Texas HB 3326: The 2021 Bill to Treat Abortion as Homicide

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-03-11.

The short version: in March 2021 Texas state representative Bryan Slaton, a first-term Republican, filed House Bill 3326, which would have treated abortion from the moment of fertilisation as a criminal homicide. Because some homicides in Texas carry the death penalty, critics warned that the bill could in theory expose women who end a pregnancy to capital charges. Slaton denied that it would jail anyone. The bill never received a vote and did not become law, but it became a symbol of how far the Texas abortion debate had moved, months before the state passed the laws that actually reshaped abortion access.

A Texas Lawmaker's 2021 Abortion-Penalty Proposal

Bryan Slaton's 2021 bill drew national attention because of the penalties critics said it could open up for women.

What HB 3326 proposed

Slaton announced the bill on 9 March 2021 on Twitter, describing it as a measure to abolish abortion in Texas and to give unborn children equal protection under the law:

According to reporting by KWTX in Waco, the bill would have:

  • banned abortion starting at fertilisation, with no exceptions for rape or incest;
  • exempted ectopic pregnancies that seriously threatened the woman's life when no reasonable alternative existed;
  • allowed both women who obtain abortions and doctors who perform them to face assault or homicide charges;
  • offered immunity to people who gave evidence about offences involving the death of, or injury to, an unborn child;
  • told the attorney general to have a state agency enforce these provisions "regardless of any contrary federal statute, regulation, treaty, order or court decision."

That last clause was a direct challenge to Roe v. Wade, the 1973 Supreme Court ruling that still protected a constitutional right to abortion when the bill was filed.

Why critics talked about the death penalty

The bill itself did not mention execution. The concern came from how Texas law works. Under the state penal code, capital murder, a form of homicide with aggravating circumstances such as killing a child under a certain age, can be punished by death. If an embryo or fetus were legally treated as a person from fertilisation, opponents argued, a prosecutor could in principle bring the most serious homicide charges against a woman who had an abortion.

Most mainstream anti-abortion organisations have long opposed criminal penalties for women, focusing instead on doctors and providers. Slaton's bill belonged to a smaller "abolitionist" movement that rejects that distinction and argues the woman should be treated like anyone else who ends a life. That is why the bill was controversial on both sides of the debate, not only among supporters of abortion rights.

What Slaton said about it

Slaton framed the bill as a test of whether Republicans meant what they said. He told KWTX that it was time for Republicans to make clear "we actually think abortion is murder," and compared abortion numbers to Covid-19 deaths in Texas.

Asked directly about prison or execution, he insisted the bill would not "put a single person in jail," describing its purpose as simply declaring that an unborn child is the same as a born child. Critics replied that legal effect depends on the text and on how prosecutors use it, not on a sponsor's assurances.

Before filing the bill he had tried to block the Texas House from naming bridges and roads until it voted to abolish abortion. That amendment failed, but more than 40 lawmakers backed it, a sign that his position had some support inside the chamber.

The bill never became law

HB 3326 was referred to committee and went no further. It received no floor vote in the 87th Texas Legislature, and the official bill history on the Texas Legislature Online site shows no action after referral. News headlines suggesting that Texas was about to execute women for abortions therefore described a proposal, not a law.

It is worth keeping that distinction in mind whenever a single lawmaker's bill makes national news. Thousands of bills are filed in each Texas session, and only a minority are ever heard in committee, let alone passed.

Not the first attempt

Slaton was following a path already tried by Representative Tony Tinderholt of Arlington. Tinderholt filed a bill in 2017 that could have exposed women who had abortions to homicide charges; it received no hearing, and he later reported receiving death threats and was given protection by the Texas Department of Public Safety.

In 2019 a related Tinderholt bill drew nearly eight hours of public testimony before dying in committee. The committee chair, Representative Jeff Leach, cited security concerns that year. Bills to ban abortion in almost all cases had also been filed in 2011 and 2017, and none passed.

The wider picture in 2021 and after

Slaton's bill appeared during a wave of new state abortion laws. In the same week, Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson signed SB6, a near-total ban allowing abortion only to save the mother's life in a medical emergency. Like many such laws, it was written partly to invite a court challenge to Roe.

Texas itself then passed two laws that did take effect. The Texas Heartbeat Act, SB 8, signed on 15 May 2021, banned most abortions once cardiac activity can be detected, usually around six weeks, and was enforced through private civil lawsuits rather than by the state. A "trigger" law, HB 1280, signed on 6 June 2021, made performing an abortion a first-degree felony once Roe fell.

That happened on 24 June 2022, when the Supreme Court decided Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization. The Texas trigger ban took effect on 25 August 2022. It targets those who perform or assist abortions, with narrow exceptions for a risk of death or serious impairment to the mother, rather than the women themselves. Even so, prosecutions linked to pregnancy have not vanished: in 2022 a woman in Starr County was arrested and charged with murder over a self-managed abortion before the charge was dropped, a case that showed why critics had worried about laws like HB 3326.

What became of the sponsor

Slaton represented Texas House District 2 from January 2021. In May 2023 a House investigating committee found that he had given alcohol to a 19-year-old aide and had sex with her when she was unable to give effective consent. He resigned on 8 May 2023, and two days later the House voted 147 to 0 to expel him anyway, the first expulsion of a Texas lawmaker since 1927.

His abortion bill remains a reference point in the debate over whether women, and not only providers, should face criminal penalties. For readers trying to make sense of today's laws, the key facts are simple: HB 3326 never passed, the current Texas ban is aimed at providers, and the rules continue to be argued over in courts and in the legislature.

Sources: KWTX, 9 March 2021: Texas GOP lawmaker attempting to make abortion punishable by the death penalty; Texas Legislature Online: HB 3326 bill history (87th Legislature); Wikipedia: Abortion in Texas; Wikipedia: Bryan Slaton.

COMMENTS