Originally published 2020-10-16.

Photo: Baby River with her mother Reina Mae Nasino at hospital on the day of her birth. Copyright: Kapatid
River Nasino was born in mid-2020 to Reina Mae Nasino, a young Filipino activist held in a Manila jail. A court refused to let mother and baby stay together, and River was handed to her grandmother. She fell ill with pneumonia and died in October 2020, at about three months old. Her mother was allowed out only briefly, under guard and in handcuffs, for the funeral. In July 2023 a Manila court acquitted Nasino of the weapons charges that had kept her in jail.
River's short life became a symbol, both in the Philippines and abroad, of how harsh pre-trial detention can be and of the wider crackdown on activists under President Rodrigo Duterte.
The arrest and the charges
In November 2019 police raided the office of the left-wing alliance Bayan in Tondo, Manila, as part of a wider operation against activist groups. Nasino, who worked with urban poor communities, was arrested along with Alma Moran and Ram Carlo Bautista. Police said they found firearms, ammunition and explosives, and the three were charged with illegal possession.
The activists denied the charges from the start. They and their supporters said the evidence had been planted and that they were victims of "red-tagging", the practice of labelling government critics as communist rebels. Because the charges were treated as non-bailable at first, they stayed in jail while the case went on.
A baby born in custody
After her arrest, Nasino discovered she was pregnant. She gave birth to River in a Manila hospital in mid-2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic. Her lawyers asked the court to let her keep the baby with her for longer, or to release her on humanitarian grounds so she could care for and breastfeed her daughter.
The court refused, citing the jail's lack of facilities for infants. Detained mothers in the Philippines were generally allowed to keep newborns with them only for a short period. Roughly a month after birth, River was separated from her mother and taken home by her grandmother.
The National Union of Peoples' Lawyers, which represented Nasino, criticised the decision sharply, telling the BBC that "compassion and mercy were not extended to mother and child." Nasino, they said, had pleaded to keep her baby longer.
River's illness and death
Within weeks River fell ill and was admitted to hospital with pneumonia. She died in early October 2020. Nasino was not able to be with her in her final days.
Medical records and the specific care decisions are what establish why a baby becomes ill; the timing alone does not prove that the separation caused her death. Still, many doctors and child-rights advocates point out that breastfeeding and close contact help protect young infants against infections, and the court's refusal drew widespread criticism.
The funeral added to the public anger. Nasino was granted a few hours' leave to attend, but she was escorted by armed jail guards and police in protective gear, and her handcuffs stayed on, so she could not hold her daughter's coffin freely. Images from the day were shared around the world.
The wider context: Duterte and human rights
The case unfolded during a period of intense criticism of the Philippine government's human rights record. Rodrigo Duterte became president in 2016 promising a ruthless campaign against illegal drugs. Thousands of suspected users and dealers were killed in police operations and by unidentified gunmen, and rights groups documented a sharp rise in threats against activists, journalists and lawyers.
Before the presidency, Duterte spent more than two decades as mayor of Davao City, where human rights groups linked a so-called Davao Death Squad to more than 1,400 killings and disappearances of alleged criminals, including petty offenders and street children. In 2005 he said that "summary execution of criminals remains the most effective way to crush kidnapping and illegal drugs."
For years he denied running any death squad, and a 2016 ombudsman's inquiry found no evidence tying him to the killings. In October 2024, however, he told a Senate hearing that he had maintained such a squad. He has also claimed in the past that he shot a fellow student while at law school, a story that has never been independently verified.
The International Criminal Court began investigating the drug-war killings, including those in Davao, even after the Philippines withdrew from the court in 2019. In March 2025 Duterte was arrested in Manila and flown to The Hague to face charges of crimes against humanity. Proceedings against him are continuing.
Acquittal in 2023
The case against Nasino eventually fell apart. In December 2022 she, Moran and Bautista were released after the court allowed bail. In July 2023 Judge John Benedict Medina of the Manila Regional Trial Court, Branch 47, acquitted all three of illegal possession of firearms and explosives.
The judge found the prosecution's evidence "flawed and deficient." Conflicting testimony from the officers involved left serious doubt about whether the weapons had been found in the activists' rooms at all. After nearly four years, about three of them in jail, Nasino was cleared, but nothing could return the months she lost with her daughter.
What the case shows about mothers in detention
River's story raises questions that go beyond one country:
- Pre-trial detention. Nasino was legally innocent throughout and was eventually acquitted. People held while awaiting trial bear the full weight of prison life without a conviction.
- Mothers and babies. The United Nations rules on the treatment of women prisoners, known as the Bangkok Rules, encourage non-custodial options for pregnant women and mothers of young children where possible, and call for decisions to keep a child with a parent to be based on the child's best interests.
- Accountability. Cases that rest on disputed raid evidence need careful judicial scrutiny, because the cost of a wrong decision can be irreversible.
River Nasino lived for only a few months. Her name is still invoked in the Philippines by people campaigning for the release of political detainees and for more humane treatment of mothers behind bars.
Sources: BBC News, October 2020; Philippine Daily Inquirer, 28 July 2023: 3 activists acquitted, including mom who lost baby River; Wikipedia: Davao Death Squad; Human Rights Watch, 2015 (archived); Inquirer, 2016, on Duterte's law-school shooting claim; photo credit: Kapatid.

COMMENTS