Originally published 2020-10-01.
Timothy Ray Brown, the American known worldwide as the "Berlin patient" and the first person known to have been cured of HIV, died on 29 September 2020 at his home in Palm Springs, California. He was 54. The cause was not HIV but a return of the leukaemia that had led to his life-saving transplants more than a decade earlier. His Berlin doctor, Gero Hütter, said Brown still appeared to be free of HIV when cancer took his life.
Brown's case changed how scientists think about HIV. Before him, a cure was widely seen as impossible. Here is his story, how the treatment worked, why it cannot simply be given to everyone with HIV, and what it led to.
Who Timothy Ray Brown was
Brown was born in Seattle on 11 March 1966 and raised by his mother, Sharon. In the 1990s he moved to Berlin to study. In 1995 he tested positive for HIV and began antiretroviral treatment, which kept the virus under control for years.
In 2006 he was diagnosed with acute myeloid leukaemia (AML), an aggressive blood cancer. Chemotherapy alone was not enough, and his doctors in Berlin decided he needed a stem cell transplant, often called a bone marrow transplant. That decision set up a medical first.
The transplant that cleared his HIV
Gero Hütter, then a young haematologist, knew that a small share of people of northern European ancestry carry two copies of a mutation called CCR5-Δ32. CCR5 is a receptor on the surface of immune cells that most strains of HIV use as a doorway. People with two copies of the mutation lack a working version of that doorway and are highly resistant to infection.
Hütter searched for a donor who was both a tissue match for Brown and carried the double mutation. He found one. On 7 February 2007 Brown received the transplant and stopped his HIV medication. The virus did not come back. His leukaemia, however, returned, and in 2008 he underwent a second transplant from the same donor.
The treatment was brutal. Brown went through intense chemotherapy and whole-body radiation, developed graft-versus-host disease and suffered neurological damage that affected his memory and speech for a long time. Doctors later stressed that the approach was justified only because he needed a transplant to survive cancer anyway.
Tests over the following years found no replicating HIV in his blood or tissue, even without medication. His case was presented anonymously at a major AIDS conference in 2008, and the medical world began calling him the Berlin patient.
Stepping out of anonymity
In 2010 Brown decided to go public with his name and face. In a 2015 personal reflection in the journal AIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, he explained the choice in simple terms: "I did not want to be the only person in the world cured of HIV."
He became an advocate for cure research, speaking at conferences and meeting scientists around the world. In July 2012 he launched the Timothy Ray Brown Foundation in Washington, D.C., to support work on HIV cures. He told interviewers he was glad he had the transplant because it motivated researchers to keep looking.
In 2019 his leukaemia came back. In September 2020 he shared that he was terminally ill and moved into hospice care at home. His partner, Tim Hoeffgen, announced his death on social media.
Tributes from the scientific world
The International AIDS Society said Brown and Hütter deserved deep gratitude for showing scientists that an HIV cure was a realistic goal. Hütter said Brown symbolised that it is possible, under special circumstances, to rid a patient of the virus, something many experts had doubted.
Professor Sharon Lewin, who then led the Doherty Institute in Melbourne and later became president of the IAS, made a similar point: the transplant route could never be a large-scale cure, but Brown's case marked a turning point in the search for one.
Why the Berlin cure cannot be given to everyone
It is tempting to ask why this treatment is not offered to all 39 million or so people living with HIV. The answer is that a stem cell transplant is one of the riskiest procedures in medicine. Patients must have their own immune system largely wiped out, which leaves them open to deadly infections for months. A meaningful share of patients die from complications, and finding a matching donor with two copies of CCR5-Δ32 is extremely difficult.
For someone with HIV who is otherwise healthy, those risks would be far worse than the condition itself, because modern treatment works so well. Transplant-based cures are therefore considered only for people who already need a transplant to treat a blood cancer.
Claims circulating in 2020 that six more people had already been cured by transplants were overstated. At the time of Brown's death, only one other case was widely accepted: Adam Castillejo, the "London patient," who had a transplant for Hodgkin lymphoma in 2016 from a donor with the same mutation and went public in early 2020. Since then, a handful of further cases have been reported from Düsseldorf, New York, California and elsewhere, still a tiny number compared with the millions living with the virus.
What his legacy means for people with HIV today
Brown's case pushed researchers towards ideas that could one day work for many more people: gene therapies that edit a person's own cells to remove CCR5, treatments that flush hidden virus from reservoirs in the body, and antibodies that might keep HIV under control without daily pills. In July 2020, for example, scientists reported that a Brazilian man may have entered long-term remission after an intensive drug regimen, a result that still needs confirmation.
Meanwhile, the everyday picture for people with HIV has transformed since the 1980s. With early diagnosis and consistent antiretroviral treatment, many people now live close to a normal lifespan, and someone whose virus is kept undetectable does not pass HIV to sexual partners. Anyone with questions about testing or treatment should talk to a doctor or a local sexual health clinic.
Timothy Ray Brown did not live to see a cure for everyone. But by agreeing to a risky experiment and then telling the world about it, he turned a single extraordinary case into a lasting source of hope and research.
Sources: Wikipedia: Timothy Ray Brown; Associated Press via ABC7 New York: Timothy Ray Brown, 1st person cured of HIV, dies of cancer (1 October 2020); Timothy Ray Brown, AIDS Research and Human Retroviruses (2015); BBC News: First person cured of HIV dies (2020).

COMMENTS