Originally published 2021-01-02.

On New Year's Day 2021, people walking near Roma Termini, the Italian capital's main railway station, found hundreds of small dark birds lying dead on pavements and roads. Most of them were starlings. Animal welfare campaigners quickly linked the deaths to the loud fireworks and firecrackers set off around midnight, even though Rome had banned private displays and a Covid-19 curfew was in force. No official post-mortem result was widely published, so the exact cause was never firmly established. What we can say is that sudden, very loud explosions near a crowded winter roost are a well-documented way to send thousands of birds into a panicked night flight, and that panic can kill.
Below we look at what was reported in Rome, why starlings gather there in such numbers, what scientists have learned about fireworks and birds since then, and what towns can do to reduce the risk.
What was found in Rome on 1 January 2021
Footage filmed that morning and shared widely online showed dozens of birds scattered along a street close to Termini, in a leafy part of the city where large flocks roost in the trees through the winter. Press reports, including an Associated Press story carried by Euronews, described the number as "hundreds". No precise count was given, and some of the birds may have been cleared before reporters arrived.
The timing was what made the scene so striking. The city had banned personal fireworks displays, and Italy was under a 10 pm curfew because of the pandemic. Even so, residents reported a particularly noisy night, with powerful firecrackers going off from balconies and streets for a long time after midnight. The person filming one of the videos could be heard expressing disgust at the scale of the loss.
(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)
Why animal groups blamed the fireworks
The International Organization for the Protection of Animals (OIPA), a charity with a strong presence in Italy, called the deaths a "massacre" and asked for a ban on selling fireworks and firecrackers for private use. Its spokeswoman Loredana Diglio offered several ways the noise could have killed the birds:
"It can be that they died from fear. They can fly up together and knock against each other, or hit windows or electric power lines."
She also suggested that some may have suffered heart failure. Each of these is a plausible mechanism. Starlings roost packed tightly together. When a sudden bang startles one, the whole roost tends to lift off at once, in darkness, into a sky full of light flashes and smoke. Birds that cannot see well at night are then flying blind among buildings, cables and each other. Collisions with hard surfaces leave the kind of blunt injuries that are typical of panic flights.
The counterargument: how unusual is it?
Not every bird organisation agreed that fireworks were the obvious answer. The UK's Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) responded to the Rome reports by repeating its long-standing position: that there is little evidence fireworks harm wild bird populations or their conservation status, and that the effect of a display is broadly similar to a thunderstorm. It still urged organisers to keep rockets away from nature reserves and from places where birds nest or roost, because disturbance there is a real concern.
The two views are less contradictory than they first seem. The RSPB was talking about population-level harm, meaning whether fireworks reduce the number of birds of a species across a country. OIPA was talking about one roost on one night. A few hundred starlings dying in a city street is shocking to see, but it does not threaten the species, which the IUCN rates as Least Concern with a global population estimated in the hundreds of millions. Both things can be true: fireworks can kill birds locally while having little measurable effect on the species as a whole.
It is also fair to keep other causes on the table until tests rule them out. Mass bird deaths can result from poisoning, disease, severe weather, or collisions unrelated to noise. Without published necropsy results, the Rome case remains a strong suspicion rather than a proven cause.
A familiar pattern: Beebe, Arkansas
Rome was not the first place where birds fell from the sky on New Year's Eve. Just before midnight on 31 December 2010, residents of Beebe, a small town in Arkansas, reported that thousands of red-winged blackbirds and starlings were dropping onto roofs and streets across an area of about a mile. The event drew worldwide headlines and wild theories.
After examining the birds, the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission concluded on 5 January 2011 that a resident had set off professional-grade fireworks near a large roost. The explosions startled the birds into a panic flight in the dark, and they died from the resulting trauma. Before that conclusion, an ornithologist had also floated lightning and high-altitude hail as possible explanations, which shows how easily such events invite speculation.
The Beebe case matters for Rome because it shows the mechanism campaigners described is real and has been confirmed by an official investigation elsewhere.
What research shows about fireworks and birds
The best large-scale evidence came after the Rome incident. In December 2023, a team led by Bart Hoekstra and Judy Shamoun-Baranes at the University of Amsterdam published a study in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment. They combined Dutch weather radar data with bird counts gathered by volunteers to compare New Year's Eve with ordinary winter nights.
The results were striking:
- Near fireworks, roughly a thousand times more birds were in the air than on a normal night, with peaks far higher still.
- In the two radar study areas, almost 400,000 birds took off immediately after the fireworks started.
- The effect was strongest within about 5 km of the fireworks, and still clear up to 10 km away.
- Larger birds such as geese, ducks and gulls climbed hundreds of metres and stayed airborne for up to an hour.
Sudden flight in cold weather costs birds energy they need to survive winter, and flying in darkness raises the risk of disorientation and accidents. The study did not count deaths, but it shows that the disturbance is massive and widespread, not limited to a few unlucky roosts.
What cities and individuals can do
Banning private fireworks on paper did not stop the noise in Rome, which points to enforcement as part of the problem. The Dutch researchers suggested several practical steps that would reduce harm without cancelling celebrations:
- Fireworks-free zones around wetlands, parks and known roosts, with larger buffers in open landscapes where sound carries further.
- Central, organised displays in built-up areas, as far as possible from where birds sleep, instead of scattered private fireworks across a whole city.
- Quieter alternatives such as drone light shows or low-noise decorative fireworks.
For individuals, the simplest rule is distance. If you know a tree, park or riverbank where starlings or other birds gather at dusk, do not set off firecrackers nearby. If you find injured birds after a celebration, contact a local wildlife rescue centre rather than trying to treat them yourself, and avoid handling dead birds with bare hands.
Starlings in Rome: a winter spectacle
The sad scene at Termini is the flip side of one of Rome's best-loved natural sights. Each winter, very large flocks of starlings spend the night in the city's trees and perform swirling evening displays known as murmurations. These shape-shifting clouds, in which each bird reacts to its nearest neighbours, are thought to help protect the flock from falcons and hawks. Cities offer warmth, light and shelter, which is why starling roosts in urban centres can number in the hundreds of thousands or more.
The same dense packing that makes a murmuration so beautiful also makes a roost vulnerable when something frightens it in the dark. Remembering that may be the most useful lesson from Rome: celebrations and wildlife can share a city, as long as the loudest moments happen away from where the birds sleep.
Sources: Euronews / AP: Hundreds of birds found dead in Rome's streets after New Year fireworks (1 January 2021); Veterinary Nurse online: Hundreds of birds found dead in Rome (RSPB statement); Wikipedia: Beebe, Arkansas; University of Amsterdam: Millions of birds lose precious energy due to fireworks on New Year's Eve (2023); Wikipedia: Common starling.

COMMENTS