COVID-19 and Extreme Poverty: World Bank's 88-150 Million Estimate

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-14.

The World Bank's 2020 Pandemic Poverty Estimates

People queue for free food in Kolkata, India, in September 2020. Photo: Debajyoti Chakraborty/NurPhoto/ZUMA Press.

On 7 October 2020 the World Bank said the COVID-19 pandemic would push an extra 88 million to 115 million people into extreme poverty that year. It warned the total could reach as many as 150 million by 2021, depending on how deep the global recession turned out to be. Extreme poverty then meant living on less than $1.90 a day.

Later data showed the real figure for 2020 was close to the bottom of that range. In 2022 the Bank put the number pushed into extreme poverty by the pandemic at about 70 million. That was still the largest one-year increase since global poverty monitoring began in 1990.

What the 2020 report said

The figures came from the World Bank's flagship Poverty and Shared Prosperity 2020: Reversals of Fortune report. Its main points were:

  • The global extreme poverty rate was expected to rise to between 9.1% and 9.4% in 2020, up from 9.2% in 2017. Without the pandemic it had been on course to fall to about 7.9%.
  • About 82% of the "new poor" would live in middle-income countries, many of them countries that already had high poverty rates.
  • World Bank president David Malpass said the pandemic and recession could push more than 1.4% of the world's population into extreme poverty.
  • Conflict and climate change were already slowing progress before COVID-19. The Bank warned that ending extreme poverty by 2030 would be beyond reach without swift, substantial policy action.

These numbers were projections. They were built from economic growth forecasts and survey data, not a headcount of people who had lost their income. That is why the Bank gave a range and why it revised the figures as new data came in.

Who the new poor were

The pandemic hit a different group of people from the one most anti-poverty programmes were built for. Before 2020, most people in extreme poverty lived in rural areas and worked in farming. The World Bank's analysis found that the people newly falling below the line were more likely to live in cities and towns, more likely to have some education, and less likely to work in agriculture.

The report summed it up in one line: "The new poor are more urban, better educated and less likely to work in agriculture." That made sense given what lockdowns did. Informal work in services, construction, street trading and manufacturing disappeared almost overnight, and these are urban jobs. Workers without savings, contracts or social insurance had nothing to fall back on. Many governments' safety nets were designed to reach the rural poor, so they struggled to reach people who had been just above the line a few months earlier.

Some economists also worried that a sudden rise in urban poverty could feed social unrest. That risk is harder to measure than income, but it was one reason the Bank urged fast action.

The historic comparison

The reversal was so notable because extreme poverty had fallen almost every year for a generation. Around 1990 roughly a third of humanity lived below the international poverty line. By 2019 that share was below a tenth, even though the world's population had grown by billions. Much of that progress came from rapid growth in East Asia, above all China, while poverty fell far more slowly in sub-Saharan Africa.

The financial crisis of 2008–09 slowed this decline but did not reverse it. COVID-19 did. In its 2022 follow-up report, the World Bank confirmed that 2020 was the worst single year for global poverty since its records began. It said progress had "essentially halted". By 2022, sub-Saharan Africa held about 60% of the world's extreme poor, roughly 389 million people.

Is $1.90 a day the right line?

The international poverty line is deliberately very low. It is based on the national poverty lines of some of the poorest countries and adjusted for differences in prices, so $1.90 means what $1.90 would buy in the United States, not what it converts to at the bank. Critics have long argued that a line this low hides how many people are struggling. Some also say income alone misses things like schooling, clean water and electricity.

The World Bank partly answers this by publishing higher lines too. In 2020 nearly a quarter of the world lived on less than $3.20 a day, and more than 40%, almost 3.3 billion people, lived on less than $5.50. It also tracks a broader measure that counts access to education and basic services. In 2022 the extreme poverty line was updated to $2.15 a day to reflect new price data. That is why recent figures, such as about 719 million people in extreme poverty at the end of 2020, are not directly comparable with the 2020 estimates.

What happened next

The worst-case figure of 150 million by 2021 did not come true, partly because many economies recovered faster than feared and partly because of large emergency cash transfer programmes in several countries. The recovery was uneven, though. Richer countries bounced back quickly. Many low-income countries, facing debt, inflation and the food and energy price shock that followed Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022, did not.

The World Bank's 2022 report projected that nearly 600 million people would still live on less than $2.15 a day in 2030. That makes the United Nations goal of ending extreme poverty by then very unlikely to be met. The Bank's chief economist, Indermit Gill, argued that governments would need to focus on building human capital and on growth to get progress moving again.

Reading poverty headlines

When you see a headline about millions being pushed into poverty, it helps to ask three things: which poverty line is being used, whether the figure is a forecast or a measurement, and what year it refers to. The 2020 estimates were honest forecasts made in the middle of a crisis. The later, lower figure of about 70 million does not make them wrong. It shows how forecasts tighten as real data arrives, and the human cost was still enormous.

Sources: World Bank press release, 7 October 2020; World Bank press release, 5 October 2022. Photo: Debajyoti Chakraborty/NurPhoto/ZUMA Press.

COMMENTS