Mahathir Mohamad's Post After the Nice Attack: What He Said

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-30.

Mahathir Mohamad's 2020 Remarks After the Nice Attack

On 29 October 2020, hours after a knife attack killed three people in a church in Nice, Malaysia's former Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad published a long series of posts about France. One sentence stood out and travelled around the world: "Muslims have a right to be angry and to kill millions of French people for the massacres of the past." Twitter removed it, saying it glorified violence, Facebook also took it down, and French ministers and foreign diplomats condemned it. Mahathir, then 95, said he had been quoted out of context.

This article sets out what he wrote, how the platforms and governments reacted, and the events in France that formed the background: the Nice basilica attack, the murder of the teacher Samuel Paty and the long-running dispute over secularism and religious caricatures.

What Mahathir wrote

Mahathir served as Malaysia's prime minister for 22 years, from 1981 to 2003, and again from 2018 to 2020, which made him one of the most experienced political figures in Asia. In his October 2020 posts, published on his blog and shared on Twitter, where he reportedly had more than a million followers, he attacked President Emmanuel Macron, accusing him of blaming Islam and Muslims for the killing of Samuel Paty. He argued that angry people kill regardless of their religion and that France had killed millions of people, many of them Muslims, during its colonial history.

It was in that context that he wrote the sentence about a "right" to kill millions of French people. He continued by saying that, by and large, Muslims had not applied an "eye for an eye" principle and that the French should not either, and he urged France to teach its people to respect other people's feelings.

Platforms remove the post, and his defence

Critics flagged the post to Twitter within the first hour. Among them, according to British media reports, was Brian Klaas, a political scientist at University College London, who called it an incitement to mass killing by a former head of government with a huge following. Twitter removed the tweet, saying it glorified violence; Facebook deleted the post under its hate-speech rules. France's digital minister asked Twitter to ban Mahathir from the platform altogether.

Diplomats also spoke up. The United States ambassador to Malaysia said she strongly disagreed, and Australia's High Commissioner warned that in the current climate words can have consequences.

Mahathir rejected the criticism. He said he was disgusted by attempts to misrepresent what he had written, insisted that critics had left out the next sentence about Muslims not seeking revenge, and accused the platforms of hypocrisy for removing his words while defending the right to publish caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad. Readers can judge the full passage for themselves; many argued that framing mass killing as a "right", even in a passage that then counsels restraint, was dangerous on a day when people had just been murdered in a church.

The Nice basilica attack

The attack happened at about 8:30 in the morning on 29 October 2020 at Notre-Dame de Nice, a Catholic basilica on Avenue Jean Médecin in the city centre. A man armed with a knife killed a 60-year-old woman who had been praying, the church's 55-year-old sexton, and a 44-year-old Brazilian-born Frenchwoman who escaped with stab wounds to a nearby café, where she died. Police shot and wounded the attacker.

He was Brahim Aouissaoui, a 21-year-old Tunisian who had arrived by boat on the Italian island of Lampedusa in late September 2020. Italy ordered him to leave the country, but he was not monitored, and he travelled by train to Nice, arriving roughly a day before the attack. Macron called it an Islamist terrorist attack and announced extra security at schools and places of worship. In February 2025 a French court sentenced Aouissaoui to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

The attack was condemned by many governments and religious bodies, including in Muslim-majority countries such as Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Iran and Pakistan. Canada's Justin Trudeau stressed that the attackers did not represent Islam or Muslims, a point worth repeating: the crime belongs to the person who committed it, not to a faith shared by nearly two billion people.

Samuel Paty and the cartoons row

Thirteen days earlier, on 16 October 2020, Samuel Paty, a history and geography teacher, was murdered and beheaded near his school in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine, west of Paris. During a lesson on freedom of expression he had shown caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad published by the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo. A student's father led an online campaign against him; the student later admitted she had not even attended the class and had lied about it.

The killer, Abdoullakh Anzorov, was an 18-year-old of Chechen origin who had come to France as a child with his refugee family. Police shot him dead minutes after the murder. French courts later convicted several people connected to the case, including the student's father and an imam who joined his campaign, in trials in 2023 and 2024.

Macron's defence of the cartoons on free-speech grounds after Paty's death provoked protests and calls for boycotts of French products in several Muslim-majority countries. Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was among the loudest critics. Mahathir's posts came at the height of this storm.

Laïcité, the veil laws and the facts

Much of the anger turned on French secularism, known as laïcité. Since 1905 France has separated church and state. The principle requires the state, including public schools, to be neutral about religion, while individuals remain free to believe and worship as they wish.

Two laws are often mentioned in this debate, and they are sometimes described loosely:

  • The 2004 school law bans conspicuous religious symbols in state primary and secondary schools. It applies to all religions, covering items such as large crosses, kippahs and turbans as well as Islamic headscarves.
  • The 2010 face-covering law, in force since 11 April 2011, bans clothing that covers the face, such as the niqab or burqa, in public places, with exceptions for health, work and sport. Breaking it can bring a fine of up to €150, while forcing someone to cover their face is a far more serious offence. The European Court of Human Rights upheld the law in 2014.

Supporters see these rules as protecting equality and shared public space; critics see them as falling hardest on Muslim women. Both views are part of a legitimate democratic debate. None of it, on any side, justifies violence.

Why the words caused alarm

Statements by retired leaders often pass with little notice. This one did not, for clear reasons. It came from a man who had led a modern, prosperous country for more than two decades; it was published on the very day of a deadly attack; and it described the killing of millions of civilians as something a group had a "right" to do. Even read with the sentences around it, the line could be clipped and shared as encouragement by people looking for one.

The episode is also a reminder to keep blame precise. Mahathir's words were his own. They did not represent Malaysians, and they did not represent Muslims, many of whom condemned both the Nice attack and his remarks. Precise attribution is the best defence against the collective blame that extremists of every kind want to provoke.

For more on the attacker's background, see our report on the man who killed three in Nice weeks after arriving from Tunisia.

Sources: Al Jazeera, 30 October 2020: Malaysia's Mahathir says post on French killings taken out of context; Wikipedia: 2020 Nice stabbing; Wikipedia: Murder of Samuel Paty; Wikipedia: French ban on face covering; Wikipedia: Mahathir Mohamad. Brian Klaas's comments were reported by The Independent.

COMMENTS