Macron After the Vienna Attack: “This Is Our Europe”

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-11-03.

Macron After the Vienna Attack: “This Is Our Europe”

On the evening of 2 November 2020, a gunman opened fire in the centre of Vienna, killing four people and wounding 23 before police shot him dead. Within hours, French President Emmanuel Macron posted a message of solidarity with Austria in French, German and English. Its most quoted line was short and defiant: “This is our Europe.” He added that Europe's enemies must know who they were dealing with and that “we will not give up anything.”

The words carried extra weight because France itself had just suffered a series of violent attacks. This article sets out what happened in Vienna, why Macron's message resonated, how some of the early reporting turned out to be wrong, and what followed.

What happened in Vienna

The attack began just before 8 pm in the Innere Stadt, Vienna's historic centre, near Seitenstettengasse, the street that is home to the city's main synagogue. Bars and restaurants were busy because a national COVID-19 lockdown was due to start at midnight, and many people had gone out for a last evening.

The attacker, armed with a rifle, a handgun and a machete, fired about 80 rounds over roughly nine minutes. Police shot him in the courtyard of St Rupert's Church. Four people died, among them a 24-year-old German woman and a 44-year-old Austrian woman, and 23 were injured, seven of them critically, including a police officer.

“This is our Europe”: Macron's message and other reactions

Macron's post, reproduced below in its German version, expressed France's shock and grief and pointed out that after France, a friendly country had now been attacked. Its message was that an attack on one European democracy was an attack on a shared way of life.

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen also offered Europe's full solidarity with Austria, calling the attack brutal and declaring that Europe was stronger than hatred and terror.

Leaders across the continent and beyond sent similar messages. Austria's chancellor at the time, Sebastian Kurz, called it a repugnant terrorist attack and stressed that the enemy was extremism, not any religion or nationality.

Early reports versus what investigators found

In the confusion of the first night, police and media reported that several gunmen might be on the loose, and residents were told to stay indoors. That fear proved unfounded. Investigators later said there was no sign of an accomplice at the scene: the shooting had been carried out by one man.

He was Kujtim Fejzulai, a 20-year-old with Austrian and North Macedonian citizenship. In April 2019 he had been sentenced to 22 months in prison for trying to travel to Syria to join the Islamic State group, but he was released on parole in December 2019 after serving about eight months. He had taken part in a deradicalisation programme. According to the record of the attack, Slovak police had earlier warned Austria that he had tried to buy ammunition in Bratislava. The Islamic State group claimed responsibility the next day.

The missed warnings caused a political storm in Austria, prompting a review of how its domestic intelligence service handled the case and a reorganisation of the agency.

Why the message resonated in France

Macron's words came at the end of a painful few weeks for France.

  • 16 October 2020: the history teacher Samuel Paty was murdered and beheaded near his school in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine by an 18-year-old of Chechen origin who had refugee status in France. Paty had shown cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad in a lesson on freedom of expression, after which an online campaign targeted him.
  • 29 October 2020: a 21-year-old Tunisian man killed three people with a knife inside the Notre-Dame basilica in Nice. He was sentenced to life imprisonment without parole in February 2025.

A third incident is often wrongly grouped with these. On 31 October 2020 a Greek Orthodox priest, Nikolaos Kakavelakis, was shot outside his church in Lyon. Early fears that it was another terrorist attack were not borne out: anti-terrorism prosecutors did not take the case, and according to reporting a week later, the suspect told prosecutors the shooting stemmed from a personal dispute. The priest survived after surgery.

After Paty's murder, Macron gave a speech at the Sorbonne in which he defended the right to publish cartoons and called the killing an Islamist terrorist attack. He had also announced plans to fight what he called “Islamist separatism” in France. These positions drew anger in parts of the Muslim world, calls to boycott French goods, and a public clash with Turkey's President Erdoğan.

The online backlash and Mahathir's remarks

The tension spilled onto social media. On 29 October, after the Nice attack, Malaysia's former prime minister Mahathir Mohamad wrote on his blog and Twitter that Muslims had a right to be angry and to kill millions of French people for past massacres. Twitter removed the post for glorifying violence and Facebook took down the full text. Mahathir said he had been quoted out of context, pointing to his next sentence, which argued that Muslims had generally not sought revenge, according to the Associated Press.

The wider picture: Islamic State after its defeat

The Islamic State group lost the last of its territory in Syria in 2019, but it did not disappear. On the same day as the Vienna attack, gunmen stormed Kabul University in Afghanistan, killing more than 30 people in an attack claimed by the group's local affiliate. Just over a week earlier, a suicide bomber had killed around 30 people at an education centre in the city. Together these attacks showed that the group and its followers could still strike far from their former strongholds.

In Europe, many recent attacks were carried out by individuals inspired by the group rather than directed by it, and several, like Vienna, involved people already known to the authorities. That is why the debate after 2 November focused so much on prison release, deradicalisation and intelligence sharing between countries.

What came next

Austria closed two mosques it accused of contributing to radicalisation, passed new anti-terror laws in 2021 and restructured its domestic intelligence agency. EU interior ministers met days after the attack and pledged closer cooperation on border checks, online extremist content and tracking known extremists.

Macron's phrase endured because it captured a simple idea: that a shooting in Vienna, a knife attack in Nice and the murder of a teacher near Paris were attacks on shared European values, and that the answer was solidarity rather than fear. Remembering the victims, and getting the facts right about each incident, is part of that answer.

Sources: 2020 Vienna attack (Wikipedia); Murder of Samuel Paty (Wikipedia); 2020 Nice stabbing (Wikipedia); 2020 Kabul University attack (Wikipedia); Al Jazeera, 31 October 2020; The Greek Herald, 8 November 2020; AP via News4Jax, 30 October 2020.

COMMENTS