world within days. It is an extraordinary piece of footage, but the most useful thing about it is what wildlife officials said afterwards: why the bear acted as it did, why it was a black bear and not a brown one, and why nobody should try the same move at home.

What happened in Bradbury

The encounter took place on Memorial Day, Monday 31 May 2021, according to NBC reporting at the time. The family was outside, working in the garden, when their dogs spotted a bear and two cubs climbing along the wall at the edge of the yard. The dogs rushed over, barking. The mother bear answered with a few swipes of her paw and appeared to lift one of the smaller dogs off the ground.

That is the moment Hailey sprinted into frame and pushed the adult bear with both hands, sending it backwards off the wall. She then scooped up a dog and ran. Speaking to reporters, she said her only thought was simple: "I have to protect the baby," meaning the family's smallest dog.

The video was shared on TikTok by a relative under the handle @bakedlikepie, with a caption that summed up the internet's reaction: "My cousin Hailey yeeted a bear off her fence today and saved her dogs." Hailey was later reported to have come away with only a sprained finger, and none of the family's four dogs was hurt. A local flashlight maker even gave her a bravery award a few days later.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

Which bear was it? Black, not brown

Many early posts about the video called the animal a brown bear. That is a common mix-up. According to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), black bears are the only wild bears living in California today.

The name is misleading because black bears are not always black. Their coats range from jet black through chocolate and cinnamon to blond or tan, and many have a pale muzzle or a white patch on the chest. A brown-coated black bear is still a black bear.

Brown bears, the species that includes grizzlies, once lived across California, and a grizzly still appears on the state flag. But California's grizzlies were wiped out by the 1920s. If you see a bear in Los Angeles County, it is a black bear.

How to tell the two species apart

  • Shoulders: grizzlies have a prominent muscle hump above the shoulders; black bears do not.
  • Face: a grizzly's face looks dished or concave, while a black bear has a straighter profile.
  • Ears: black bears have taller, more pointed ears; a grizzly's ears look short and rounded.
  • Claws: grizzly front claws are long and pale; black bear claws are shorter and curved, built for climbing.

Why the bear swatted the dogs

After the video went viral, CDFW wildlife biologist Rebecca Barboza told NBC that the footage suggested the dogs had provoked the encounter. Her explanation was short: "The bear was protecting her cubs." The agency said it would take no action against the bear.

That fits what biologists know about black bears. They are generally shy and tend to avoid people, but a mother with cubs will defend them when she feels cornered or threatened. Barking, charging dogs are exactly the kind of threat that can turn a passing bear into a defensive one. Warning signs that a bear is agitated include huffing, snapping or clacking its jaws, swatting the ground and lowering its head. A "bluff charge", where a bear rushes forward and stops short, is a message to back away.

Bears are also superb climbers, which is why a garden wall is no barrier at all. In the foothills of the San Gabriel Mountains, bears regularly wander into neighbourhoods, especially in late spring and summer, drawn by bins, fruit trees, pet food and swimming pools.

Why you should not copy her

Hailey's story ended well, and her instinct to protect her pets is easy to understand. But wildlife officials were clear that it is not a technique to repeat. California's adult female black bears typically weigh 100 to 300 pounds, males 150 to 400 pounds or more. A bear that is already defending its cubs, and then gets shoved, could just as easily have turned on the person.

The advice from CDFW after the incident was to keep pets indoors in bear country, keep your distance if a bear is in the yard, and never confront a bear that has entered a home. If a bear is close, the usual guidance is to make yourself look large, speak firmly, back away slowly and give the animal a clear escape route. Do not run straight at it, and do not get between a mother and her cubs.

Living alongside black bears

California has a healthy black bear population, estimated by CDFW at roughly 49,000 to 71,000 animals statewide. Black bears are flexible omnivores: most of their diet is plants such as berries, acorns, grasses and leaves, plus insects, carrion and other animal food. They also learn fast where human food can be found, and a bear that gets used to raiding bins becomes more likely to end up in conflict with people.

That is why the most effective protection is boring and practical:

  • store rubbish in bear-resistant containers and put bins out only on collection day;
  • feed pets indoors and bring bowls and pet food inside;
  • pick ripe fruit and clear fallen fruit from the ground;
  • remove bird feeders in seasons when bears are active;
  • never feed a bear deliberately, which is illegal in California.

CDFW also mentions electric fencing and electric mats as deterrents for persistent visitors, and runs an online reporting system for bear sightings and conflicts. When bears stop finding food around houses, they tend to stop visiting, which is safer for families, pets and the bears themselves.

Why the video struck a nerve

Part of the appeal is obvious: a young woman, a large wild animal and a split-second decision. But the clip also captured something many people living on the edge of wild land know well. Suburbs in the San Gabriel Valley sit right against national forest, and bears, coyotes and mountain lions move through them regularly. The encounter was startling, yet, as Hailey herself told reporters, bears coming down from the mountains in summer was nothing unusual where she lived.

The best ending to stories like this is the one that happened here: a frightened bear and her cubs went back to the hills, the dogs went back inside, and the wildlife agency treated the bear as an animal doing what mothers do.

Sources: NBC News; NBC: bravery award and injuries; California Department of Fish and Wildlife: how many bear species live in California?; CDFW: black bear; first reported via The Mind Unleashed.

COMMENTS