Nada Hassan's Death and Egypt's Long Fight to End FGM

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published February 14, 2021.

Egyptian Girl's Death After FGM Renewed Calls for Accountability

Pictured: Sohair al-Bata'a, a 13-year-old who died after FGM in Egypt in 2013. Photo: Women's Center for Guidance and Legal Awareness.

In late January 2020, a 12-year-old girl named Nada Hassan Abdel-Maqsoud died in a private clinic in Manfalut, in Egypt's Assiut governorate, during a female genital mutilation (FGM) procedure her family had arranged. Forensic examiners found that the cutting had been done without anaesthesia, and the retired doctor who performed it was not a qualified surgeon. Her death came twelve years after Egypt first outlawed FGM, and it showed how far the law still was from everyday practice.

Her story resurfaced in February 2021, when Egyptian police arrested a father and a nurse over the cutting of a 15-year-old girl. Both cases point to the same hard truth: a ban on paper protects girls only when families, doctors, police and courts treat it as real.

What happened to Nada

According to Egyptian prosecutors, Nada's parents agreed on 29 January 2020 to have her cut, citing "customs and traditions", and arranged it with a doctor in his 70s who ran a private clinic whose licence had expired in 2016. The procedure lasted around half an hour. Nada fell into a coma, attempts to revive her failed, and she died.

The doctor first told investigators that he had been removing an external growth, and later suggested that she had suffered an allergic reaction to antibiotics. The autopsy ordered by the prosecution found that FGM had been carried out and found no trace of the drugs he named. Egyptian media reported that her mother and an aunt were present, and that the parents and aunt later admitted they had brought her for cutting, not for any other operation.

Police detained the doctor, the parents and the aunt. In February 2020, Prosecutor-General Hamada El-Sawy referred the doctor and both parents to a criminal court in Assiut. Local outlets reported widely on the referral; the final sentences were covered far less, and readers should treat second-hand claims about them with care.

How common FGM is in Egypt

Egypt has one of the highest FGM rates in the world. The 2014 Egypt Demographic and Health Survey found that 92.3% of ever-married women aged 15 to 49 had been cut, and the 2015 Egypt Health Issues Survey put the figure at around nine in ten women in that age group. Those numbers describe women who were cut years or decades earlier, so they lag behind change.

The trend among younger girls is more hopeful. Among girls aged 15 to 17, the rate fell from 74% in 2008 to 61% in 2014, according to figures cited by Egypt's health ministry and a UNDP-backed study. That is still a majority, but it shows that attitudes can shift within a single generation.

One feature makes Egypt unusual: most procedures are carried out by medical professionals rather than traditional cutters. Around four in five cases recorded in the 2014 survey were performed by doctors, nurses or other health workers. Families often believe this makes the practice safe. Nada's death, in a clinic and at the hands of a doctor, shows that it does not.

What Egyptian law says

Egypt banned FGM in 2008. For years the penalty was mild, from three months to two years in prison or a fine, and prosecutions were rare. In September 2016 the law was tightened: performing FGM became a felony punishable by five to seven years, with heavier sentences when the girl dies or is left with a permanent disability, and anyone who brings a girl to be cut, including a parent, became liable to one to three years in prison.

In 2021, after Nada's case and others, lawmakers approved a further bill with tougher penalties, including longer sentences for medical staff and for cases that end in death. The pattern is consistent: each high-profile death has pushed Egypt's parliament to raise the stakes on paper.

Sohair al-Bata'a and the first conviction

The girl in the photo above is Sohair al-Bata'a, a 13-year-old who died in June 2013 after being cut by a doctor, Raslan Fadl, in the Nile Delta. Her case became the first FGM prosecution of a doctor in Egypt. Fadl was acquitted in November 2014; on appeal, in January 2015, he was sentenced to two years with hard labour for manslaughter and three months for performing FGM.

The sentence did not immediately take effect. Egyptian Streets later reported that Fadl was found still practising medicine, that his licence was revoked in early 2016, and that he was only arrested and jailed in July 2016. For campaigners, that gap between verdict and prison said a great deal about how seriously the system was taking the crime.

Why the practice persists

FGM in Egypt is usually justified as a way to protect a girl's "purity", to make her marriageable, or as a religious duty. Egypt's highest religious authorities have said that it has no basis in Islam, and it is also practised by some Christian families, which underlines that it is a social custom rather than a requirement of faith. Where it is the norm, parents may fear that an uncut daughter will be shamed or will not find a husband.

Enforcement is the other weak point. Speaking to The Guardian after Nada's death, Egyptian lawyer and anti-FGM campaigner Reda El Danbouki argued that FGM continues because there is "no desire from the political leadership to stop it." Families who arrange the procedure rarely report it, girls cannot, and complications are often recorded under other names. Prosecutions tend to follow only when a child dies.

A global problem, and what helps

The World Health Organization estimates that more than 230 million girls and women alive today have undergone FGM, across some 30 countries in Africa, the Middle East and Asia, and in diaspora communities worldwide. It is usually done between infancy and age 15. WHO lists immediate dangers such as severe pain, heavy bleeding, infection, shock and death, and long-term harms including urinary and menstrual problems, complications in childbirth and lasting psychological trauma. Treating these harms costs health systems an estimated US$1.4 billion a year.

WHO classes FGM as a violation of the human rights of girls and women and specifically warns health workers against performing it, because "medicalised" cutting gives the practice false legitimacy. Programmes that have worked elsewhere combine several things at once: enforcing the law, training doctors and nurses to refuse, involving religious leaders, and helping whole communities agree to stop together, so that no single family carries the social risk.

For readers outside Egypt, the practical takeaway is simple. If you know a girl who may be at risk, contact local child protection services or the police; anyone who has been cut and has health concerns should talk to a doctor, ideally one experienced in FGM care.

Nada should be alive today. Her death, like Sohair's before her, has become part of the case Egyptian activists make every time they ask for the law to be enforced, not just written.

Sources: Ahram Online (February 2020), Egyptian Streets (February 2020), The Guardian (original report), WHO: Female genital mutilation fact sheet, Wikipedia: FGM in Egypt.

COMMENTS