Originally published 2020-12-30.

Trophy Leaks: Top Hunters and Industry Secrets is a 2020 book by Eduardo Gonçalves, founder of the UK-based Campaign to Ban Trophy Hunting. Its headline claim is that trophy hunters took around 1.7 million animals in a decade, and that the industry behind them is wealthy, well organised and politically influential. The 1.7 million figure is real, but it comes from an earlier study of international trade records, and it measures something slightly different from what many headlines suggested.
This guide explains what the book argues, where its numbers come from, how they should be read, and what the wider debate about trophy hunting and wildlife decline looks like.
What the book claims
Gonçalves, a British campaigner and former journalist, set up the Campaign to Ban Trophy Hunting to stop hunters, especially British ones, from bringing home body parts of animals they have shot abroad. In Trophy Leaks he describes trophy hunting as a global business in which wealthy foreigners pay large fees to shoot animals, mainly in Africa but also in Asia and elsewhere.
The book's main claims, as reported when it came out in December 2020, were:
- around 1.7 million trophies were taken by hunters over roughly a decade;
- the trade is worth as much as $400 million a year, by the author's estimate;
- lions, elephants, rhinos, leopards and many bird species are among the animals killed in large numbers;
- pro-hunting groups run well-funded lobbying and social media campaigns to resist import bans;
- hunting advocates gave around $2 million to Donald Trump's presidential campaign, a figure the book presents but which we could not confirm independently.
In an interview with the British press, Gonçalves described trophy hunting not as the work of a few individuals but as a powerful global industry able to influence governments.
Where the 1.7 million figure comes from
The number matches a June 2016 report by the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) called Killing for Trophies. It analysed the trade database of CITES, the international convention that regulates trade in endangered species, and estimated that as many as 1.7 million hunting trophies may have been traded between countries from 2004 to 2014. At least 200,000 of those came from species classed as threatened.
Two points matter when reading this figure:
- It counts trophies crossing borders, not every animal killed. Hunts where the trophy stays in the country, or species not listed by CITES, are not included. Equally, one animal can produce more than one traded item, so the records do not map perfectly onto individual animals.
- It covers 2004 to 2014. The data predates the book by several years, so it describes the decade before publication rather than the years immediately leading up to 2020.
"One every three minutes": checking the maths
Some headlines said an endangered animal is killed by a trophy hunter every three minutes. Spread over eleven years, 1.7 million trophies work out at roughly 420 a day, or about one every three and a half minutes. That rate applies to all traded trophies, not just threatened species. For the 200,000 threatened-species trophies, the rate is closer to 50 a day, or about one every half hour. Still a striking number, but a different one, and it is worth being precise when the subject is this serious.
How trophy hunting works
Trophy hunting means hunting animals mainly for sport, keeping a part of the animal, such as the head, skin, horns or tusks, to display. Hunters usually target mature males with the biggest horns, manes or tusks. Hunts are sold as packages through outfitters and game ranches, with fees depending on the species.
The so-called "Big Five", a term from the colonial era, are the lion, leopard, African elephant, Cape buffalo and rhinoceros. They were seen as the most dangerous animals to hunt on foot, and collecting all five is still regarded by some hunters as the ultimate achievement.
The industry received worldwide attention in 2015, when Cecil, a well-known lion in Zimbabwe's Hwange National Park, was killed by an American dentist after being lured out of the park. The outcry led several airlines to stop carrying hunting trophies. A few years earlier, photos from a hunting trip in Zimbabwe showing Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump with animals they had shot, including a leopard, caused a similar public backlash.
The argument for and against
The debate is genuinely contested, even among conservationists.
The case made by supporters
Supporters, including some African governments and wildlife agencies, argue that well-regulated hunting pays for conservation. Fees can fund anti-poaching patrols and give rural communities a reason to keep wildlife on their land instead of turning it over to cattle or crops. The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has said that well-managed trophy hunting can create incentives for conservation. Namibia's community conservancies and the recovery of white rhinos in South Africa are often cited as examples.
The case made by critics
Critics question how much money actually reaches local people. Studies by economists and animal welfare groups found that hunting brings in a small share of overall tourism revenue in the countries that allow it, and that communities often see little of it. Removing the biggest males can upset animal social groups; in lions, it can lead to infanticide when new males take over prides. Corruption, poorly set quotas and "canned" hunting of captive-bred lions in South Africa add to the concerns.
Laws vary widely. Kenya has banned sport hunting since 1977. Botswana banned trophy hunting in 2014 and then lifted the ban in 2019. Many countries, including South Africa, Namibia, Zimbabwe and Tanzania, still allow it under quotas.
Import bans and the UK campaign
Much of Gonçalves's campaigning has focused on the United Kingdom. He says British hunters have brought home around 5,000 trophies of CITES-listed animals since the 1980s. A government consultation found that 85% of respondents supported a ban on importing hunting trophies.
A private member's bill to ban imports, the Hunting Trophies (Import Prohibition) Bill, passed every stage in the House of Commons with cross-party support but ran out of time in the House of Lords, and a new attempt followed. Several southern African governments, notably Botswana, have objected, arguing that decisions about their wildlife should be made by them and that bans could hurt the communities that live alongside dangerous animals.
The bigger picture: wildlife decline
Trophy hunting is one pressure on wildlife, but not the biggest. WWF's Living Planet Report 2018 found that monitored populations of mammals, birds, fish, reptiles and amphibians had fallen in size by an average of 60% between 1970 and 2014. That is often misreported as 60% of species being wiped out, which it does not mean: it is an average decline in the size of tracked populations, and some scientists have also questioned how it should be interpreted.
Later editions showed the trend continuing, with an average decline of 69% to 2018 and 73% to 2020 in the 2024 report. The main drivers identified by WWF are habitat loss, mostly from farming, followed by overexploitation, including hunting and fishing, as well as climate change, pollution and invasive species. Releasing the 2018 report, WWF's Mike Barrett warned that we are sleepwalking towards the edge of a cliff
.
For readers who care about these animals, the practical options include supporting reputable conservation groups, choosing wildlife tourism that clearly benefits local communities, avoiding products made from threatened species and following the evidence on both sides of the trophy hunting debate.
Sources: Conservation Action Trust, 14 June 2016: Killing for Trophies, an analysis of global trophy hunting trade (IFAW); Wikipedia: Trophy hunting; Wikipedia: Living Planet Report; Mail & Guardian, 27 January 2024: UK to vote on banning hunting trophy imports; Daily Mail, December 2020 (original report).

COMMENTS