Tasmania's 2020 Pilot Whale Stranding: What Happened and Why

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-25.

Tasmania's September 2020 Pilot-Whale Stranding and Rescue Effort

On 21 September 2020, an aerial survey found a pod of long-finned pilot whales stranded on sandbars in Macquarie Harbour, on the remote west coast of Tasmania. The final count was about 470 whales, the largest mass stranding ever recorded in Australia. After roughly a week of work in cold water, rescuers had refloated about 110 animals. Around 350 died.

In the first days the news focused on the rising death toll, which reached at least 380 by 23 September, and on the 50 or so whales saved at that point. The rescue went on after that, and the numbers changed. This article sets out what happened, how the rescue worked, why pilot whales strand in such numbers and what scientists still do not know.

What happened in Macquarie Harbour

Macquarie Harbour is a large, shallow inlet near the small town of Strahan. Its only link to the Southern Ocean is a narrow, notoriously dangerous channel known as Hell's Gate. Inside, broad sandbars sit just below the surface at low tide.

The first group, about 270 whales, was spotted on Monday 21 September. Two days later, searchers found roughly 200 more, most already dead, about 10 kilometres away. The animals were spread over several sites up to six miles apart, which made both counting and rescue much harder. Tasmania Parks and Wildlife Service officials called it the largest stranding on record in the state and in Australia.

Tasmania's earlier record was reportedly a stranding of 294 pilot whales in 1935, and a smaller event of around 200 whales was reported in 2009. September 2020 surpassed them by a wide margin.

How rescuers moved whales weighing tonnes

The response brought together Parks and Wildlife staff, marine biologists, trained volunteers and workers from local salmon farms, whose boats and knowledge of the harbour were essential. A core team of about 60 people waded into the shallows each day.

Moving a pilot whale is slow and dangerous. Adults commonly measure four to six metres and weigh well over a tonne, with large males even bigger. Rescuers kept the animals upright and wet, then eased them into fabric slings attached to boats and towed them, one or two at a time, into deeper water beyond the sandbars.

Some whales stranded again overnight, something experts had warned was likely. Volunteer rescuer Tom Mountney told the BBC the animals were remarkably calm, and that it felt as if they sensed what people were trying to do. Officials later said that most of the whales released had stayed in deep water, and that they hoped the survivors would regroup.

When the rescue ended, attention turned to the carcasses. Hundreds of dead whales in an enclosed harbour risked attracting sharks and polluting the water. Crews corralled the bodies with booms and towed them out to sea over several days.

Why do pilot whales strand together?

There is no single, settled explanation, and that is still true years later. Researchers point to several factors that may combine.

  • Tight social bonds. Pilot whales live in close family groups, often organised around mothers. If one or a few animals get into trouble in shallow water, the rest may follow or stay close, drawn by distress calls. This is a leading theory, but it is not proven as the cause of every event.
  • Confusing coastlines. Gently sloping, sandy seabeds may weaken the echoes whales use to navigate, so a shallow bay can look like open water until it is too late.
  • Feeding and pursuit. Some researchers suggested the Macquarie Harbour pod may have come inshore to feed and become disoriented.
  • Other possible factors include illness in a lead animal, disturbances to Earth's magnetic field during solar storms, and, for some other species, underwater noise from naval sonar. None has been shown to explain this stranding.

Kris Carlyon, a marine biologist with Tasmania's environment department, described it as a "natural event". He noted that strandings of this species happen regularly in southern Australia and New Zealand, and that there is little anyone can do to prevent them.

Why Tasmania's west coast is a hotspot

Tasmania has long been known for whale strandings. Tasmanian officials have said that a large majority of Australia's mass strandings happen there, an estimate often given as around 80 percent. The island sits in the path of species that roam the Southern Ocean, and its west coast combines deep offshore water with shallow, sandy harbours and beaches.

Macquarie Harbour proved the point again two years later. On 21 September 2022, exactly two years after the 2020 discovery, about 230 pilot whales stranded on Ocean Beach at the harbour's mouth. Pounding surf made rescue very difficult; about 200 died, and 32 of the 35 survivors were released the next day.

About pilot whales and their numbers

Despite their name, pilot whales are large members of the dolphin family. Long-finned pilot whales are the second-largest dolphins after the orca. Females can reach about six metres and males more than seven, weighing up to several tonnes. They live in groups of a few dozen to over a hundred, and calves, including males, often stay with their mothers for life.

A figure of about 1.2 million pilot whales worldwide circulated with the 2020 coverage, alongside claims that numbers are falling. Neither is well supported. Scientists say there is no recent reliable global estimate for long-finned pilot whales, and the International Union for Conservation of Nature lists the species as Least Concern. Some regional populations face real pressures, including bycatch, hunting and pollution, so "not threatened" does not mean "no problems".

Long-finned pilot whales are the species most often involved in mass strandings worldwide. The largest event on record involved about 1,000 animals at New Zealand's Chatham Islands in 1918. More than 600 stranded at Farewell Spit, New Zealand, in February 2017.

What to do if you find a stranded whale or dolphin

Strandings can happen on almost any coast. If you come across a whale or dolphin on a beach, the most helpful steps are simple:

  • Call the authorities first. In Australia that means the state wildlife or parks service; elsewhere, the coastguard, police or a marine rescue organisation can connect you. Trained teams know how to assess an animal.
  • Keep your distance and keep others back. Even a small whale can injure people with its tail, and crowds add stress.
  • Do not drag or push the animal back into the sea. Pulling on fins or tail can cause serious injury, and a weak animal may simply strand again.
  • If rescuers ask for help, follow their instructions. Typical tasks include keeping the skin wet and shaded while avoiding the blowhole.

The 2020 rescue showed both the limits and the value of human effort. Most of the pod could not be saved, but more than a hundred whales returned to the open ocean because people were willing to stand in winter water for days to help them.

Sources: CBS News: early rescue and official statements; Newshub: end of the rescue and carcass removal; ITV News: the 2022 stranding and final 2020 figures; Wikipedia: Cetacean stranding; Wikipedia: Long-finned pilot whale; BBC News: rescuers' accounts.

COMMENTS