What WWF’s 68% Living Planet Index Decline Actually Meant

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Images accompanying WWF’s Living Planet Report 2020

Photos: WWF Living Planet Report 2020, Left: © Svalbard Global Seed Vault / Riccardo Gangale, Right: © naturepl.com / Andy Rouse / WWF

The Living Planet Report 2020 presented a stark finding: the global index of monitored vertebrate populations fell by an average of 68 percent between 1970 and 2016. The underlying dataset included 20,811 populations representing 4,392 species of mammals, birds, fish, reptiles and amphibians.

The freshwater index showed an average decline of 84 percent over the same period. These figures describe trends assembled from monitored populations. They are not a count showing that 68 percent of all wild animals, or 84 percent of every freshwater species, had disappeared.

WWF identified human pressures on nature as the central concern, including land-use change, exploitation, pollution and climate change. Its announcement highlighted the conversion of natural habitats to agriculture as a major direct driver of biodiversity loss. The report connected those pressures with the ways societies produce food, consume resources and develop land.




In WWF’s September 2020 announcement, its US president and CEO, Carter Roberts, said:


"This report reminds us that we destroy the planet at our peril — because it is our home. As humanity's footprint expands into once-wild places, we're devastating species populations. But we're also exacerbating climate change and increasing the risk of zoonotic diseases like COVID-19. We cannot shield humanity from the impacts of environmental destruction. It's time to restore our broken relationship with nature for the benefit of species and people alike."


Published during the COVID-19 pandemic, WWF’s announcement also linked environmental disruption with concerns about diseases passing between animals and people. The population index itself is not a test of the origin of a particular disease; the health discussion formed part of the wider case for protecting ecosystems.

The warning that around one million animal and plant species face extinction comes from the separate 2019 IPBES Global Assessment. That estimate concerns extinction risk, a different measure from changes in monitored population sizes. The two findings describe related pressures on nature without being interchangeable statistics.

Agriculture is important in both land and water use. In November 2021, FAO reported survey findings attributing almost 90 percent of global deforestation to agricultural expansion, with conversion to cropland and livestock grazing making different contributions. This later finding gives a dated reference for the scale of land conversion.

For water, FAO’s AQUASTAT methodological overview gives agriculture’s share of global withdrawals as 69 percent, close to the often-rounded figure of 70 percent. Withdrawal means water taken from a source; it is not the same as water permanently consumed, and some returns to the environment after use. Regional shares also differ substantially.



In the same 2020 announcement, WWF global chief scientist Rebecca Shaw emphasised the possibility of change:


"While the trends are alarming, there is reason to remain optimistic. Young generations are becoming acutely aware of the link between planetary health and their own futures, and they are demanding action from our leaders. We must support them in their fight for a just and sustainable planet."


WWF called for changes in food production and consumption, action on climate change and investment in conserving and restoring nature. Its message combined a warning about the direction of change with the argument that different choices could alter that direction. The figures were intended to inform action, rather than describe an inevitable endpoint.

The figure measures population trends

A population is a group of animals of one species in a particular setting. One species can therefore contribute several monitored populations, each with its own history. Combining those records allows researchers to look for a wider pattern without pretending that every group followed the same path.

The index’s methodology page explains that records may use population size, density, abundance per sample or a suitable proxy, such as nest counts. The essential requirement is a series of observations over time. A single photograph or one count, however interesting, cannot by itself show a trend.

The index includes increasing and stable populations as well as declining ones. A falling global result does not mean every monitored species is declining, and the headline percentage is not the proportion of species that became extinct. These distinctions help connect the summary statistic to the observations behind it.

From a global index to local conservation

For a local conservation decision, the global figure is a starting point. Managers still need to know what is happening to the relevant population, which pressures it faces and whether an intervention is helping. A broad index can signal a serious pattern while local evidence guides the response.

The dates also matter. The 2020 report’s headline trend ended in 2016, so its publication year is not the final year of the underlying series. Later editions can incorporate additional records and a longer period. Comparing headlines without checking those changes can create the impression that unlike measurements are directly interchangeable.

Read in context, the 68 percent figure remains a substantial warning about monitored wildlife trends. Its value is clearer when the population measure, the species covered and the period are kept together. That understanding supports a more useful discussion of conservation than turning the index into an imagined count of every animal left on Earth.

COMMENTS