Originally published 2020-11-30.

Yes, a British astronaut really did believe for a moment that he was looking at UFOs from the International Space Station, and no, they were not alien craft. Tim Peake, who spent six months on the station in 2015 and 2016, said the mysterious lights were tiny frozen droplets drifting just outside the window. By his account, the liquid had leaked from a docked Russian vehicle, and he summed up the answer with a punchline that got a big laugh on BBC television.
The story is funny, but it is also a neat lesson in how easily human eyes and brains misjudge distance, size and speed when there is nothing familiar to compare against. Below is what Peake described, why the illusion happens, how earlier astronauts were fooled in the same way, and how this anecdote fits next to the US military UFO videos that were in the news the same year.
What Tim Peake described on the Graham Norton Show
Peake told the story on BBC One's The Graham Norton Show, in an episode broadcast in late November 2020 while he was promoting his autobiography, Limitless. Looking out from the station, he and his crewmates noticed three lights apparently moving together in formation, and then a fourth joined them. For a few moments the obvious thought was that something large and far away was keeping pace with the ISS.
The truth turned out to be the opposite. The lights were very small and very close: droplets of liquid that had escaped from a Russian spacecraft attached to the station, frozen almost instantly in the vacuum and lit up by the Sun. Peake delivered the conclusion with a straight face: "What we were seeing was Russian urine."
He did not say which vehicle it was, and nobody has published an official log of the event, so the exact source is unconfirmed. What matters is the mechanism, and that part is well understood.
Why a few droplets can look like distant spacecraft
On Earth we judge distance with a whole toolbox of clues. Air softens and blues faraway objects, buildings and trees give us a sense of scale, and our two eyes see slightly different angles of anything nearby. In orbit most of those clues vanish. There is no haze, the background is pure black, and a bright point of light gives no hint of whether it is a metre away or a hundred kilometres away.
Sunlight in space is also harsh and unfiltered. A speck of ice a few millimetres across can flash brilliantly when it catches the light at the right angle, the same way dust glitters in a sunbeam in a dark room. Viewed through a thick station window, with eyes adjusted to the interior lights, a cluster of drifting crystals can easily read as a group of lit objects in the far distance.
Motion completes the illusion. Droplets released from the same leak move away at similar speeds and directions, so they appear to travel "in formation". Because they share the station's orbit and drift slowly relative to it, they can seem to hang alongside the ISS, which is exactly what you would expect from a craft that was following you.
John Glenn's "fireflies": the same trick in 1962
Peake was in good company. During the first American orbital flight, Friendship 7 in February 1962, John Glenn reported brilliant specks floating around his Mercury capsule at sunrise. He called them "fireflies" and at first wondered whether the spacecraft was tumbling.
The particles were later judged to be small ice crystals venting from the capsule's own systems. Glenn even found he could release a fresh shower of them by banging on the wall of the cabin. Six decades later, the setting had changed from a cramped capsule to a football-pitch-sized laboratory, but the physics of frozen water and sunlight had not.
Spacecraft release liquids and gases for many ordinary reasons: venting waste water, purging lines, firing small thrusters, or simple leaks. Each release can create a short-lived cloud of glittering particles. Astronauts learn to recognise these, but even experienced crews can be caught off guard for a moment, as Peake's story shows.
Who Tim Peake is, and the second flight he hoped for
Tim Peake, born in Chichester in 1972, is a former Army Air Corps helicopter pilot and test pilot who was selected by the European Space Agency in 2009 from more than 8,000 applicants. He became the first British ESA astronaut and flew to the ISS on Soyuz TMA-19M in December 2015 for his Principia mission, returning to Earth in June 2016.
During those six months he became the first British astronaut to carry out a spacewalk, replacing a failed power unit on the station's solar array in January 2016. In April 2016 he ran the London Marathon on the station's treadmill, earning a Guinness World Record for the fastest marathon in orbit.
On the same chat show he admitted that every launch involves a sense of rolling the dice, outweighed by excitement, and said he was keen to return, with a second mission pencilled in before 2024. That flight did not happen with ESA: he retired from active astronaut service in 2023, so Principia remains his only spaceflight to date.
The Pentagon videos: what was released and what they show
The urine story landed in a year when UFOs were being taken unusually seriously. In April 2020 the US Department of Defense formally released three short infrared videos filmed by Navy fighter pilots, often called "FLIR", "Gimbal" and "GoFast". The first came from an encounter near the aircraft carrier USS Nimitz in 2004; the other two were filmed in 2014 and 2015 by aviators from the USS Theodore Roosevelt. The clips had already leaked to the press in 2017, and the Pentagon said its release was meant to clear up questions about whether the footage was real.
In the videos the pilots sound genuinely puzzled, and the objects were officially labelled "unidentified aerial phenomena". That label means exactly what it says: unidentified, not extraterrestrial. Analysts and sceptics, including science writer Mick West, have argued that ordinary explanations such as distant aircraft, balloons, camera glare and the motion of the jet itself can account for what the sensors show. As West put it, "A lack of data does not mean aliens are the likely answer."
In June 2021 the US Office of the Director of National Intelligence published a preliminary assessment of 144 reports from US government sources, dated from November 2004 to March 2021. Only one could be explained with confidence, as a large deflating balloon. The report did not find evidence of alien spacecraft; it said most cases simply lacked enough data to reach a conclusion. The Pentagon later created the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office to investigate reports, and it has since explained many cases as aircraft, balloons, drones and sensor effects.
Common myths about astronauts and UFOs
"Astronauts see UFOs all the time and keep quiet"
Astronauts do see unexplained lights, as Peake and Glenn both did. Their accounts show the usual pattern: a brief puzzle, followed by a mundane explanation once more information is available. Peake told his story precisely because it was funny, not because it was hidden.
"If the military can't identify it, it must be alien"
An unidentified object is a gap in information, not a positive discovery. Sensors have blind spots, and small or distant objects can be very hard to measure. Investigators prefer to say "we don't know yet" rather than leap to the most dramatic answer.
"Space is empty, so anything you see must be a craft"
The space around an inhabited station is surprisingly busy: ice crystals, flecks of paint, tiny debris, other satellites and the station's own visiting vehicles. Most of what catches an astronaut's eye is very close and very small.
What to take from the story
If you ever see a strange light in the sky, Peake's experience is a good guide. Note the time, direction and how it moved, and then look for ordinary explanations first: satellites, the ISS itself, aircraft, drones, balloons, bright planets such as Venus, or reflections in the window you are looking through. Free satellite-tracking apps can tell you in seconds whether a moving dot was a passing spacecraft.
Being puzzled is not embarrassing. Even a trained test pilot sitting in the best observation post humanity has ever built was briefly fooled by a handful of frozen droplets. The healthy response, which Peake modelled perfectly, is curiosity followed by a willingness to accept the simple answer, even when the simple answer is a little bit gross.
Sources: Forces News, 27 November 2020: Tim Peake recalls the moment he thought he saw alien spaceships; Wikipedia: Tim Peake; Wikipedia: Mercury-Atlas 6 (John Glenn's fireflies); Wikipedia: Pentagon UFO videos; ODNI, Preliminary Assessment: Unidentified Aerial Phenomena, 25 June 2021. Videos courtesy of their original YouTube publishers.

COMMENTS