Boğaziçi Protests: Why Erdoğan Attacked 'LGBT Youth' in 2021

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-02-02.

In early 2021, Turkish students at Istanbul's Boğaziçi University protested against the appointment of a ruling-party figure as their rector. When the protests grew, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan responded by attacking "LGBT youth" and accusing the movement of vandalism. On 1 February 2021 alone, police detained 159 people at the campus, and the government's rhetoric drew criticism from human rights groups and Western governments.

Here is what sparked the protests, what Erdoğan and his interior minister said, and why the dispute became a test case for academic freedom and LGBT rights in Turkey.

Erdoğan Blames “LGBT Youth” as Boğaziçi Student Protests Grow

How the protests began

Boğaziçi University, founded in 1863 as Robert College, is one of Turkey's most prestigious public universities and has a long reputation for liberal, English-language teaching. On 2 January 2021, Erdoğan appointed Melih Bulu, an academic with long-standing ties to the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP), as its rector by presidential decree.

Students and many faculty members objected on two grounds. They saw Bulu as a political appointee with no connection to the university, and they said the appointment broke with the tradition of rectors being chosen from within. It was the first time an outsider had been imposed on Boğaziçi in this way since the period after the 1980 military coup. Protests started on 4 January. Academics turned their backs on the rector's building in silent daily vigils, while students held rallies on campus and in other cities.

The artwork that triggered arrests

In late January, students staged an exhibition supporting the protest. One piece, displayed near the rector's office, showed the Kaaba in Mecca, Islam's holiest site, together with rainbow LGBT flags and an image of the Shahmaran, a half-woman, half-snake figure from Anatolian folklore.

Police detained four students over the artwork and accused them of inciting hatred and insulting religious values. Two were remanded in custody and two placed under house arrest. Soon afterwards Bulu closed the university's LGBT studies club.

Interior minister Süleyman Soylu publicly described the four detainees as "four LGBT freaks." The phrase was widely condemned as dehumanising language from a senior official about people who had not yet been tried.

Erdoğan's "LGBT youth" speech

On 1 February, as riot police broke up a new rally at the campus, Erdoğan spoke to members of his party by video link. Casting the protesters as outsiders, he told young AKP members: "You are not the LGBT youth, not the youth who commit acts of vandalism." He praised them instead as people who mend broken hearts and connect to the nation's past.

The same day, police detained 159 people around the university, according to Istanbul's governor; another 104 people were detained the following day near Kadıköy, on the Asian side of the city. Footage showed officers pinning students to the ground and dragging them away, and protesters reported being struck with batons. Smaller rallies took place in Ankara and in İzmir, where police scuffled with students waving rainbow flags.

Erdoğan had used even harsher language before, calling demonstrators in earlier protests "terrorists", and his government described parts of the Boğaziçi movement as provocation by terror groups. The protest organisers, for their part, framed their demands around university autonomy, the right to elect their own leadership and freedom of expression.

International reaction

The United States State Department said it was concerned by the detentions and condemned the anti-LGBT rhetoric. European officials also voiced concern about the crackdown. Turkish officials rejected the criticism, telling foreign governments to stay out of the country's internal affairs.

The episode fitted a wider pattern that critics had documented for years. Homosexuality has been legal in Turkey since the Ottoman era, but LGBT people face widespread discrimination. Istanbul Pride, which once drew tens of thousands of people, has been refused permission by the Istanbul governor's office every year since 2015, officially on grounds of security and public order; police have broken up attempted marches with water cannon and tear gas.

The wider context: power, press and secularism

Since a failed coup attempt in July 2016, Erdoğan's government has detained or dismissed tens of thousands of people it accused of links to the plot, including judges, teachers, soldiers and journalists. Press freedom groups have repeatedly ranked Turkey among the world's worst jailers of journalists; the Committee to Protect Journalists placed it first in 2012 and 2013, and in 2016 it held a record number of reporters behind bars.

Critics also argue that Erdoğan has steadily given religion a larger public role in a republic founded on secular principles by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk. Abroad, his government has been criticised for military operations in northern Syria, involvement in the Libyan civil war, and disputes with Greece and Cyprus over maritime borders in the eastern Mediterranean. Supporters see the same record as strong leadership and a confident foreign policy, which partly explains why he has kept winning elections.

Universities have long been centres of dissent in Turkey, and the power to appoint rectors directly was given to the president under emergency decrees after 2016. That is why Boğaziçi's students and staff saw the Bulu appointment as more than a personnel decision.

How the dispute ended

The protests continued for months. By some counts they led to more than 500 detentions. Bulu struggled to find vice-rectors willing to serve, around 70 faculty members took legal action to remove him, and the government created two new faculties at the university, which protesters saw as a way to bring in loyal staff.

On 15 July 2021, Erdoğan removed Bulu by another presidential decree. The faculty's broader demand was not met, however: Bulu's vice-rector, physicist Naci İnci, was later appointed rector, and the vigils continued.

The lesson many observers took from Boğaziçi is that the argument was never really about one artwork. It was about who controls universities, how far peaceful protest is tolerated, and whether a minority can be used as a political target to discredit a much wider movement.

Sources: France 24 / AFP: Erdogan hits out at "LGBT youth" as police break up fresh protest; Wikipedia: 2021 Boğaziçi University protests; Wikipedia: Istanbul Pride; Wikipedia: Media freedom in Turkey.

COMMENTS