Slovenian Woman Who Sawed Off Her Hand Jailed for Insurance Fraud

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-13.

In September 2020 a court in Ljubljana convicted Julija Adlešič, a 22-year-old Slovenian woman, of attempted insurance fraud after prosecutors showed she had deliberately cut off her own hand to collect more than €1 million from insurers. She was sentenced to two years in prison. Her boyfriend received three years, and his father a one-year suspended sentence. No insurer ever paid out the money they were hoping for.

A Slovenian Insurance-Fraud Case Reported in 2020

The verdict in Ljubljana

The judgment was delivered on Friday 11 September 2020. The court found that the loss of Adlešič’s hand in early 2019 was not an accident but the centre of a planned scheme. Because the payout never happened, the charge was attempted fraud rather than completed fraud.

The sentences were:

  • Julija Adlešič: two years in prison;
  • her boyfriend: three years in prison, as the person prosecutors said had pushed the plan;
  • the boyfriend’s father: one year, suspended.

Reporters noted that she kept her reattached hand hidden under a blanket during the sentencing hearing.

How the plan was supposed to work

According to the prosecution, the preparation began in 2018, when Adlešič took out five separate insurance policies on herself, each paying out for serious injury. Taken together, the policies stood to pay more than €1 million, about $1.2 million at the exchange rates of the time.

In early 2019 her left hand was severed just above the wrist with a circular saw. Her boyfriend and his father drove her to hospital and said she had been hurt while cutting tree branches. They did not bring the hand with them. Investigators believed this was intentional, because a hand that cannot be reattached means a permanent disability and therefore the largest possible claim.

What gave the scheme away

The missing hand was the first warning sign. Doctors and police found it odd that a family rushing an injured relative to the emergency room would leave the severed limb behind. Police went to the house, recovered the hand and got it to surgeons in time for it to be sewn back on. That probably saved much of her future use of it, and it also undercut the claim of a total loss.

Investigators then examined the boyfriend’s internet history. Shortly before the injury, he had searched for information on prosthetic hands. Prosecutors argued that this showed the amputation was planned and that he had talked her into giving up her hand for money. The cluster of new policies taken out the year before added to the picture.

The age of the people involved also stood out. Adlešič was 20 when she lost her hand, and insurers selling accident and disability cover to a young adult would not usually expect five overlapping policies within a short period. Each policy on its own may have looked ordinary; it was the combination, followed so soon by a catastrophic claim, that drew attention.

The case also shows how modern investigations work. Very little depended on a confession. Physical evidence from the scene, the timeline of the policies and the record of what had been searched online together told the court more than any of the accused were willing to say.

Her side of the story

Adlešič denied the charges throughout the trial, insisting it had been an accident and that nobody would deliberately maim themselves. After the verdict she told reporters:

“No one wants to be crippled. My youth has been destroyed. I lost my hand at the age of 20. Only I know how it happened.”

Some commentators wondered whether a young woman could have been pressured into the act by people around her, and the boyfriend’s heavier sentence reflects the court’s view that he played the leading role. Still, the court found her guilty as a willing participant. Under Slovenian law the verdict could be appealed, and we have not found reliable reports on the outcome of any appeal.

Why self-injury fraud keeps happening

Cases like this are rare but not unique. Insurance investigators around the world have documented people who cut off fingers, hands or feet to claim on accident or disability policies. Over the years such schemes have even earned slang nicknames in insurance circles. What links them is a large potential payout tied to a specific, permanent injury.

The money involved helps explain the temptation. Slovenia’s average net monthly wage was about €1,100 in 2018, so a €1 million claim would have represented decades of ordinary earnings. That does not make the act less shocking, but it shows how a large lump sum can distort judgement, especially for young people with few prospects or for those under the influence of someone else.

How insurers spot staged injuries

The same red flags that tripped up this family are ones investigators routinely look for:

  • Several policies bought shortly before a claim, especially from different companies and with high payouts for one type of injury.
  • Accounts that do not match the injury, such as a clean cut described as a garden accident.
  • Behaviour that maximises the loss, like leaving a severed limb behind or delaying treatment.
  • Digital traces, including web searches, messages and purchases made before the event.

Insurers share information on suspicious claims, and large payouts trigger closer checks. A staged injury carries a double cost: a lifelong disability for the person hurt, and, if discovered, a criminal record and prison time instead of the money.

A case with no winners

The Slovenian case drew attention worldwide because it is hard to imagine anyone choosing such a loss. In the end the plan collapsed at almost every stage. The hand was saved, the policies paid nothing, and three members of one family were convicted. For anyone in serious financial trouble, debt advice services and social support, however slow, offer a far better path than any scheme that relies on harming yourself.

Sources: Global News, 14 September 2020: Woman who sawed off hand for $1 million insurance payout found guilty; Metro, 12 September 2020: Woman deliberately cut off own hand to scam insurance companies; Wikipedia: List of European countries by average wage (Slovenia). Photo: PA Images.

COMMENTS