Did a Massachusetts School Ban The Odyssey? What Really Happened

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published January 1, 2021.

Odyssey Curriculum Dispute Prompted Claims of a School Ban

Left: Shea Martin, an educator whose 2020 tweet about The Odyssey drew wide attention. Right: an ancient Greek vase painting of Odysseus tied to his ship's mast as he sails past the Sirens.

Short answer: no school "banned" Homer's Odyssey in the sense most headlines suggested. In late 2020 a ninth-grade English teacher at Lawrence High School in Lawrence, Massachusetts, said on Twitter that her school had dropped the poem from its curriculum. A Wall Street Journal opinion column picked up the tweet, and within days stories around the world were reporting that a Massachusetts school had outlawed one of the oldest works of European literature. The real story is smaller, and more interesting: it is about who chooses the books in a classroom and why.

What actually happened in Massachusetts

The chain of events began in June 2020, when educator Shea Martin posted a tweet urging teachers to "take the Odyssey out of your curriculum because it's trash." Heather Levine, who taught ninth-grade English at Lawrence High School, replied: "Very proud to say we got the Odyssey removed from the curriculum this year!"

Six months later, children's book reviewer Meghan Cox Gurdon quoted that exchange in a Wall Street Journal column published at the end of December 2020. Her piece argued that a campaign against the classics was spreading through American schools. When Gurdon asked Levine to confirm the change, she reportedly called the question invasive, and the head of the Lawrence Public Schools English department did not answer requests for comment. Levine later made her Twitter account private.

According to a detailed write-up on the classics blog Mythoversal, Levine reportedly explained afterwards that the poem had been taken out of one ninth-grade unit, that teachers were still free to teach it, and that no book had been banned. In other words, this was a change to a reading list, not a prohibition on reading.

Curriculum change or book ban?

The words matter, because they describe very different things. A curriculum change means a teacher or department decides which texts a class will study this year. Schools do this constantly, swapping books in and out as courses are redesigned. A library removal means a book is taken off the shelves, so students cannot borrow it at school. A ban, in the everyday sense, suggests that students are forbidden to read the work at all.

Nothing in the Lawrence case points to the second or third. The Odyssey stayed in libraries, in bookshops and free online in many translations. What changed was that one group of ninth-graders would no longer read it as a set text. Whether that was a good teaching decision is a fair debate. Calling it a ban, however, made a local choice sound like censorship and helped the story travel much further than the facts justified.

Why The Odyssey matters

The Odyssey is traditionally credited to Homer, although most scholars believe it grew out of a long oral tradition rather than the pen of one author. It was probably composed in the 8th or 7th century BC and runs to 24 books and just over 12,000 lines of verse.

Its story picks up ten years after the end of the Trojan War. Odysseus, king of the island of Ithaca, is still trying to get home. His wife, Penelope, is besieged by suitors who assume he is dead and want her hand and his kingdom, while their son Telemachus sets out to find news of his father. Odysseus faces the Cyclops Polyphemus, the sorceress Circe and the Sirens before reaching Ithaca in disguise, testing his household and taking revenge on the suitors.

Few books have shaped storytelling so deeply. The very word "odyssey" now means a long, eventful journey. James Joyce built Ulysses on its structure, and recent novels such as Margaret Atwood's The Penelopiad and Madeline Miller's Circe retell it from the women's side. For Greek readers in particular, the poem is part of a living cultural inheritance, which is one reason the story caused such strong reactions in Greece and among the Greek diaspora.

What #DisruptTexts is, and what it is not

The online campaign linked to the episode is called #DisruptTexts. It was started by four teachers, Tricia Ebarvia, Lorena Germán, Kim Parker and Julia Torres, and offers blog posts, chats and teaching guides. Its aim is to get teachers to question how reading lists are chosen, to add more writers from under-represented groups and to read older works critically.

Its founders have stated that they "do not believe in censorship and have never supported banning books." Critics answer that the effect of the campaign, whatever its intent, is to push long-established classics out of crowded syllabuses. Both points can be true at once: a teacher can adopt the ideas of #DisruptTexts and decide to drop a book, without anyone banning it.

The wider debate over classics in schools

The Lawrence episode landed in a long-running argument. Books such as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and To Kill a Mockingbird have been challenged in American schools for decades, most often because of racial slurs in the text. The Great Gatsby and Joyce's Ulysses have faced challenges of their own over the years.

Those who want the classics kept on reading lists argue that a work can be studied without being endorsed, and that students lose a shared stock of references when the great texts disappear. Science-fiction writer Jon Del Arroz was among the voices quoted in coverage at the time, calling the movement against the classics a tragedy for young readers.

Those who want more change argue that there are only so many weeks in a school year, and that the choice of which books to teach sends a message about whose stories count. Young-adult author Padma Venkatraman, whose essay in School Library Journal was cited in the Wall Street Journal column, argued for teaching older works with careful framing and said she was not calling for bans.

Reading The Odyssey critically today

Modern readers do find difficult material in the poem. Odysseus is a trickster whose lies are celebrated. The suitors are slaughtered, and the twelve enslaved women who served them are hanged, a scene that has troubled readers for centuries and inspired Atwood's novel. The poem takes slavery for granted, and its picture of Penelope as the ideal faithful wife reflects the values of an ancient aristocratic society.

Many teachers see these tensions as a reason to teach the book, not to avoid it. Students can ask why the poem rewards cunning, how it treats strangers and guests (the Greek idea of xenia), and what it means that so much of the story turns on the patience and intelligence of a woman left alone. The Odyssey has survived nearly three thousand years precisely because each generation finds new questions in it.

What to take from the story

  • Check the claim. "Banned" often means "removed from one class's reading list." The difference is real.
  • Look for the source. This story rested on two tweets and one opinion column, with no official statement from the school.
  • The book is easy to find. The Odyssey remains widely available in libraries and in many modern translations, including several free public-domain versions online.
  • The debate is about choices. The real argument is over how limited classroom time should be used, and that is a question parents, teachers and students can discuss calmly.

Sources: Mythoversal: No, a Massachusetts school has not banned Homer's Odyssey; Greek Reporter; Greek City Times; Meghan Cox Gurdon, Wall Street Journal column (reprinted by Fox News); Wikipedia: Odyssey.

COMMENTS