Jack Ma's Disappearance After His 2020 Shanghai Speech, Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-09.

Reports Said Jack Ma Was Keeping a Low Profile in Early 2021

Jack Ma, the co-founder of Alibaba and for years the most famous entrepreneur in China, vanished from public view for almost three months after a sharply worded speech in Shanghai in October 2020. He was not arrested, as some rumours claimed. He resurfaced on 20 January 2021 in a short video, but the episode marked the start of a long retreat from public life and a sweeping government crackdown on his companies.

Below is a clear account of what he said, what Beijing did next, why so many people feared the worst, and what has happened to Ma and his businesses since.

The Shanghai speech that started it

On 24 October 2020, Ma spoke at a financial forum in Shanghai attended by senior regulators and bankers. He argued that China's financial rules were built for an earlier industrial age and were holding back innovation. He described the big state-owned banks as having a "pawnshop mentality", because they lend only against collateral rather than judging a borrower's prospects, and he mocked international banking rules as a club for the elderly.

The timing could hardly have been more sensitive. Ant Group, the financial technology company that grew out of Alibaba's Alipay payment service and was controlled by Ma, was days away from what would have been the largest share sale in history, worth about US$34.5 billion across the Shanghai and Hong Kong markets. Criticising the officials who supervise that business, in front of them, was seen in China as a direct challenge.

Beijing's response: a halted IPO and an antitrust fine

The reaction came quickly. Ma and senior Ant executives were summoned to meet financial regulators and the central bank. On 3 November 2020, two days before trading was due to begin, the Shanghai Stock Exchange suspended Ant's listing, saying the company no longer met the requirements; Ant then pulled the Hong Kong part of the offering.

Regulators had real concerns. Most of Ant's revenue came from financial services such as consumer lending, yet it sought the high valuation of a technology company while holding little of the risk on its own books. In December 2020, China's market regulator opened an antitrust investigation into Alibaba, and in April 2021 it fined the company 18.2 billion yuan, about US$2.8 billion, for anti-competitive practices. Ant was ordered to restructure as a financial holding company supervised by the People's Bank of China.

China analyst Bill Bishop summed up how many observers read the moment, writing in his Sinocism newsletter:

"The party has once again reminded all private entrepreneurs that no matter how rich and successful you are, it can pull the rug out from under your feet at any time."

Missing or simply keeping quiet?

As the weeks passed without a public appearance, international media began asking where Ma was. Speculation grew after he failed to appear as a judge in the final episode of a television talent show for entrepreneurs that he had created. Some social media posts claimed he had been detained; others suggested he was under some form of house arrest.

None of those claims was confirmed. Reports at the time said he was deliberately lying low. In China, where several wealthy businesspeople have been detained without notice in the past, the silence of such a prominent figure was enough to cause alarm, but silence on its own proved nothing.

On 20 January 2021, Ma appeared in a 50-second video shown at the online ceremony of his foundation's annual Rural Teacher Initiative, which honours around 100 teachers from poor rural areas. He did not mention where he was or what had happened. Alibaba's shares in Hong Kong jumped more than 6% on the news, a sign of how much the market had been worried.

Correcting the record on 996 working hours

Ma was already a divisive figure before the speech, largely because of his views on work. In April 2019, speaking to Alibaba staff, he defended the "996" schedule common in Chinese tech companies and called the ability to work that way a huge blessing for young people who want to succeed.

The name is often misunderstood. 996 means working from 9am to 9pm, six days a week: about 12 hours a day and 72 hours a week, not a 54-hour week as some early reports said. Critics argued it breaks Chinese labour law, and in March 2019 programmers launched a GitHub project called 996.ICU, a joke meaning that working 996 sends you to the intensive care unit. It quickly became one of the most-starred projects on the platform before several Chinese browsers blocked it.

In August 2021, China's Supreme People's Court published guidance stating that 996 schedules were illegal. Scholars have questioned how strictly that ruling is enforced, but it was a striking official rebuke of a practice the country's best-known tycoon had praised.

What happened to Jack Ma afterwards

The January 2021 video did not mark a return to normal. Ma gave up his post as head of Hupan University, the business school he founded, in 2021. Through 2022 he was spotted mostly abroad and lived for long periods in Tokyo, and from May 2023 to October 2024 he was a visiting professor at the University of Tokyo, working on sustainable agriculture and food production.

In January 2023, Ant Group announced that Ma would give up control of the company: his voting rights fell from more than 50% to about 6%, and no single shareholder now holds a controlling stake. Two months later, Ma made his first confirmed public appearance in China in many months, touring a school in Hangzhou, and Alibaba announced a plan to split into six separately run businesses. In July 2023, regulators fined Ant about 7.12 billion yuan, a step widely seen as closing the main phase of the crackdown.

The clearest sign of rehabilitation came on 17 February 2025, when Ma was seen at a symposium of private business leaders chaired by President Xi Jinping in Beijing. State television showed him in the room, though some state media reports left his name out, which kept analysts debating how far his standing had really been restored.

Why the story still matters

For investors and entrepreneurs, the Jack Ma episode became a reference point for how China's leadership treats private wealth. Ma started as an English teacher in Hangzhou, founded Alibaba in his apartment in 1999 with a small group of friends, and became a symbol of the country's rise as a technology power. Within months of one speech, his flagship financial company had lost its listing and his control, and Alibaba had paid a record fine.

A few practical lessons stand out:

  • Absence is not proof of arrest. Rumours that Ma had been detained spread widely but were never confirmed. When a public figure goes quiet, it is worth waiting for reliable reporting before assuming the worst.
  • Regulation and politics overlapped. Concerns about Ant's lending model were genuine and shared by some independent analysts, yet the timing of the crackdown made it impossible to separate from Ma's public criticism.
  • Fortunes on paper can move fast. Ma's personal wealth was estimated at around US$60 billion before the speech and fell sharply as Alibaba's share price dropped, though figures from rich lists vary and change daily.

Today Ma keeps a far lower profile than in his years on global stages, speaking mostly about education, agriculture and the future of technology rather than about regulators.

Sources: The Kathmandu Post/Reuters, 20 January 2021; Wikipedia: Jack Ma; Wikipedia: Ant Group; Wikipedia: Alibaba Group; Wikipedia: 996 working hour system.

COMMENTS