Trump Says He Feels Immune at First Rally After Covid-19

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-13.

Trump's October 2020 Speech After COVID-19

Photo: Reuters

On 12 October 2020, ten days after announcing he had Covid-19, Donald Trump returned to the campaign trail with a rally in Sanford, Florida, and told supporters he felt immune to the virus. He joked that he would walk into the crowd and kiss everyone, men and women alike, in front of thousands of people standing close together, most of them without masks. Scientists at the time could not say how long protection after infection lasted, and public-health agencies warned that reinfection was possible.

The rally became one of the defining images of the final weeks of the 2020 campaign. Here is what Trump said, what was known about his illness and his claim of immunity, and how his attacks on Joe Biden held up.

Trump's illness: a short timeline

Trump announced shortly before 1am on 2 October that he and Melania Trump had tested positive. It later emerged that the White House outbreak was linked to at least 53 cases, many traced to a crowded Rose Garden event on 26 September for Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett.

  • 2 October: Trump received an experimental Regeneron monoclonal antibody treatment and was flown to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. Doctors later acknowledged he had been given supplemental oxygen.
  • 3 to 4 October: his doctors reported two drops in his blood oxygen levels. He was started on the steroid dexamethasone and a five-day course of the antiviral remdesivir.
  • 5 October: he left hospital about 72 hours after admission, returned to the White House and removed his mask on the balcony for photographs. In a video that day he said "maybe I'm immune" and urged people not to let Covid dominate their lives.
  • 12 October: White House physician Sean Conley said Trump had tested negative on consecutive days with rapid antigen tests and was no longer infectious. That evening Trump held the Sanford rally.

Experts noted that the CDC did not recommend using rapid antigen tests alone to end isolation; it advised confirming with a laboratory PCR test. At 74, and with obesity, Trump was in a high-risk group, and later reporting said he had been sicker than the White House admitted at the time.

What he said in Sanford

The rally took place at Orlando Sanford International Airport, in a crucial swing state. Trump spoke for over an hour and seemed energetic. His best-known line came early:

"They say I'm immune – I feel so powerful. I'll walk in there and kiss everyone."

He went on to warn that a Biden presidency would turn the United States into "Communist Cuba" or "Socialist Venezuela", claimed that Biden admired Fidel Castro, and said Biden would wreck Florida's economy with a draconian lockdown. He offered no evidence for these claims. He ended, as at many of his rallies, by dancing to the Village People's "Y.M.C.A."

Reporters at the event noted how few people in the tightly packed crowd wore masks, at a time when US Covid deaths were still averaging hundreds a day and no vaccine was yet available.

Was Trump really immune?

In October 2020 the honest answer was that nobody knew. People who recover from Covid-19 usually develop antibodies and other immune defences, and these do give some protection. But studies at the time could not say how strong that protection was or how long it lasted, and documented cases of reinfection were already being reported. Antibody treatments like the one Trump received also complicate the picture, because they supply ready-made antibodies rather than the body's own.

The day before the rally, Twitter attached a warning label to a Trump post claiming he was immune, saying it broke the platform's rules on misleading health information. Later experience settled the question: immunity after infection fades over time and is weaker against new variants, which is why reinfections became common and why health bodies went on to recommend vaccination even for people who had already had the virus.

For anyone recovering from Covid-19 or another infection, the practical lesson is simple: ask a doctor about when it is safe to mix with others and whether vaccination is advised, rather than relying on how you feel.

The claims about Biden

Trump also told the crowd, and later repeated online, that Biden was coughing and fiddling with his mask, and accused the media of covering it up. There was no evidence that Biden had Covid-19 at the time. His campaign published a series of negative test results through October, and he did not test positive until July 2022, while president.

The "socialism" warnings were aimed squarely at Florida's large Cuban-American and Venezuelan-American communities, many of whom fled left-wing governments. Biden had rejected socialist labels throughout the campaign, and his platform did not include the policies Trump described.

How the race ended

National polls in mid-October showed Biden with a clear lead, and there were three weeks left until polling day on 3 November. The Florida strategy partly worked: Trump won the state by about three points, improving on his 2016 margin, helped by gains among Latino voters in Miami-Dade County. Nationally, though, Biden won the election with 306 electoral votes to Trump's 232.

The Sanford rally is remembered less for its politics than for its public-health message. A president who had just been treated in hospital told a packed, mostly maskless crowd that he was immune and wanted to kiss them, at a moment when his own doctors could not confirm how long his protection would last.

Sources: NPR: Timeline of President Trump's Covid-19 diagnosis and treatment; Wikipedia: White House COVID-19 outbreak; History.com: Trump tests positive for Covid-19; Wikipedia: 2020 United States presidential election. Rally quotes as reported by The Independent; photo by Reuters.

COMMENTS