Argentina Legalises Abortion up to 14 Weeks: The 2020 Law Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-02.

Argentina legalised abortion on request up to the 14th week of pregnancy when its Senate approved the Voluntary Termination of Pregnancy bill in the early hours of 30 December 2020, by 38 votes to 29 with one abstention. After 14 weeks, abortion remains legal when a pregnancy results from rape or puts the woman's life or health at risk. President Alberto Fernández, who had sent the bill to Congress, signed it into law as Law 27,610 on 14 January 2021, and it took effect on 24 January. The vote made Argentina the largest country in Latin America at the time to allow elective abortion, and it became a turning point for the region's "green wave" movement.

Argentina's Abortion-Law Reform Reported in 2021

What the law allows

The core of Law 27,610 is simple: during the first 14 weeks of pregnancy, a woman or pregnant person can request an abortion without giving a reason, and the public health system must provide it free of charge. The law also sets time limits so that requests are not delayed until the window closes.

After 14 weeks, the older grounds still apply: rape, or a risk to the life or health of the pregnant person. Doctors who object on grounds of conscience may decline to take part, but they must refer the patient promptly to another professional or facility. Alongside the abortion law, Congress passed a companion "1,000 days" plan to support pregnant women and children in their first years, meant to make sure that those who continue a pregnancy also get help.

Laws describe rights, not individual situations. Anyone facing a pregnancy decision should talk to a doctor or local health service for advice that fits their own circumstances.

A century of restriction

Argentina's previous rules came from its 1921 Penal Code. Abortion was a crime for both the woman and anyone who performed it, with two exceptions: to avoid a serious danger to the woman's life or health, and in cases of rape involving a woman with a mental disability. For decades even those narrow exceptions were applied unevenly, and many women were turned away.

In 2012 the Supreme Court clarified, in a case known as the F.A.L. ruling, that abortion was legal after any rape, that a sworn statement from the woman was enough, and that provinces should adopt protocols to provide it. Access still varied widely from province to province.

The human cost of clandestine abortion was the strongest argument for change. Government estimates cited at the time put the number of women who had died from unsafe abortions since the return of democracy in 1983 at more than 3,000, with hundreds of thousands of secret procedures over the same period. Argentina had been ruled by a military dictatorship from 1976 until that 1983 transition. Research has also shown that deaths were concentrated among poorer women, especially in the northern provinces.

The green wave

The campaign behind the law is known for its symbol: a green triangular scarf. Activists began using green bandanas in 2003, inspired by the white headscarves of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, who protested the disappearances of their children during the dictatorship. Over the following years the green scarf became the emblem of the National Campaign for the Right to Legal, Safe and Free Abortion.

The movement grew enormously after 2015, when mass marches under the slogan Ni Una Menos ("Not one less") protested against violence and murders of women. In 2018 a legalisation bill passed the Chamber of Deputies by 129 votes to 125 but was defeated in the Senate by 38 votes to 31. Opponents adopted a sky-blue scarf as their own symbol, and the two colours have defined the debate ever since.

Fernández campaigned on bringing the bill back. His plan to present it in March 2020 was delayed by the pandemic, and after pressure from feminist groups the government sent it to Congress in November 2020.

The vote and the arguments on each side

The Chamber of Deputies approved the bill on 11 December 2020 by 131 votes to 117, with six abstentions. The Senate debate lasted more than 13 hours, while crowds in green and in sky blue kept vigil outside Congress in Buenos Aires. When the result came, supporters celebrated in the streets through the night.

Fernández wrote on Twitter that Argentina was "a better society, which widens women's rights and guarantees public health." Vilma Ibarra, the legal secretary who had drafted the bill, said there would never again be a woman killed in a clandestine abortion.

Opponents, including the Catholic Church and evangelical groups, argued that the law ended a developing human life and that the state should instead support women to continue their pregnancies. Senator Inés Blas, who voted against the bill, described ending a pregnancy as a tragedy. Pope Francis, himself Argentine, had spoken out against the bill shortly before the vote. The debate cut across party lines, with senators from both the governing coalition and the opposition voting on each side.

How the law has worked since

Implementation has been gradual and uneven. According to the Ministry of Health, the public system recorded 96,664 abortions in 2022, the first full year under the law. Advocates point to that figure as evidence that procedures moved out of hiding and into the health system; critics say it shows how many pregnancies are now ended.

Access still depends heavily on where someone lives, and conscientious objection is more common in some provinces than others. Politically, the issue has not gone away. After Javier Milei, an outspoken opponent of abortion, became president in December 2023, a deputy from his party introduced a bill in February 2024 to repeal the law, but it did not win support even within her own party, and the 2020 law remains in force.

Argentina and the rest of Latin America

When the law passed, elective abortion was legal in only a handful of places in Latin America: Cuba, Uruguay, Guyana, Puerto Rico and Mexico City. Argentina joined that group, and its success inspired campaigners elsewhere, who adopted the green scarf as their own.

The wave did spread. Colombia's Constitutional Court decriminalised abortion up to 24 weeks in February 2022, and in September 2023 Mexico's Supreme Court ordered abortion removed from the federal penal code. Elsewhere change has been slower: Chile and Brazil continue to debate the issue, while El Salvador and Nicaragua still ban abortion in all circumstances, even when a pregnancy results from rape or threatens the woman's life.

Whatever one's view, the Argentine vote of December 2020 is one of the defining moments in the region's recent history, the result of decades of organising and of a public debate that changed how an entire country talks about women's health.

Sources: Wikipedia: Abortion in Argentina; Wikipedia: Green Wave (abortion rights); Global Voices, 31 December 2020: Argentina closes 2020 with historic Senate vote legalizing abortion; SBS News / AFP, 15 January 2021: Argentina officially legalises abortion; original reporting by the BBC.

COMMENTS