First published November 8, 2017.
Was this really an astronaut selection question?
Solving the riddle can be an enjoyable reasoning exercise. It does not establish eligibility for spaceflight. Peake presented it as one of the tests from his own selection process when he posted it to promote his book; he and the European Space Agency later published The Astronaut Selection Test Book, describing its puzzles as tests similar to those astronaut candidates are given. That makes it a genuine example of the spatial-reasoning style of test, rather than proof that this exact question decides who flies.

You might have been dreaming to become an astronaut since you were a kid, but if that moment ever came, would you be able to pass the test?
One of the most famous astronauts of the UK, Tim Peake, shared a post on his Facebook page with a question that's included in his new book, "Ask an Astronaut".
His post also included an image that depicted a cube with a dot in its bottom and the riddle that people should solve was the following:
The cube can be moved if you roll it to the left, to the right, forward (towards you), or backwards (away from you).Now in your mind roll the cube: forward, left, left, forward, right, backwards, right. After you do that, you should try to answer the following question: where's the dot?
This was supposed to be a real question Tim, and other astronauts had to solve before they were chosen to go to space.
Since Tim posted that on Facebook, it has gone viral.
Try to solve it and share what you found. When this article was first published, Peake had not yet revealed the 'correct answer'; he did so a few days later.
Track the marked face one move at a time
Label the six faces on paper, then record the dot’s position after each roll. This makes an error easier to locate than trying to hold the entire sequence in memory. The directions “towards you” and “away from you” must remain fixed throughout; changing your viewpoint halfway through silently changes the problem.
The answer (spoiler): the dot ends up on the bottom again. The quickest way to see why: a roll only moves the dot if the dot is on one of the four faces that turn with that roll. After the first forward roll the dot is on a side face that the two left rolls do not touch; the second forward roll brings it to the top; the first right roll takes it to a side face, which the backward roll does not touch; and the last right roll brings it back to the bottom. Most wrong answers come from treating “roll left” as “turn left”.

On the right hand side.
ReplyDelete*Left hand side . . . forget previous answer. Can I go to space now?
Deletea cube doesn't roll...
ReplyDelete