Lyon Orthodox Priest Shooting, October 2020: Facts vs Early Claims

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published October 31, 2020.

The Lyon Priest Shooting of October 2020: Early Claims and Uncertainty

On the afternoon of Saturday 31 October 2020, a Greek Orthodox priest, Father Nikolaos Kakavelakis, was shot and seriously wounded as he was closing his church on Rue Père Chevrier in Lyon, France. He was reportedly hit twice with a sawn-off shotgun and taken to hospital in a critical condition. Coming two days after a deadly terrorist attack in Nice, the shooting was immediately treated by many on social media as another Islamist attack, and some early reports claimed the gunman had shouted a religious slogan. That claim was never confirmed. The first man detained was released, and later reporting pointed towards a personal dispute rather than terrorism.

What happened in Lyon

The attack took place around 4 pm outside the church in Lyon's 7th arrondissement. Police sealed off the area and launched a manhunt, while officials urged people to avoid the neighbourhood. Within hours a suspect was taken into custody, but he was released shortly afterwards when investigators found no evidence linking him to the shooting.

A Greek church official, Christos Koutsiouris, told reporters that the priest had been threatened by men who stole his cross about a week earlier, while also saying he did not know who had carried out the shooting. Father Nikolaos survived his injuries.

Posts like the one below spread widely on the evening of the attack, asserting a terrorist motive before any facts were known:

À #Lyon, un prêtre orthodoxe a été touché par balle alors qu'il fermait son église, au 45 Rue Père Chevrier#attaque à caractère #terroriste ne fait aucun doute pour Moi, dans le contexte actuel, elle porte une Signature #islamiste

Pronostic vital engagé pic.twitter.com/VZrtKM4WBA

— La Fouine #FrançaisReveillezVous 🇫🇷 (@BBR4369) October 31, 2020

(This post is no longer available on X.)

Early claims and what investigators found

Several early accounts repeated a claim that the attacker shouted "Allahu Akbar" before firing. No official source confirmed this, and it should not be treated as fact. France's national anti-terrorism prosecutor's office reportedly did not take over the case, leaving it with the Lyon prosecutor, which is itself a sign that investigators did not see clear evidence of terrorism.

In the following days, French media reported other lines of inquiry. Some suggested a dispute connected to the priest's private life; others raised a possible conflict within the church community. Reports in November 2020, including an Associated Press account, said investigators were focusing on a personal motive. These reports should be read with care, since no trial outcome has been widely published, but none supports the idea of an Islamist attack.

The episode is a good example of how quickly a narrative forms after violent events. When an attack happens in a tense moment, people fill the gap with assumptions. Waiting for confirmation from police or prosecutors protects both the public and any innocent person wrongly suspected.

Why France was on edge in October 2020

The Lyon shooting came at one of the most frightening moments in recent French history. On 16 October 2020, history teacher Samuel Paty was murdered and beheaded near his school after showing caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad during a class on freedom of expression. Thirteen days later, on 29 October, a 21-year-old Tunisian man, Brahim Issaoui, killed three people inside the Notre-Dame basilica in Nice. He had reached the Italian island of Lampedusa in September and entered France days before the attack. In 2025 he was sentenced to life imprisonment.

The trial over the January 2015 Charlie Hebdo attack was also under way, after the magazine republished the caricatures in September 2020. With France on its highest terror alert level, it is understandable that people feared the worst when a priest was shot two days after Nice.

Macron and the protests abroad

President Emmanuel Macron had given a speech in early October announcing measures against what he called "Islamist separatism", arguing that some communities were withdrawing from French society. After Paty's murder he strongly defended the right to publish caricatures, describing it as part of French freedom of expression.

His remarks provoked anger in many Muslim-majority countries. Protesters burned French flags and images of Macron in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Lebanon and elsewhere, and there were calls to boycott French products. At a large rally in Dhaka, the BBC reported one organiser telling the crowd that "we won't tolerate anybody making fun of our beloved Prophet."

The former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad caused outrage on the day of the Nice attack with a series of posts saying Muslims had a right to be angry and "to kill millions of French people" over past massacres. Twitter removed the post for glorifying violence, and he was widely condemned, including by the French government. Our separate report covers his statement.

French secularism in brief

France's tradition of laïcité, set out in a 1905 law, separates religion and the state. State schools do not teach religion as a subject, apart from a historical exception in Alsace-Moselle. A 2004 law bans conspicuous religious symbols, including Islamic headscarves, in public primary and secondary schools, and a 2010 law bans face coverings such as the niqab and burqa in public places. Supporters see these rules as protecting neutrality and equality; critics argue they fall hardest on Muslim women.

Terrorism in France since 2015

France has suffered a long series of jihadist attacks. In January 2015 gunmen killed 12 people at the Charlie Hebdo offices, followed by the killing of four hostages at a kosher supermarket. In November 2015 coordinated attacks in Paris, including at the Bataclan concert hall, killed 130 people. On 14 July 2016 a man drove a truck into crowds on the Promenade des Anglais in Nice, killing 86. (Some accounts mistakenly place that truck attack in Marseille.) Together these and other attacks have killed more than 250 people in France since 2015.

That history explains the fear in October 2020. It also explains why careful reporting matters: linking an unrelated crime to terrorism without evidence can inflame tensions and point suspicion at people who had nothing to do with it.

Sources: Thinking Humanity: initial suspect released; Wikipédia: Attentat de la basilique Notre-Dame de Nice; BBC News: protests against Macron.

COMMENTS