Whale Shark With 50 Remoras in Its Mouth: Evans Baudin's Winning Photo

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Evans Baudin's Awarded Whale-Shark Photograph

Photo: Evans Baudin, grand prize winner of Scuba Diving magazine's 2020 Through Your Lens contest.

The photograph shows a huge female whale shark gliding towards the camera off Baja California, Mexico, with dozens of small fish packed inside her open mouth. Those fish are remoras, and according to the photographer, Evans Baudin, there were about 50 of them. The picture won the grand prize in the 16th annual Through Your Lens underwater photo contest run by Scuba Diving magazine, announced at the end of August 2020.

The image looks alarming at first, as if the shark had just scooped up a meal. In reality the fish were in no danger of being eaten. Here is the story behind the shot, what remoras are doing in a whale shark's mouth, and why the world's biggest fish is harmless to anything larger than a sardine.

How the winning photo was taken

Baudin was diving in June 2020 on an expedition operating under a special permit. The aim was to document marine life at a time when the pandemic had sharply reduced boat traffic and tourism, and to see how animals were responding to the quieter sea.

He has described spending about two hours in the water with a school of silky sharks near the surface when the boat captain shouted a warning that a whale shark was right behind him. He turned to find a female he estimated at more than 12 metres long, roughly 39 to 40 feet. Only when she came closer did he notice the passengers. In his words, there were "about 50 remoras peacefully enjoying a free ride in her mouth."

The fish count is Baudin's own estimate from the encounter. In a small web version of the image it is hard to count them precisely, but the crowd of slim grey bodies lining the shark's jaw is unmistakable.

The contest it won

Through Your Lens is Scuba Diving magazine's yearly competition for underwater photographers, open to amateurs and professionals. The 2020 edition received more than 2,600 entries, the largest number in the contest's history at that point. Judges first chose winners in several categories and then picked one overall grand prize image from among the finalists.

Other winners that year give a sense of the competition. Jules Casey took first place in the Behavior category with a seahorse grabbing a pipefish, Jeffrey Haines won Macro with a seahorse on sargassum, Martin Strmiska won Wide Angle with a diver lit by a beam of light in a cenote, and Tobias Friedrich won the Compact Camera category with a juvenile wonderpus octopus.

The magazine also shared the winning picture on its Instagram account:

A post shared by Scuba Diving (@scubadivingmag)

Why the fish are safe inside a shark's mouth

Whale sharks are filter feeders. Instead of biting prey, they take in large volumes of water and sieve out plankton such as copepods and krill, along with fish eggs and small schooling fish like sardines and anchovies. They can feed by swimming forward with the mouth open, a method called ram filtration, or by actively sucking water in and pushing it out through the gills. Filter pads inside the mouth trap the food, and a single shark can process thousands of litres of water an hour.

A whale shark's teeth are tiny and play no real part in feeding, so a remora riding in the mouth is not on the menu. The shark simply has no hunting interest in fish that size.

What remoras are and what they get out of it

Remoras are a family of fish best known for hitching rides. Their first dorsal fin has evolved into an oval suction disc on top of the head, made of slat-like plates that open and close to create grip. A remora can tighten its hold by sliding backwards and let go by swimming forwards. Depending on the species, adults range from about 30 centimetres to just over a metre long.

They attach to sharks, manta rays, whales, sea turtles and dugongs. Riding along saves energy, offers some protection from predators and keeps oxygen-rich water flowing over their gills. Remoras are thought to feed on scraps from the host's meals and possibly on its waste, though the details of their diet are still being studied.

Older articles often say the fish "clean" the whale shark and keep it healthy. That is partly true and partly an oversimplification. Biologists usually describe the relationship as commensalism: the remora benefits and the host is mostly unaffected. In some cases it may be mutually helpful, because remoras can pick off parasites and loose skin. But smaller remoras have also been seen entering the mouths, gill chambers and even cloacas of whale sharks and manta rays, and sometimes they cause minor injuries there. A mouth full of 50 hitchhikers is a striking sight, not a sign of a perfect partnership.

Whale shark facts and figures

The whale shark is the largest living fish. The biggest reliably measured individual, a female reported from the Arabian Sea in 2001, was about 18.8 metres (61.7 feet) long. Weight is much harder to pin down. The often-repeated figure of around 20 tonnes for the largest sharks is an estimate; one 11 to 12 metre animal found off Karachi, Pakistan, in 2012 was reported at about 15 tonnes. Baudin's 12-metre female would therefore have weighed many tonnes, even if nobody could put her on a scale.

These sharks live in tropical and warm temperate seas, usually where the water is warmer than about 21 °C. In Mexico, divers meet them in the Bay of La Paz in Baja California Sur and at Bahía de los Ángeles, among other places. Studies of growth bands in their vertebrae suggest they can live for many decades, with estimates ranging from 80 to well over 100 years.

They are also in trouble. The IUCN lists the whale shark as Endangered after the global population fell by roughly half over about 75 years, mainly because of targeted fishing, accidental capture in fishing gear and collisions with ships. Large, slow and often feeding near the surface, they are especially vulnerable to boat strikes.

Swimming with whale sharks responsibly

Pictures like this one inspire many people to seek out whale sharks, and in several countries regulated tours make that possible. If you go, a few common-sense rules help protect the animals:

  • Choose licensed operators that follow local regulations and limit the number of swimmers per shark.
  • Keep a respectful distance, usually several metres, and stay clear of the head and tail.
  • Never touch or try to ride a whale shark, and do not use flash photography if the operator or local rules prohibit it.
  • Let the animal set the pace: if it dives or turns away, do not chase it.

Baudin's encounter happened during a rare quiet period in the ocean, when fewer boats were on the water. The image is a reminder of how much life gathers around these giants when they are left undisturbed, and why the effort to protect them matters.

Sources: Photo by Evans Baudin, published by Scuba Diving magazine with the 2020 Through Your Lens results (31 August 2020); My Modern Met: Scuba Diving magazine's 2020 photo contest winners; Wikipedia: Whale shark; Wikipedia: Remora.

Related articles

COMMENTS