Originally published 2020-09-05.

Photo: Spencer Platt / Getty Images
On 2 September 2020, President Donald Trump signed a memorandum ordering federal agencies to review the money they send to New York City, Portland, Seattle and Washington, D.C., which he accused of allowing "anarchy, violence, and destruction" during that summer's protests. In short: it was a review, not an instant cut. The Justice Department later labelled three of the cities "anarchist jurisdictions", the cities sued, no major funding cut took effect, and President Joe Biden revoked the memo in February 2021.
Here is what the order said, why those cities were singled out, and why cutting their funding was much harder than the announcement suggested.
The summer that led to the memo
The killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer on 25 May 2020 set off one of the largest protest movements in US history. Millions of people took part in demonstrations against police brutality and racism over the following months. Most were peaceful, but some cities also saw looting, arson and clashes with police, and the unrest was widely described as the most serious since the late 1960s.
Several cities faced loud calls to cut police budgets, and some councils did move money away from their police departments. Debates over defunding or rebuilding police forces became a central political argument of the year.
Portland saw around a hundred consecutive nights of protest. In July, the administration sent federal officers there to protect a federal courthouse, which drew criticism from local leaders and further protests. In Seattle, demonstrators held several blocks of the Capitol Hill neighbourhood for close to a month in June, an area known first as the Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone and later as the Capitol Hill Occupied Protest.
What the 2 September memo said
The memorandum was titled "Reviewing Funding to State and Local Government Recipients That Are Permitting Anarchy, Violence, and Destruction in American Cities". Its main points were:
- A list of jurisdictions. Attorney General William Barr was told to identify state and local governments that, in the administration's view, had allowed violence and property destruction to continue and had refused reasonable steps to stop it.
- A funding review. Federal agencies were directed to report on the grants they gave to those places and how they might be limited, with guidance coming from the White House budget office.
- Named targets. New York, Portland, Seattle and Washington, D.C. were mentioned by name, and the memo singled out New York's Governor Andrew Cuomo and Mayor Bill de Blasio, both Democrats.
The memo pointed to falling arrest numbers in New York during the summer and to the city's decision to move about one billion dollars away from the NYPD budget, including cancelling a planned class of new recruits. Critics, including some council members, noted that a good part of that "cut" came from shifting functions such as school safety to other departments rather than removing spending outright.
The Justice Department's list
On 21 September 2020, the Justice Department named New York City, Portland and Seattle as "anarchist jurisdictions". Washington, D.C., which the president had mentioned in the memo, was not on the list. The department said it had weighed four main questions:
- Did the city stop its police from intervening during sustained violence?
- Did it withdraw police from areas they were legally entitled to enter?
- Did it disband or significantly defund its police department?
- Did it unreasonably refuse federal law-enforcement help?
For each city, the department cited rising shootings, budget changes and the refusal of federal help. In New York it pointed to sharp increases in shootings in July and August compared with 2019. In Seattle it cited the Capitol Hill protest zone, where police were kept out and two teenagers were later shot dead. In Portland it highlighted months of nightly clashes and a council decision to cut about $15 million from the police budget.
Why cutting the money was so difficult
The president cannot simply switch off federal funding to a city. Under the US Constitution, Congress controls spending, and most federal grants are set by laws that define who qualifies and what conditions apply. Agencies can only add conditions that Congress has authorised, and courts expect those conditions to be clear and related to the purpose of the grant.
This was not new legal ground. Earlier in the Trump administration, the Justice Department had tried to attach immigration-enforcement conditions to policing grants for so-called sanctuary cities. Several federal courts ruled against parts of that policy, and New York's officials pointed to their own win in that fight when responding to the new memo.
The sums involved were large. Local reporting at the time estimated that New York City received around $7 billion in federal funds that could in theory be affected, from food and housing aid to school programmes. Much of that money supports low-income residents, which made any cut politically and legally risky.
How the cities responded
The reaction was immediate. Mayor de Blasio called the designation unconstitutional and "just another one of President Trump's games", and promised to sue if any money was withheld. Governor Cuomo argued that Congress, not the president, decides how appropriated money is spent. New York's Attorney General Letitia James also said the state would fight it in court.
In October 2020, Seattle, Portland and New York filed a joint federal lawsuit to overturn the designation. The three mayors accused the administration of playing political games with money Congress had directed to their communities. In Portland, local officials pointed out that the first funding reportedly considered for a cut, around $1.8 million in grants for health centres treating COVID-19 patients, actually went to the county rather than the city.
How it ended
The order came about two months before the 2020 election, with Trump trailing Biden in national polls and making "law and order" a central campaign message. Supporters saw the memo as a firm response to disorder; opponents saw it as an election-year attempt to punish Democratic-led cities.
The designation never produced a broad funding cut. On 24 February 2021, a month after taking office, President Biden signed an executive order revoking a group of his predecessor's actions, and the "anarchist jurisdiction" memo was among them. Seattle's city government welcomed the decision, and a spokesman for Portland's mayor said it was good to have a federal partner instead of an opponent.
The episode remains a useful reminder of the limits of executive power over federal money. Presidents can review, delay and pressure, but lasting changes to who receives federal funds usually run through Congress and the courts.
Sources: ABC7 New York, 21 September 2020: New York City one of three cities deemed 'anarchist jurisdiction' by DOJ; OPB, 25 February 2021: Under President Biden, Portland loses 'anarchist jurisdiction' designation; Al Jazeera, 25 February 2021: 'Anarchist jurisdictions' no more: Biden revokes Trump's order. Photo: Spencer Platt / Getty Images.

COMMENTS