Originally published 2021-02-03.

In January 2021, Melvin Capital, the hedge fund founded by Gabe Plotkin, lost about 53% of its value as retail traders organised on Reddit's r/WallStreetBets drove up the price of GameStop, a stock Melvin had bet against. Around the same time, reports revealed that Plotkin had paid a combined $44 million for two neighbouring properties in Miami Beach and was planning to demolish one house to expand his grounds. The contrast between a fund in crisis and a manager's lavish property plans became one of the most-shared stories of the GameStop saga.
Melvin never recovered. In May 2022 Plotkin told investors he would wind down the funds and return their money. Here is what happened, how short selling works, and what the episode revealed about markets, risk and public anger.
Who Gabe Plotkin is and what Melvin Capital did
Plotkin, a former star trader at Steven Cohen's SAC Capital, launched Melvin Capital in 2014, naming it after his late grandfather. He raised close to $1 billion at the start, and the fund became one of Wall Street's best performers, with assets reported at around $8 billion at the beginning of January 2021. Some reports at the time gave larger figures, around $12.5 billion, which likely included leverage or different accounting dates.
Plotkin was also prominent outside finance. In 2019 he bought a minority stake in the Charlotte Hornets basketball team from Michael Jordan, and in 2023 he led a group that bought Jordan's majority stake.
How short selling works, and why it can go so wrong
Most investors buy a share hoping it will rise. A short seller does the reverse: they borrow shares, sell them at today's price and plan to buy them back later, cheaper, to return to the lender. The difference is their profit.
The danger is that losses on a short position have no ceiling. A stock can only fall to zero, but it can rise without limit. When a heavily shorted stock jumps, short sellers may be forced to buy shares to close their positions, and that buying pushes the price even higher. This feedback loop is called a short squeeze.
GameStop was a natural target for short sellers. The video game retailer had been struggling as more games were sold as downloads, and pandemic lockdowns had closed many of its stores. By late 2020, short interest in the stock was reported to exceed the number of shares available to trade, an unusual and risky situation.
What happened in January 2021
GameStop started 2021 at roughly $17 a share. Investors on r/WallStreetBets, inspired in part by Keith Gill, known online as Roaring Kitty, had been arguing for months that the company was undervalued and that short sellers were overexposed. In January, the buying snowballed. Elon Musk added fuel on 26 January with a one-word tweet, "Gamestonk!!", linking to the forum.
The stock closed near $347 on 27 January and hit an intraday high of $483 the next morning. Motives among buyers varied: some believed in the company, some wanted to punish hedge funds, and many simply hoped to profit from the momentum. Those who bought early and sold near the peak made extraordinary gains; many who bought late lost heavily as the price fell back toward $90 in early February.
On 28 January, Robinhood and several other trading apps restricted purchases of GameStop and other volatile stocks. Robinhood said it needed to meet higher deposit demands from its clearinghouse. Many users saw it as protecting Wall Street, and anger spread across the political spectrum: Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez called the move unacceptable, and Republican senator Ted Cruz agreed with her.
Melvin's losses and the $2.75 billion lifeline
Melvin said it closed out its GameStop short on 26 January, but by then the damage was severe. The fund lost 53% in January, roughly $6.8 billion, and at times reportedly more than $1 billion in a single day. To steady the firm, Citadel and Point72, the firm of Plotkin's former boss Steven Cohen, invested a combined $2.75 billion.
That rescue fed suspicion, since Citadel's market-making arm also handled many Robinhood trades. At a congressional hearing on 18 February 2021, Citadel's Ken Griffin denied pressuring Robinhood to limit trading, and no evidence of coordination was found. Plotkin testified at the same hearing.
The fund struggled through 2021 and early 2022. On 18 May 2022, Plotkin told investors he would close the fund and return their money, writing, as CNBC reported, that he needed "to step away from managing external capital."
The $44 million Miami Beach property story
In December 2020, shortly before the squeeze, Plotkin bought two adjacent waterfront properties in Miami Beach for a combined $44 million. In early February 2021, British and American outlets reported that he planned to tear down one of the houses, a roughly $12 million home, to make room for amenities such as a tennis court. Miami Beach's islands and bayfront streets are home to many wealthy buyers, and the area drew a wave of finance executives during the pandemic.
The story spread because it seemed to capture the moment: a fund losing billions of investors' money, and its founder expanding a mansion. It is worth separating the two, though. A fund's losses fall mainly on its investors and its fee income; a manager's personal property was usually bought with past earnings. The renovation plans were reported proposals, not a record of completed work or new spending after the losses.
What the GameStop episode changed
The saga prompted a long debate about market structure. Regulators and lawmakers looked at payment for order flow, where brokers are paid to route trades to market makers; at the two-day settlement cycle that forced brokers to post large deposits; and at the risks of gamified trading apps. The US moved to next-day (T+1) settlement for most stock trades in May 2024, a change partly motivated by the deposit pressures seen in 2021.
For ordinary investors, the lessons are practical:
- Momentum cuts both ways. Prices driven by crowds can collapse as fast as they rise.
- Short selling carries unlimited risk. Even large, experienced funds can be overwhelmed.
- Apps can restrict trading. Read a broker's terms; access is not guaranteed in extreme conditions.
- Only risk money you can afford to lose. For personal decisions, talk to a licensed financial adviser.
GameStop itself survived, raising cash by selling new shares during later price spikes. Melvin Capital did not, and its rise and fall remains one of the clearest examples of how a crowded short can unravel.
Sources: Wikipedia: Melvin Capital; Wikipedia: GameStop short squeeze; CNBC: Melvin Capital plans to unwind funds (18 May 2022); CBS News: GameStop stock falls (3 February 2021); Daily Mail: Plotkin's Miami Beach property plans (February 2021).

COMMENTS