Originally published 2020-12-29.

In December 2020 Pakistan's President Arif Alvi signed the Anti-Rape (Investigation and Trial) Ordinance 2020. It promised special courts, trials finished within four months, the country's first national register of sex offenders and, most controversially, chemical castration for some convicted rapists. The castration clause drew worldwide attention, and less than a year later, as the government turned the ordinance into a permanent law, it was reported to have been dropped.
This guide explains what the ordinance set out to do, why it was introduced, how chemical castration works, and what changed when parliament took up the bill in November 2021.
What the ordinance introduced
An ordinance in Pakistan is a temporary law issued by the President when parliament is not passing legislation on a subject. It lapses unless parliament replaces it. The December 2020 ordinance covered several areas:
- Speed. Rape trials were to be completed within four months, through special courts.
- A national register. For the first time, Pakistan would keep a database of convicted sex offenders.
- Chemical castration. Judges could order it for certain offenders, reportedly without the offender's consent.
Human-rights lawyers worried that fast-track trials in an overstretched system could produce wrongful convictions that would be hard to undo. Others welcomed any attempt to cut the years that rape cases often take in Pakistani courts, where many convictions are later overturned on appeal.
Why Pakistan acted in 2020
The trigger was a crime that shocked the country. In September 2020 a woman whose car had broken down on a motorway near Lahore at night was gang-raped in front of her children. Protests spread across Pakistan, and many people demanded tougher punishment. The two attackers were later sentenced to death, though they appealed.
Sexual violence against women and children is under-reported in Pakistan because of stigma and fear, and campaigners had long argued that police and courts failed survivors. The ordinance was the government's answer to that pressure.
From public hanging to castration
Prime Minister Imran Khan had first reached for an even harsher idea. In a television interview in September 2020 he said he believed rapists and child molesters "should be hanged publicly." He acknowledged in the same interview that public executions would breach international human-rights commitments and could damage Pakistan's trade relations with the European Union and other partners. Chemical castration was presented as an alternative.
The idea of public hanging had divided Khan's own government before. In February 2020 the National Assembly passed a resolution calling for public executions of people convicted of child sexual abuse and murder. Fawad Chaudhry, then federal minister for science and technology, condemned it on X as an expression of extremism.
Strongly condemn this resolution this is just another grave act in line with brutal civilisation practices, societies act in a balanced way barberiaism is not answer to crimes...... this is another expression of extremism pic.twitter.com/ye2abes8Dc
— Ch Fawad Hussain (@fawadchaudhry) February 7, 2020
How chemical castration works
Despite the name, chemical castration involves no surgery. Doctors give drugs that sharply reduce testosterone, which usually lowers sex drive. The medicines used include medroxyprogesterone acetate, cyproterone acetate and LHRH agonists such as leuprolide.
The effects are generally reversible when treatment stops, but long courses can cause lasting harm. Reported side effects include depression, hot flashes, loss of bone density, weight gain, anaemia, a higher risk of heart disease and, after several years, possible infertility. In voluntary treatment, doctors weigh these risks against the benefits. Imposed as a punishment, they raise serious medical-ethics questions, which is why many doctors' organisations oppose forced use.
Does it reduce reoffending?
The evidence is thinner than the headlines suggest. Some small studies found that men who received anti-androgen drugs reported fewer deviant urges, especially when medication was combined with therapy. But most studies involve volunteers, who are already motivated to change, and critics point out that this makes the results hard to apply to people forced into treatment.
Rape is also not driven by sex drive alone. Researchers stress the role of power, anger and opportunity, which hormones do not address. For that reason, many specialists see chemical treatment, at best, as one part of supervised therapy, not a stand-alone punishment.
Where else it is used
Pakistan was not alone in turning to this option. California became the first US state to authorise chemical castration in 1996, for repeat child molesters on parole. Florida, Montana, Iowa, Wisconsin, Louisiana and Alabama (in 2019) followed. Georgia and Oregon later repealed their programmes. Texas, often included in such lists, has instead had a law on voluntary surgical castration. In practice US courts have rarely used it: Florida reportedly ordered it in only a handful of cases.
Outside the US, Poland introduced compulsory chemical castration for some child abusers in 2010, South Korea passed a law in 2011, and Indonesia approved it in 2016. Russia, Moldova and Estonia also have or have had programmes.
What changed in 2021
In November 2021 the government rushed dozens of bills, including a permanent anti-rape law, through a joint session of parliament. Several media outlets first reported that chemical castration had become law. On 19 November, however, Maleeka Bukhari of the ruling PTI party said the clause had been removed before the vote, after the Council of Islamic Ideology, a state advisory body of clerics, said such a punishment was against Islam. She added that it would also have conflicted with the constitution. Some summaries still describe the punishment as part of the final law, so readers will find conflicting accounts; the government's own statement was that it had been dropped.
The faster trials, special courts and national register stayed at the heart of the reform. Whether they deliver justice depends on what campaigners have asked for all along: trained police, protected witnesses, prompt forensic testing and courts that treat survivors with respect.
Sources: Gulf Today / Associated Press, Wikipedia: Chemical castration.

COMMENTS