DeSantis Filmed Maskless High-Fiving Crowd at Trump's Sanford Rally

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-13.

Maskless Florida Governor High-Fiving Attendees At Trump Rally In Direct Opposition To CDC Guidelines

On 12 October 2020, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis was filmed walking through the crowd at Donald Trump's rally at Orlando Sanford International Airport without a mask, high-fiving supporters and then touching his nose. It was Trump's first campaign rally since his COVID-19 diagnosis earlier that month, and most of the crowd was also unmasked and packed closely together.

The clip spread quickly on social media because it captured the sharp divide of that autumn: a governor who opposed lockdowns, a president just out of hospital, and public health guidance that urged masks and distance at large gatherings. Here is what happened, the context at the time, and how it looks with hindsight.

What the video showed

The short clip was posted on Twitter by Daniel Uhlfelder, a Florida lawyer who had become known in 2020 for protesting the early reopening of Florida beaches. It shows DeSantis arriving at the rally, moving along the barrier and slapping hands with supporters, with no mask in sight. At the end, he rubs his nose.

The gesture would hardly be noticed at any other political event. In October 2020, with no vaccines yet available and health authorities warning that the virus spread through close contact and touching the face, it became a talking point for critics who saw it as a poor example from a state leader.

Trump's first rally after his COVID-19 diagnosis

Trump had announced in the early hours of 2 October 2020 that he had tested positive for the virus. He spent three nights at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, from 2 to 5 October, where he was treated with an experimental Regeneron antibody cocktail, the antiviral remdesivir and the steroid dexamethasone.

After a short appearance at the White House on 10 October, the Sanford event was his return to the campaign trail. He did not wear a mask. During the speech he reportedly said he felt so powerful that he would walk into the audience and kiss everyone, "the guys and the beautiful women". He had already suggested a few days earlier, in a video released when he left hospital, that he might now be immune.

Scientists at the time cautioned that immunity after infection was not guaranteed, that its length was unknown, and that recovered people could still be reinfected.

What DeSantis said, and Florida's approach to the pandemic

Speaking before Trump arrived, DeSantis told the crowd that Republicans would not let Democrats shut down the country, and praised Florida's open approach. As Bay News 9 reported, he said: Florida people can go to school. You can go to a store. He also urged the Senate to confirm Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court, whose hearings began that same day.

DeSantis was one of the country's most prominent opponents of lockdowns. On 25 September 2020, he moved Florida into "Phase 3" of reopening, lifting capacity limits on most businesses and barring local governments from fining people for breaking local health rules, including mask orders. Dr Anthony Fauci called the decision to allow full capacity in restaurants and bars "very concerning".

Florida had already been through a severe summer wave. The average number of new daily cases rose almost tenfold during June 2020, and by early July more than 40 hospitals were at or near intensive care capacity. By the time of the rally, the state had recorded well over 700,000 cases and more than 15,000 deaths, according to state figures widely reported at the time.

Did the rally break CDC guidance?

Critics said the president, the governor and the crowd were ignoring the guidelines of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. That is fair, with one clarification: CDC guidance was advice, not law. It recommended that people wear masks in public, keep about six feet apart and avoid large crowds, and it rated big indoor or outdoor gatherings where people could not keep their distance as the highest-risk type of event.

The rally clearly did not follow those recommendations. But it was not illegal in Florida, where the state had specifically blocked local fines for mask rules. The question was one of public health judgement and leadership example, not law enforcement.

Were Trump's rallies actually "superspreader" events? That is hard to prove, because cases cannot easily be traced to a single outdoor gathering. A widely reported working paper by Stanford economists, published later that month and not peer reviewed, estimated that 18 Trump rallies held between June and September 2020 led to more than 30,000 additional infections. The Trump campaign rejected the study, and other researchers questioned its methods.

Why Florida mattered so much in 2020

Florida was the largest battleground state of the 2020 election, with 29 electoral votes. Analysts widely believed that Trump could not win a second term without it, which is why both campaigns poured time and money into the state.

The state also has one of the oldest populations in the United States, and older people faced by far the highest risk of severe illness and death from COVID-19. That made the images from Sanford especially uncomfortable for some voters and health experts.

In the end, Trump carried Florida in November 2020, but he lost the national election to Joe Biden. DeSantis went on to win re-election as governor in 2022 by a wide margin, and many political scientists later concluded that his pandemic record had helped rather than hurt him with Florida voters.

Looking back

Judged by the science of autumn 2020, before vaccines, the scenes in Sanford ran against nearly every recommendation for slowing the virus. Judged by politics, they were a deliberate message: Florida was open, and its leaders were not afraid to show it.

Both readings can be true at once. The clip remains a snapshot of how differently Americans weighed health risks, personal freedom and economic pressure during the first year of the pandemic.

Sources: Video posted by Daniel Uhlfelder on Twitter; Bay News 9; Wikipedia: White House COVID-19 outbreak; Wikipedia: COVID-19 pandemic in Florida; Wikipedia: Ron DeSantis.

COMMENTS