Trump's 2020 Election Lawsuits: What He Claimed and How They Ended

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-05.

Trump's Legal Challenges After the 2020 US Election

Photo: BBC, Getty Images/Twitter/Facebook

In the days after the 3 November 2020 election, Donald Trump's campaign went to court in several swing states while late-counted mail ballots steadily turned his early leads into a win for Joe Biden. The short answer to how it ended: the lawsuits failed. More than sixty cases were filed, almost all were dropped or dismissed, and Biden won 306 electoral votes to Trump's 232, with roughly seven million more votes nationwide.

This page walks through what the campaign asked the courts for, why the count moved the way it did, and how those challenges played out between election week and the certification of the result in January 2021.

Where the race stood in election week

By Thursday 5 November, the contest had narrowed to a handful of states that were still counting: Pennsylvania, Georgia, Nevada and Arizona. Michigan and Wisconsin had already been projected for Biden. Trump needed to hold almost all of the remaining states to reach 270 electoral votes, and the ballots still to be counted came mostly from mail voters, who in 2020 leaned heavily Democratic.

Pennsylvania alone still had a very large pile of mail ballots to process, many from Philadelphia and its suburbs. Nationally, Biden was already several million votes ahead in the popular count, and that gap kept growing as California and other large states finished their tallies.

Biden did not declare victory that week. Speaking in Wilmington, Delaware, he struck a cautious tone and said, "When the count is finished, we believe we will be the winners." The major news organisations projected him as the winner on the morning of Saturday 7 November, once Pennsylvania's count put him clearly ahead.

Why early leads melted away

Much of the confusion in election week came from the order in which votes were counted. During the pandemic, the Democratic Party pushed its supporters to vote early or by post, while Trump repeatedly told his voters to turn up in person on election day. That split the electorate by voting method as well as by party.

In several key states, notably Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan, election officials were not allowed to start processing mail ballots until election day or very close to it. Same-day, in-person votes were therefore reported first, giving Trump large early margins. As the postal ballots were opened and added over the following days, those margins shrank and then reversed. Analysts had a name for this before the vote: the "red mirage".

Trump described the shift differently. On social media he wrote that his leads had begun to "magically disappear" as "surprise ballot dumps" were counted. Twitter put a warning label on the post and hid it behind a notice. In practice, a "dump" was simply a batch of legally cast mail ballots being reported at once, which is how counties normally release results.

The pattern had been predicted. In an October appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon, Senator Bernie Sanders laid out almost exactly this scenario: Trump ahead on election night, mail ballots narrowing the gap, and the president then calling the process fraudulent.

What the Trump campaign asked the courts for

The legal push in election week had several strands, and they were not all the same kind of claim.

Observer access in Pennsylvania

The campaign argued that its poll watchers in Philadelphia were being kept too far from the tables where ballots were processed to see anything meaningful. It asked for counting to pause until observers had better access. A state court did order observers to be allowed closer, but counting continued, and the wider effort to stop or throw out ballots did not succeed.

Stopping or pausing counts

In Michigan and Georgia, the campaign filed suits seeking to halt counting or to separate certain ballots. A Michigan judge dismissed a request to stop the count, noting that it had largely finished by the time the case was heard. In Georgia, a case over a small number of ballots in Chatham County was thrown out after a hearing.

Claims of illegal voters in Nevada

In Nevada, Republicans alleged that thousands of people who no longer lived in the state had cast ballots there. Election officials and reporters who checked the lists found that many of the people flagged were legitimate voters, such as military members or students living temporarily elsewhere, who remain eligible to vote in their home state. All the post-election suits in Nevada were later dismissed or dropped.

Recounts

The campaign also signalled it would seek recounts in close states. A recount is a normal legal option when margins are thin, and it is not the same as a fraud claim. Wisconsin carried out a partial recount in Milwaukee and Dane counties, paid for by the campaign, which slightly increased Biden's lead. Georgia's full hand count of paper ballots, part of a statewide audit, also confirmed Biden as the winner.

How the court challenges ended

Over the following weeks, the effort grew into more than sixty lawsuits across nine states and Washington, D.C., brought by the campaign and its allies. By mid-December, more than fifty had been dismissed or withdrawn. Around thirty were dismissed after judges looked at the merits, often with sharp comments about the lack of evidence.

The campaign won only one early ruling of note, over the deadline for Pennsylvania voters to fix missing identification on mail ballots. It affected very few votes and was later overturned by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.

The most high-profile attempt, Texas v. Pennsylvania, asked the US Supreme Court to block the results in four states. On 11 December 2020 the court refused to hear it, saying Texas lacked standing to challenge how other states run their elections. The Electoral College voted on 14 December, and Biden received 306 votes.

Federal officials responsible for election security also pushed back. In mid-November, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency and its partners in state election offices issued a joint statement calling 2020 the most secure election in the country's history and saying there was no evidence that votes had been lost, changed or compromised.

Protests, certification and 6 January

In election week itself, small groups of supporters of both candidates gathered outside counting centres in Michigan, Pennsylvania and Arizona. Most of these gatherings stayed peaceful, though some were tense, with chants of "stop the count" in some places and "count every vote" in others.

The dispute did not end with the courts. On 6 January 2021, as Congress met to count the electoral votes, a crowd of Trump supporters stormed the US Capitol and forced lawmakers to evacuate. The joint session resumed later that night, rejected objections to the results from Arizona and Pennsylvania, and confirmed Biden's victory in the early hours of 7 January.

The final figures were clear. Biden received about 81.3 million votes, or 51.3 percent, against Trump's 74.2 million, or 46.8 percent. Turnout, at about two-thirds of eligible voters, was the highest in more than a century.

What this episode shows about election disputes

A few lessons stand out for anyone trying to follow a contested count, in the US or elsewhere.

  • Filing a lawsuit is not proof. Anyone can bring a case. What matters is the remedy requested and what the judge actually decides.
  • Counting order shapes the story. When different kinds of ballots are counted at different times, early leads can be misleading in either direction.
  • Recounts rarely change much. In modern US elections, recounts typically shift results by a few hundred votes at most, far below the margins in 2020.
  • Check the final record. Court dockets, certified state results and official canvass reports give a more reliable picture than claims made on the night.

The 2020 cases are now one of the most thoroughly documented sets of election lawsuits in American history, and the outcome they produced was the same as the vote count: Biden won.

Sources: Wikipedia: Post-election lawsuits related to the 2020 United States presidential election; Wikipedia: 2020 United States presidential election; Al Jazeera, 7 January 2021: US Congress certifies Joe Biden as next president. Photo: BBC, Getty Images/Twitter/Facebook.

COMMENTS