Face Masks in the Ocean: The 1.56 Billion Estimate Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2021-01-05.

Group Estimates 1.56 Billion Face Masks Entered the Oceans in 2020

In December 2020 the Hong Kong marine conservation group OceansAsia estimated that about 1.56 billion disposable face masks ended up in the world’s oceans during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic. That number is not a count of masks pulled from the sea. It is a model: roughly 52 billion masks were thought to have been made worldwide in 2020, and the group assumed that a conservative 3% of them escaped bins and waste systems and reached the coast.

Because a typical single-use surgical mask weighs 3 to 4 grams, the report put the extra burden at around 4,680 to 6,240 tonnes of plastic. Masks are mostly polypropylene, and the group warned they could take up to 450 years to break down. Below we look at how the estimate was built, why discarded masks matter for wildlife, how the figure compares with the wider plastic problem, and what actually helps.

Where the 1.56 billion figure comes from

The report, titled Masks on the Beach: The Impact of COVID-19 on Marine Plastic Pollution, was published on 7 December 2020. Its lead author was Dr. Teale Phelps Bondaroff, OceansAsia’s director of research. The arithmetic is simple and transparent, which is a strength: production estimate multiplied by a loss rate, then multiplied by the weight of a single mask.

That simplicity also means the result is only as good as its inputs. Global mask production in 2020 was itself an estimate, and leakage rates differ enormously between a country with closed landfills and regular street cleaning and one where waste is dumped or burned in the open. A 3% loss rate is borrowed from wider studies of how much plastic escapes waste systems. The honest way to read the headline is “around one and a half billion, give or take a lot,” not as a precise tally.

Even so, the order of magnitude matched what clean-up crews were seeing. OceansAsia had begun finding masks on the beaches of the Soko Islands, south of Lantau in Hong Kong, early in 2020, only weeks after mask wearing became widespread there.

Why a discarded mask is a problem at sea

A disposable mask looks harmless, but it combines several of the features that make plastic litter dangerous:

  • Entanglement. The elastic ear loops can wrap around the legs, wings or beaks of birds and the limbs of small animals. Wildlife rescue groups in several countries reported cases of birds caught in mask straps during 2020 and 2021. Cutting the loops before throwing a mask away is a small habit that removes this risk.
  • Ingestion. Turtles, fish and seabirds can mistake floating plastic for food. A soft, pale mask drifting in the water can resemble a jellyfish. Swallowed plastic can block the gut or leave an animal feeling full while it starves.
  • Microplastics. Sunlight, waves and abrasion slowly shred the layered fabric into fibres and fragments smaller than 5 millimetres. These microplastics are almost impossible to recover and can be eaten by plankton and filter feeders at the base of the food web.

Speaking to reporters when the study came out, Phelps Bondaroff explained that clean-up teams were already finding masks that had started to fall apart, which suggested they were becoming a fresh source of microplastics. He added that the masks entering the sea in 2020 would stay there “for the long run.”

Older versions of this story claimed that mask plastic can alter the DNA of marine animals. We could not find reliable evidence for that specific claim, so we have left it out. The documented harms, entanglement, ingestion and microplastic pollution, are serious enough on their own.

Masks in context: the wider ocean plastic problem

Put next to the total amount of plastic in the sea, a few thousand tonnes of masks is a small slice. Estimates of plastic already in the oceans vary widely, from about 86 million tonnes to more than 150 million tonnes, and every author admits the true figure is impossible to know exactly. Each year roughly 8 to 12 million tonnes more is thought to enter the sea, mostly from land: rivers, poorly managed dumps, storm drains and litter. Fishing gear and shipping add a significant share.

The often-quoted warning that by 2050 the oceans could hold more plastic than fish by weight comes from a 2016 projection popularised by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and repeated at the 2017 UN Ocean Conference. It is a scenario based on current trends continuing, not a measured fact, and some scientists have questioned it because the total weight of fish in the sea is itself very uncertain. It is best read as a vivid way of saying that plastic leakage is growing faster than the ocean can absorb it.

Why do masks deserve attention, then? Because they were a sudden new stream of litter created in a matter of months, they are designed to be thrown away after a few hours of use, and they turned up in places, from city pavements to remote beaches, where people could see the problem with their own eyes. They also stand for the broader surge in single-use plastic during the pandemic: gloves, takeaway containers, test kits and packaging.

Masks did their job: this is about disposal, not wearing

None of this is an argument against masks. Health agencies such as the World Health Organization recommended them because COVID-19 spreads mainly through particles breathed out by an infected person, especially in crowded or poorly ventilated rooms. Medical-grade disposable masks remain essential in hospitals and for people at high risk.

The problem the report describes is what happens after a mask is taken off. A mask dropped in a car park can be washed into a drain by the next rainstorm, then carried by a river to the coast. The solution is not to stop protecting people but to make sure protection does not end up in the sea.

What helps: practical steps for individuals

OceansAsia’s own recommendations to the public were straightforward, and they still apply to any disposable item:

  1. Choose reusable cloth masks where they are appropriate, and wash them regularly. For situations where a medical mask or respirator is advised, follow local health guidance; buy from reputable sellers, because poorly made masks may not protect well.
  2. Bin disposable masks properly, ideally in a lidded bin, and never leave them on the ground or in a shopping trolley.
  3. Snip the ear loops before throwing a mask away so that, if it does escape, it cannot trap an animal.
  4. Cut single-use plastic in general. A refillable bottle, a reusable shopping bag and avoiding unnecessary packaging reduce far more plastic over a year than any one change on its own.
  5. Join or support a beach or river clean-up. Clean-ups remove litter, and the records volunteers keep help researchers track what is reaching the coast.

What governments and businesses are doing

The report also called on governments to promote reusable masks, back the development of sustainable alternatives, raise fines for littering and invest in waste collection. More broadly, many countries have moved against single-use plastics. The European Union’s Single-Use Plastics Directive began restricting items such as plastic cutlery, plates, straws and stirrers in 2021, and Canada announced a ban on several single-use plastic items that was phased in from late 2022.

Researchers and manufacturers are also experimenting with masks made from biodegradable or plant-based materials and with recycling schemes that collect used masks and turn the polypropylene into products such as park benches or road material. Most of these are still small in scale. Collection and responsible disposal remain the cheapest and most effective tools available today.

Common myths about masks and ocean plastic

“Masks are now the biggest source of ocean plastic.” No. They are a visible and symbolic new stream, but millions of tonnes a year come from packaging, bottles, bags, fishing gear and other items.

“Plastic masks dissolve in seawater.” They do not dissolve. They fragment into ever smaller pieces that persist for decades or centuries.

“The 1.56 billion figure was counted on beaches.” It is a modelled estimate built from production numbers and an assumed loss rate. Beach surveys support the trend but cannot count every mask at sea.

The lasting lesson of the mask litter of 2020 is a simple one: a product can be life-saving and still harmful if it is thrown away carelessly. Using it well and getting rid of it responsibly are both part of the job.

Sources: OceansAsia: Masks on the Beach report (2020); The Denver Channel: interview with Teale Phelps Bondaroff; Wikipedia: Ocean plastic pollution; WHO: How is COVID-19 transmitted?.

COMMENTS