Storm Alex 2020: Deadly Floods in the French and Italian Alps

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-10-03.

Storm Alex struck south-east France and north-west Italy on 2 and 3 October 2020, dropping more rain in a single day than some Alpine valleys normally see in three months. Rivers in the Vésubie, Roya and Tinée valleys behind Nice tore away roads, bridges and houses, while Piedmont and Liguria on the Italian side recorded their wettest days in decades. In the first hours after the storm, two deaths were confirmed in Italy and around two dozen people were reported missing. As searches went on, the toll grew: by 9 October at least six people were known to have died and some 20 were still unaccounted for, and across Europe the storm was linked to at least 15 deaths.

Storm Alex in France and Italy: An October 2020 Report

What happened on 2 and 3 October

Alex began as an Atlantic depression. It deepened very quickly west of the British Isles and reached western France on the night of 1 to 2 October, with gusts of up to 186 km/h recorded on Belle-Île-en-Mer off Brittany, a record for that station. Météo-France had issued red wind warnings for parts of the north-west.

The wind made the headlines first, but the rain did the real damage, and it fell hundreds of kilometres away. As the system moved inland it pulled a stream of warm, very humid air up from the Mediterranean and pushed it against the Maritime Alps. Forced upwards over the mountains, that air wrung out its moisture for hours on end over the same narrow valleys.

The result was a flash flood of a kind few people living there had ever experienced. Mountain torrents that are usually ankle-deep in autumn became walls of brown water carrying boulders, trees and cars. Riverside roads, which in these steep valleys are often the only way in or out, were simply erased.

Record rainfall on both sides of the border

The figures are striking even by the standards of a region used to violent autumn storms. According to the Copernicus Climate Change Service, Mons in the Alpes-Maritimes received 571 mm of rain on 2 October and Saint-Martin-Vésubie 500 mm, each more than three months of normal October rainfall and both new daily records for the area. Around Nice, close to a full year's average rainfall fell in under 12 hours.

Italy was hit just as hard. Sambughetto in Piedmont measured about 630 mm in 24 hours, and Limone Piemonte, a ski resort just over the Col de Tende, recorded well over 500 mm. Piedmont logged its highest totals since its regional records began in 1951; early news reports compared the downpour with 1958, the previous benchmark many locals remembered. Rivers including the Sesia, Tanaro, Po and Roya burst their banks, and in Liguria the flood wave brought down an old Roman bridge over the Roya near Fanghetto.

Villages cut off in the Vésubie and Roya valleys

The worst destruction in France was concentrated in a few mountain communes north of Nice. Saint-Martin-Vésubie, a town of about 1,400 people, was isolated when the road along the river collapsed, and some riverside houses were swept away entirely. Villages further east in the Roya valley, such as Tende and Breil-sur-Roya, were cut off in a similar way, and rescuers relied heavily on helicopters to reach them. Nice's mayor, Christian Estrosi, flew over the area and described it as the worst flooding there in more than a century, saying around a hundred houses had been destroyed or partly destroyed.

Footage filmed in Saint-Martin-Vésubie captured a bridge giving way as the swollen river undercut it. The clip was widely shared at the time.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

On the Italian side, a three-storey house in Limone Piemonte was lifted off its foundations and dragged into the river, and in the Tanaro valley a cemetery was torn open by floodwater, scattering coffins downstream. Mud buried streets and ground floors from Ventimiglia to the Aosta Valley.

The victims, the missing and the rescuers

Early counts shifted quickly, as they always do after a flash flood, because many people who were "missing" had simply lost phone signal or power. Of roughly 24 people listed as missing on 3 October, around 16 were in Piedmont, most of them travellers caught on the Col de Tende road between the two countries. Among them, according to Italian officials quoted at the time, were two German grandparents travelling with their grandchildren. Bernard Gonzalez, the prefect of the Alpes-Maritimes, urged families not to lose hope, pointing out that silence did not necessarily mean someone had been taken by the water.

The first two deaths were both in Italy: a volunteer firefighter was killed by a falling tree during a rescue in the Aosta Valley, and a man was found dead in Vercelli province after being swept away. In France, two firefighters from the Alpes-Maritimes fire service went missing when the road collapsed beneath their vehicle during a rescue mission. In the following days several bodies washed up on the Italian Riviera between Ventimiglia and Santo Stefano al Mare, and investigators believed some had been carried down the Roya from France.

The fire and rescue service of the Alpes-Maritimes (SDIS 06), which posted regular updates on Facebook, said on 2 October that 850 firefighters, 348 of them reinforcements from outside the department, would be deployed that day. In its messages it expressed solidarity with the families of the missing and with its two missing colleagues. Within days, around 1,000 firefighters supported by the army and helicopters were working in the Roya valley alone.

#TempeteAlex // 850 pompiers dont 348 en renfort extérieur seront aujourd'hui mobilisés sur l'ensemble du département...

Posted by Sapeurs-pompiers 06 - SDIS 06 on Friday, 2 October 2020

A note on a common mix-up: some early English-language reports described the "two fellow firefighters" tribute as coming from Italy. The post came from the French department's own fire service, and it referred to its two missing firefighters in the Alpes-Maritimes.

After the flood: sediment, damage and rebuilding

When the skies cleared on 3 October, the European Copernicus Sentinel-2 satellite photographed brown plumes of sediment pouring into the Mediterranean from rivers around Nice and the Riviera di Ponente in Italy. Beaches in Nice were closed because the sea pushed mud and debris back onto the shore.

The floods were followed by a long and costly recovery. Hundreds of homes, bridges and roads were destroyed, and power, telephone and water networks failed across the affected valleys. Rail services were cut, including in the Roya valley, where the line between Nice and Piedmont runs. For residents of villages with a single access road, daily life depended for weeks on temporary tracks, helicopter drops and solidarity from neighbouring towns. Rivers continued to rise for some time after the rain eased, as water drained down from the high slopes, so alerts stayed in place well beyond the storm itself.

Was climate change to blame?

Many people immediately linked Storm Alex to global warming. The honest answer is more nuanced. Heavy autumn rain in this corner of the Mediterranean, known in France as an "épisode méditerranéen", is not new: warm sea water in September and October has always fed intense storms here. What scientists can say is that a warmer atmosphere holds more water vapour, roughly 7% more for each degree Celsius, which gives storms more fuel.

The data point in that direction. Météo-France has reported a 22% increase in the annual maximum daily rainfall in Mediterranean extremes between 1961 and 2015, along with more frequent downpours of over 200 mm in 24 hours. At the same time, the Copernicus Climate Change Service noted that events as rare as Alex are hard to analyse for trends, because there are so few comparable cases on record. A fair summary is that climate change is making the ingredients for such floods more common, without any single storm being caused by it alone.

What people in flood-prone valleys can take from it

Disaster experts drew familiar lessons from Alex: take red and orange rain warnings seriously, avoid driving on valley-floor roads during intense rain, never try to cross a flooded road or bridge, and know an escape route to higher ground. Most deaths in flash floods involve people in vehicles or near riverbanks, which is why authorities urge people to stay put somewhere high and safe rather than try to outrun the water.

Sources: Copernicus Climate Change Service: European State of the Climate 2020, Storm Alex; Belgian Science Policy Office (9 October 2020); Al Jazeera (3 October 2020); The New Daily / AAP (5 October 2020); Wikipedia: Storm Alex; SDIS 06 Alpes-Maritimes on Facebook.

COMMENTS