Facebook's 2020 Holocaust Denial Ban: What Changed and Why

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-14.

Facebook Announced a Ban on Holocaust Denial Content in 2020

Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook's chief executive, had faced months of appeals from Holocaust survivors to act on denial content. Photo: AP Photo/Andrew Harnik.

On 12 October 2020 Facebook changed its hate speech rules to ban any content that denies or distorts the Holocaust. Until then the company had removed posts praising mass murder but allowed most denial content to stay up, arguing that it should not police false claims about history. Mark Zuckerberg announced the reversal himself, saying rising antisemitism and evidence of poor Holocaust knowledge among young people had changed his mind. The company also said it would point people who searched for the Holocaust towards reliable sources.

Here is what the policy covered, what pushed Facebook to adopt it, how it compares with the law in different countries, and what it could and could not achieve.

What Facebook announced

In a company post, Monika Bickert, then Facebook's vice president of content policy, explained that the hate speech policy now prohibited "any content that denies or distorts the Holocaust." That covers claims that the genocide never happened, that gas chambers were not used, or that the number of Jewish victims has been grossly inflated.

Three practical changes came with it:

  • Removal. Posts, groups and pages promoting denial or distortion would be taken down once identified.
  • Redirection. Later in 2020, people searching for Holocaust-related terms, or terms linked to denial, would be shown links to credible information off Facebook.
  • Gradual enforcement. The company warned that the rule could not be enforced overnight, because reviewers and automated systems needed training to tell denial apart from discussion of it.

Zuckerberg shared the news on his own page. He wrote that he had struggled with the tension between free expression and the harm of minimising the Holocaust, and that data on rising antisemitic violence had shifted his view.

Today we're updating our hate speech policy to ban Holocaust denial. We've long taken down posts that praise hate...

Posted by Mark Zuckerberg on Monday, 12 October 2020

Why Facebook changed course

The decision was a striking turnaround. In a 2018 interview Zuckerberg had used Holocaust denial as an example of content he found deeply offensive but did not think Facebook should remove, on the grounds that people sometimes get things wrong without meaning to. That remark drew widespread criticism.

Pressure built through 2020. The Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, known as the Claims Conference, ran the #NoDenyingIt campaign, in which Holocaust survivors recorded video messages addressed directly to Zuckerberg asking him to act. Civil rights groups were at the same time organising an advertiser boycott over hate speech on the platform.

Facebook's own announcement leaned on survey evidence. A Claims Conference study of Americans aged 18 to 39, published in September 2020, found that almost a quarter said the Holocaust was a myth, had been exaggerated, or that they were not sure. Many respondents could not name a single concentration camp.

The move also fitted a wider tightening that autumn. Facebook had already banned more than 250 white supremacist organisations, and on 6 October 2020 it announced it would remove QAnon groups and pages across its platforms. QAnon is a conspiracy movement built on the false claim that a secret cabal of elite child abusers controls governments and media.

The history that denial attacks

The Holocaust was the systematic murder of about six million Jews by Nazi Germany and its collaborators between 1941 and 1945, roughly two thirds of Europe's Jewish population. Persecution began soon after the Nazis took power in 1933. Millions of other people were also killed, including Roma and Sinti, disabled people, Soviet prisoners of war, Polish civilians, political opponents, gay men and others the regime targeted.

The evidence is vast: German documents, the camps themselves, the testimony of survivors, perpetrators and liberating soldiers, and the records of post-war trials. Denial is not a historical debate. It is a set of claims, repeated for decades, designed to rehabilitate Nazism and to portray Jews as liars. In the well-known British libel case brought by David Irving against historian Deborah Lipstadt, the court found in 2000 that Irving had deliberately distorted evidence.

How the law treats Holocaust denial

The legal picture varies widely. Holocaust denial is a criminal offence in around 20 countries, mostly in Europe, including Germany, Austria, France, Belgium, Poland and Israel, and it can carry prison sentences. Some countries, such as Greece, Switzerland and the Netherlands, punish it only when it incites hatred or is combined with threats or insults.

A European Union framework decision requires member states to punish publicly condoning, denying or grossly trivialising genocide and war crimes, but it lets countries limit this to conduct likely to disturb public order. The United Kingdom and Spain do not ban denial as such.

In the United States the First Amendment protects such speech from government punishment. That is why the change at Facebook mattered: as a private company it can set rules stricter than US law, and its platforms reach billions of people in countries with very different legal traditions.

How campaigners responded

Jewish organisations and anti-hate groups welcomed the change while noting how long it had taken. The Anti-Defamation League, which had pressed the company for years, called it "a building block toward ensuring that this sort of anti-Semitism is not amplified." Survivors involved in the #NoDenyingIt campaign said they hoped other platforms would follow.

Others followed within days. Twitter said soon afterwards that Holocaust denial would fall under its hateful conduct rules, a shift that critics said came late.

What a policy can and cannot do

A rule only matters if it is enforced. Moderators must distinguish between a post that promotes denial, a post that quotes a denier in order to rebut them, and a museum or teacher explaining what denial looks like. Automated systems often get this wrong in both directions, removing educational material while missing coded language, memes and misspellings that deniers use to slip past filters.

Researchers and campaigners have continued to find denial content on major platforms in the years since. Policy changes at large tech companies can also be reversed or loosened as leadership and priorities shift, so the 2020 rule should be read as a record of a decision at that moment rather than a guarantee of how the platform works today.

For readers, a few practical points help:

  • Go to trusted sources. Yad Vashem, the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum and national Holocaust memorial bodies offer free, well-documented material.
  • Report rather than argue. Engaging with denial posts can boost their reach; reporting them is usually more effective.
  • Listen to testimony. Recorded survivor interviews are among the most powerful answers to denial, and many are freely available online.

Sources: Meta Newsroom: Removing Holocaust Denial Content (12 October 2020); Wikipedia: Laws against Holocaust denial; Wikipedia: Holocaust denial. Photo: AP Photo/Andrew Harnik.

COMMENTS