Originally published 2021-02-03.

On the afternoon of Friday 29 January 2021, police in Rochester, New York, answered a "family trouble" call involving a distressed nine-year-old girl. Body-camera footage released two days later showed officers handcuffing her, struggling to get her into a patrol car while she cried for her father, and then pepper-spraying her in the back seat. The video caused national outrage. Mayor Lovely Warren removed the three officers involved from patrol: one was suspended with pay and two were placed on administrative leave while an internal investigation went ahead. The girl was taken to Rochester General Hospital and released.
This article sets out what the footage shows, how city and state leaders responded, why the case became part of a wider debate about police and mental-health crises, and what better responses to children in crisis look like.
What the body-camera video shows
According to police, the call came from the girl's home on Avenue B. The caller said she had threatened to harm herself and her mother. Officers decided she needed to go to hospital for evaluation. When she ran, they caught her, handcuffed her and tried to seat her in a police vehicle.
The footage, which the department edited before release, shows her refusing to put her feet inside the car and calling for her dad again and again. Officers warn her that she will be pepper-sprayed if she does not cooperate. At one point an officer tells her she is acting like a child, and she replies: "I am a child." After a long struggle, a male officer says, "Just spray her at this point," and another officer does so. She is then heard crying in pain and begging for someone to wipe her eyes.
Deputy Chief Andre Anderson told reporters that the girl had resisted and kicked an officer, and said the spray did not have the effect officers intended. Because the clip was edited, it is not clear exactly what happened before and after the recorded sections.
How Rochester and New York responded
The city released the footage on Sunday 31 January. Police Chief Cynthia Herriott-Sullivan, who had taken charge of the department only months earlier, condemned what the video showed. Mayor Warren described the incident as "simply horrible" and said she saw her own daughter in the girl's face. After meeting the chief, she ordered the three officers off the street. The city explained that state law and police union contracts required the suspension to be with pay, and Warren said she would push for changes to New York's Civil Service Law so that cities could discipline officers faster.
New York Attorney General Letitia James called the incident deeply disturbing and said pepper spray should never be used on a child; her office said it was examining what had happened. Rochester's new Police Accountability Board also opened a review.
The response from the Rochester police union was different. Its president, Mike Mazzeo, said the officer had chosen a method that subdued the child without injuring her, while accepting that there might be better approaches. That argument did little to calm public anger. Around 150 protesters marched toward downtown Rochester on the evening the suspensions were announced, many carrying Black Lives Matter signs.
The Daniel Prude case in the background
The city was already under intense scrutiny. In March 2020 officers restrained Daniel Prude, a 41-year-old Black man in a mental-health crisis, placing a spit hood over his head and pinning him to the street. He stopped breathing, was taken off life support a week later, and the medical examiner ruled his death a homicide caused by complications of asphyxia during physical restraint. The public did not learn of it until September 2020, when the body-camera video was released, leading to weeks of protest and the departure of the police chief and his command staff.
Our earlier report on that case explains how Prude was suffocated and died soon after. In February 2021, a few weeks after the pepper-spray incident, a grand jury declined to indict the seven officers involved in Prude's arrest.
Both cases fed a nationwide debate that grew after the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis in May 2020, about whether armed police should be the first responders to people in emotional or psychiatric distress.
Why a crisis team did not respond
After the Prude case, Rochester had begun shifting some crisis calls away from police and had just launched a "person in crisis" team staffed by mental-health workers. It was not sent on 29 January. The mayor said the initial 911 call did not meet the criteria for that team, and that the city wanted joint police and crisis-worker responses in situations like this one in future.
That gap is common. Many US cities have experimented with models such as CAHOOTS in Eugene, Oregon, where medics and crisis workers handle many mental-health calls without police. Their reach depends on how calls are screened, whether teams are available around the clock, and how quickly a situation can turn unsafe.
Is pepper spray used on children?
Pepper spray, or oleoresin capsicum, causes intense burning of the eyes and skin, coughing and temporary blindness. Police policies differ widely, but many departments discourage or restrict its use on young children, people who are already restrained, and people in a mental-health crisis, because the risk can outweigh any benefit. A handcuffed nine-year-old in the back of a car fell into several of those categories at once, which is why so many officials, including some police leaders, found the footage indefensible.
Child-psychiatry and de-escalation guidance generally points the other way: slowing down, reducing the number of adults crowding a frightened child, speaking calmly, involving a trusted parent, and treating the episode as a medical emergency rather than a criminal one.
What parents and carers can do in a crisis
For families facing a child in acute distress, a few points may help:
- In the US, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (call or text 988) can connect callers to trained counsellors and, in many areas, to mobile crisis teams.
- When calling 911, say clearly that the emergency is a mental-health crisis involving a child, and ask whether a crisis worker can attend.
- Share calming information with responders: what helps your child settle, any diagnoses, and who they trust.
- Afterwards, talk to a doctor or the child's mental-health provider about follow-up care.
The Rochester footage remains difficult to watch. Its lasting value lies less in the shock than in the questions it forced cities to answer about who is sent when a child is in crisis.
Sources: NBC News; WBFO / BTPM, 2 February 2021; Wikipedia: Killing of Daniel Prude.

COMMENTS