Originally published 2020-10-26.
In October 2020 a caller in Bay Village, a suburb west of Cleveland, Ohio, phoned police to report a man asleep on a bench beside a public park. The "man" was a bronze sculpture: Timothy Schmalz's Homeless Jesus, which had been set up outside St. Barnabas Episcopal Church about twenty minutes earlier. Nobody was hurt, the officer who responded found nothing but metal under the blanket, and the story spread across the country within days.
It is a small, slightly comic episode, but it also says something real about how a piece of public art works. Below is what happened, what the sculpture is, why it keeps being mistaken for a person, and what the numbers on homelessness in the United States actually show.

What happened in Bay Village
The sculpture arrived at St. Barnabas on the church grounds next to a park, in a spot chosen so that passers-by could not miss it. According to the Cleveland weekly Scene, the call reached police on 12 October 2020, shortly after the work was placed. The church's rector, the Rev. Alex Martin, heard about it from the officer who came to check, and he shared the exchange on social media. The church's own account had announced the arrival of the statue the same day.
We're glad to temporarily host this statue of Homeless Jesus to raise awareness of homelessness in Cleveland and remind us that all people are created in the image of God. pic.twitter.com/EKClQm7PFG
— St. Barnabas, Bay Village (@StBarnabasBV) October 12, 2020
Bay Village police later confirmed the call. Their chief, Kathy Leasure, explained that the caller had not been sure whether the figure was a person or a statue. Had it been a real person, she said, the officer would have made sure there was no medical emergency and offered practical help, such as a night in a hotel. That answer matters: a check on someone sleeping outside is not necessarily hostile, and in cold weather it can save a life.
The statue was not a gift to the church. It belongs to the Community West Foundation, a local charity that bought it and has rotated it among churches and religious groups in the Cleveland area since October 2018. Its stay at St. Barnabas was planned to run until 1 December 2020.
The sculpture and the artist
Homeless Jesus shows a figure lying full length on a park bench, wrapped head to ankle in a blanket. The face and hands are hidden. The only clue to who it is lies at the far end of the bench: two bare feet, each marked with the wound of a nail. A gap is left on the bench, so that a visitor can sit beside the sleeper.
Timothy Schmalz is a Canadian sculptor and a practising Catholic. He has said the idea came to him in 2012 after he saw a homeless person asleep on a bench in Toronto. The first cast was installed in 2013 at Regis College, a Jesuit theological school at the University of Toronto, after two large Toronto-area churches declined it. The first American cast went to St. Alban's Episcopal Church in Davidson, North Carolina, in 2014. In 2013 Schmalz showed a miniature to Pope Francis, who touched the statue's knee and prayed over it; a full cast was placed outside the Vatican's charity office in 2016. By 2017 more than fifty copies stood in cities around the world.
Why the statue keeps fooling people
Bay Village was not the first place where someone mistook the bronze for a living person. In Davidson a resident called police the first time she saw it. In Hamilton, Ontario, emergency services received several calls on cold, snowy nights, and similar reports came from Minneapolis and from Fargo, North Dakota.
That is close to the point of the work. The blanket hides everything that would normally tell us whether a stranger is "one of us" or not: the face, the clothes, the hands. From a passing car, the figure reads simply as a person sleeping rough. The viewer reacts first and only then notices the wounded feet, and with them the question the artist is asking.
The emergency calls are therefore an interesting case. Some people saw them as proof that neighbours want homeless people moved on. Others read them as concern for someone who might be ill or freezing. A single call cannot prove either view, and the police statement in Bay Village suggests that the response, at least, would have been welfare-focused.
A sculpture that divides opinion
Not everyone has welcomed the piece. In Davidson some residents felt it demeaned their neighbourhood, and one neighbour said it simply unsettled him. In 2016 Westminster City Council in London refused permission for a cast outside Methodist Central Hall, citing its effect on the Parliament Square conservation area. An art critic described the work as technically well made but not very original as art.
Supporters answer that the discomfort is deliberate. Christian teaching often points to the passage in Matthew 25 in which Jesus says that whatever is done for "the least of these" is done for him, and the sculpture puts that idea on a bench in the street. Rev. Martin told Scene that the statue reminds his congregation that, even in a quiet suburb, "we don't have to drive far to find those in tremendous need."
Homelessness in the United States: the numbers
Early reports of the Bay Village story said that around half a million Americans were homeless. That was roughly right for the time. The figure comes from the annual point-in-time count, which tries to record everyone sleeping in shelters or outdoors on a single night in January; it is an undercount by design, because people staying with friends or moving between motels are often missed.
The number has risen since. According to a Congressional Research Service summary of the federal data, the January 2024 count found 771,480 people experiencing homelessness, a sharp rise from the roughly half a million of a few years earlier. The 2025 count recorded 745,652 people, of whom about 266,000 were unsheltered, sleeping outside, in vehicles or in other places not meant for living. The CRS notes that some areas skipped the outdoor count in 2025, so the drop should be read with caution.
What to do if you see someone sleeping outside
The Bay Village call raises a fair practical question: what is the right thing to do when you see a person asleep on a bench? A few simple steps help.
- If the person seems unresponsive, injured or exposed to extreme cold or heat, call the emergency number. That is a welfare call, not a complaint.
- If they are simply resting, it is usually best to leave them in peace, or to ask quietly whether they need anything.
- Many cities run street outreach teams or a non-emergency line (such as 211 in much of the US) that can connect people with shelter, food and health care.
- Local shelters and food banks often need volunteers and donations more than one-off gestures.
The statue in Bay Village was gone from St. Barnabas within a few weeks, moved on to its next host. The question it asked, who we notice and how we respond, stayed behind.
Sources: Cleveland Scene: In Bay Village, someone called cops on a sleeping homeless person. It was a statue of Jesus; Wikipedia: Homeless Jesus; Congressional Research Service: Homelessness point-in-time estimates (IF12985). Sculpture by Timothy Schmalz; tweet by St. Barnabas, Bay Village.

COMMENTS