Biden's Plan to Nearly Double Capital Gains Tax for Millionaires

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-04-24.

Biden's 2021 Tax-Rate Proposals

In April 2021 President Joe Biden set out plans to nearly double the federal tax on capital gains for the highest earners. Under the proposal, people with income above $1 million a year would pay 39.6 per cent on long-term investment gains instead of the top rate of 20 per cent. Adding the existing 3.8 per cent net investment income tax, the top federal rate would have reached 43.4 per cent. The idea was part of the American Families Plan, but it never became law.

What Biden proposed

Bloomberg first reported the plan on 22 April 2021, citing people familiar with it, and the White House published the details on 28 April as part of the American Families Plan. The key tax changes aimed at wealthy households were:

  • Capital gains: long-term gains and qualified dividends taxed at 39.6 per cent for households with income over $1 million, the same rate as top wage income. With the 3.8 per cent surtax, that meant 43.4 per cent at federal level.
  • Top income tax rate: restored from 37 per cent to 39.6 per cent, its level before the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.
  • Inherited assets: an end to the so-called step-up in basis for gains above $1 million per person ($2.5 million for a married couple), with protections for family farms and businesses.
  • Carried interest: closing the break that lets many investment fund managers pay capital gains rates on their share of profits.
  • IRS enforcement: an extra $80 billion over ten years to pursue unpaid taxes owed mainly by high earners.

The White House repeated Biden's campaign promise that nobody earning less than $400,000 a year would see a tax increase.

Why capital gains are taxed differently

A capital gain is the profit made when you sell an asset, such as shares, a business or property, for more than you paid. In the US, gains on assets held for more than a year have long been taxed at lower rates than wages, currently 0, 15 or 20 per cent depending on income.

Supporters of the lower rate argue it encourages saving and investment, compensates for inflation that inflates paper gains, and avoids taxing company profits twice. Critics reply that the preference mainly benefits the very wealthy, whose income comes largely from investments, and helps explain why some billionaires pay lower effective tax rates than nurses or teachers. Biden argued it was unfair that many wealthy people paid lower rates than middle-class workers.

Very few households would have been affected. Only a small fraction of taxpayers report more than $1 million of income in a year, but they receive a large share of all capital gains.

What the money was meant to pay for

The American Families Plan proposed around $1 trillion in new spending plus about $800 billion in tax credits over ten years. It included roughly $200 billion for universal pre-kindergarten, about $200 billion to cap childcare costs at 7 per cent of family income, over $200 billion for paid family and medical leave, funding for free community college, and extensions of the expanded child tax credit and health insurance subsidies.

The higher capital gains rate alone was estimated by the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center to raise about $370 billion over a decade, although analysts warned that wealthy investors could reduce the yield by holding assets longer or timing their sales.

A separate proposal, the $2.25 trillion American Jobs Plan for infrastructure, was to be funded mainly by higher corporate taxes.

How markets and politicians reacted

Stocks fell on the afternoon the news broke. The S&P 500 closed down about 0.9 per cent on 22 April 2021, and ten-year Treasury yields gave back earlier gains. Analysts noted that investors might rush to sell before any higher rate took effect.

Progressive groups and many Democrats welcomed the plan as a step towards fairer taxation. Republicans opposed it, arguing that higher taxes on investment would slow growth, discourage saving and cost jobs. Commentators also pointed out that in high-tax states such as California and New York, combined federal and state rates on gains could have topped 50 per cent.

In a CNN interview in March 2021, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen stressed that Biden was not proposing a wealth tax, but wanted corporations and wealthy individuals to pay more. She said higher rates on corporate profits, capital gains and dividends were "similar in their impact to a wealth tax."

Why the plan failed

Democrats held only narrow majorities in Congress, with the Senate split 50-50. Every Democratic vote was needed, and moderates were uneasy about the size of both the spending and the tax rises. The American Families Plan was folded into the Build Back Better Act, and the near-doubling of the capital gains rate was dropped along the way.

The House passed a scaled-back Build Back Better Act in November 2021, but Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia refused to support it, citing cost and inflation. Some of its climate, health and tax elements were later revived in the Inflation Reduction Act, signed in August 2022, which included a minimum tax on large corporations and more money for the IRS. The higher individual capital gains rate and the 39.6 per cent top income rate were not part of it.

Why the debate still matters

The question of how to tax investment income compared with wages has not gone away. Biden's later budgets repeated the idea of taxing capital gains as ordinary income for millionaires, and proposals to tax unrealised gains of the very richest have appeared in several plans since. Any future change would affect a small number of households but a large share of investment income.

For ordinary savers, the episode is a reminder that the headline numbers apply only above high thresholds. Gains inside retirement accounts such as 401(k)s and IRAs, and most profits on the sale of a main home, are treated under separate rules. If a proposed change might affect your plans, a qualified tax adviser can explain what it means for you.

Sources: Al Jazeera / Bloomberg (22 Apr 2021): Biden to propose nearly doubling capital gains tax for the rich; Dykema: Notable Tax Provisions of President Biden's Proposed American Families Plan; Wikipedia: American Families Plan; original report via Bloomberg.

COMMENTS