Amal Clooney's Business Case for Putting Human Rights First

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-09.

Amal Clooney Urged Businesses to Put Human Rights on Their Agenda

Amal Clooney at a United Nations Security Council meeting in New York on 21 September 2017. Photo: Mary Altaffer/AP.

Human rights barrister Amal Clooney told business leaders in June 2019 that companies should treat human rights as a core business issue, because employees, shareholders, clients and the public will increasingly hold them to account. Speaking in Barcelona at a conference hosted by the procurement software company SAP Ariba, she admitted that doing the right thing does not always pay off straight away, but argued that it is the more durable path to long-term profit.

Below: what she said, the examples she used, how her argument fits into the wider rules on business and human rights, and what it means in practice for a company of any size.

Who Amal Clooney is

Amal Clooney, born in Beirut in 1978 and raised in the United Kingdom, is a barrister at Doughty Street Chambers in London. She is best known for international criminal and human rights cases, including her long work for Yazidi survivors of Islamic State, such as Nobel Peace Prize laureate Nadia Murad, and for defending journalists, among them Filipino-American journalist Maria Ressa.

In 2016 she and her husband, the actor George Clooney, set up the Clooney Foundation for Justice, which monitors trials and supports legal action for victims of abuses. In 2019 the UK government appointed her as a special envoy on media freedom, a role she left in 2020. Her speech to SAP Ariba came in the same year, when she was being asked to speak to business audiences as well as courts and governments.

The core argument: accountability is coming

As reported by the Thomson Reuters Foundation, Clooney's message to the audience was that firms can no longer treat rights abuses as somebody else's problem. Workers, investors, customers and the wider public are watching how companies behave and where their money goes. She put it this way: "All businesses are in a position where if they don't act, they will be judged by those communities."

She also challenged a comfortable assumption she sees in wealthy democracies: that human rights violations happen to distant people with little connection to everyday life in the West. Supply chains, investments and partnerships, she argued, link ordinary businesses to those abuses far more closely than many executives assume.

She was candid about the trade-off. Doing the right thing, she said, will not always increase profit in the short term. To illustrate that, she recalled a meeting with former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, who had asked major pharmaceutical companies to lower the prices of medicines so that poor patients could afford them, a request that clashed with short-term commercial interests.

The Khashoggi example

Her clearest example of business consequences came from Saudi Arabia. In October 2018 the Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi was murdered inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul by agents of the Saudi state. In the weeks that followed, many senior executives and Western government officials pulled out of a high-profile investment conference in Riyadh, often called "Davos in the desert".

Clooney used the withdrawals to show that reputational risk is real: when a government is linked to a grave abuse, companies may decide that being seen with it costs more than the deal is worth. Two details are often garbled when this story is retold: the killing happened at the Saudi consulate, not the embassy, and the commercial damage is easier to show through those boycotts than through any precise figure in billions.

The business case she made

Clooney did not argue only from morality. She pointed to practical gains, especially in hiring. Companies that recruit and promote a more diverse workforce, including more women in leadership, are better placed to attract the best talent, which she said is likely to improve results over time.

Her closing line tied the moral and commercial arguments together: "Ultimately if businesses believe that doing good can be profitable, then doing good will be sustainable." In other words, ethics that depend only on goodwill tend to fade in a downturn; ethics that are built into how a company earns money are more likely to last.

Is the "doing good pays" argument enough?

Many human rights advocates welcome speeches like this but doubt that persuasion alone changes corporate behaviour. Their view is that voluntary pledges need to be backed by law: penalties for companies that knowingly profit from forced labour or abuse, mandatory reporting, and the possibility of prosecution or civil claims.

The policy world has been moving in that direction. In 2011 the UN Human Rights Council unanimously endorsed the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, drafted under Harvard professor John Ruggie. They rest on three pillars:

  • Protect: governments must protect people from abuses, including abuses by companies.
  • Respect: businesses have a responsibility to respect human rights, which means avoiding harm and dealing with the harm they cause or contribute to.
  • Remedy: victims need real access to remedies, through courts or other channels.

The Guiding Principles ask companies to carry out human rights due diligence: to identify where their operations, suppliers and partners could harm people, act on what they find and report on it. Several countries, and later the European Union, have turned versions of this idea into legal duties for larger firms. Clooney's argument and the legal route are not rivals; the first explains why a company should care, the second makes sure it does.

What this looks like inside a company

For a manager or small-business owner, "put human rights first" can sound abstract. In practice it often comes down to a few concrete questions:

  • Who makes the products or materials we buy, and under what working conditions?
  • Do our partners, clients or investors have links to governments or groups credibly accused of serious abuses?
  • Are our own staff paid fairly, safe at work and able to raise concerns without fear?
  • When someone reports a problem, who reviews it, what happens next, and do the affected people get a hearing?

Answering these does not guarantee extra profit next quarter, as Clooney herself acknowledged. What it does is reduce the risk of being caught up in a scandal, losing staff or customers, or facing legal action later.

The work behind the words

Clooney's credibility on this topic comes largely from her legal work. She has represented Yazidi women who were enslaved by Islamic State, and in November 2021 she was part of the legal team when a German court convicted an Islamic State member, Taha al-Jumailly, of genocide against the Yazidis. She has also pursued civil claims on behalf of Yazidi survivors, including a 2023 case against the cement company Lafarge over its dealings in Syria. That case brings her business argument full circle: it seeks to hold a company accountable for alleged links to the very abuses she has spent years documenting.

Sources: Global Citizen / Thomson Reuters Foundation report on the 2019 speech; Wikipedia: Amal Clooney; Wikipedia: Assassination of Jamal Khashoggi; Wikipedia: UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights. Photo: Mary Altaffer/AP.

COMMENTS