Why Facebook Warned It Might Pull Facebook and Instagram From the EU

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-09-25.

Facebook's 2020 Warning About EU Data Transfers

Photo: Niall Carson/PA Images / Getty Images

In September 2020, Facebook told Ireland's High Court that if it were barred from sending European users' data to the United States, it was not clear how it could go on offering Facebook and Instagram in the European Union. Headlines turned that into "Facebook threatens to quit Europe". The company insisted it was describing a legal reality, not making a threat, and in the end neither app went anywhere.

The dispute was about something most users never see: the flow of personal data across the Atlantic. To understand why Facebook issued such a stark warning, and why it all ended with a record fine rather than a blackout, you need to go back to a young Austrian law student and two landmark court rulings.

The Schrems rulings: why EU data transfers were in trouble

Under EU data protection law, personal data can only be sent outside Europe if it will be protected to a standard "essentially equivalent" to that in the EU. In 2013, after Edward Snowden revealed the US National Security Agency's PRISM programme, Austrian privacy activist Max Schrems complained that Facebook's transfers of his data to US servers exposed it to American mass surveillance.

His complaint went to the Court of Justice of the European Union twice. In October 2015, in the case now known as Schrems I, the court struck down the "Safe Harbor" agreement that thousands of companies used for transatlantic transfers. Its replacement, the EU–US Privacy Shield, lasted until 16 July 2020, when the court invalidated it too in Schrems II. The judges found that US surveillance law did not limit access to Europeans' data to what was strictly necessary, and that Europeans had no effective way to challenge it in court.

The court did leave one door open. Standard contractual clauses, model contracts that companies sign to promise data will be protected, remained valid. But regulators were told they must suspend transfers under these clauses whenever the destination country's laws made the promises impossible to keep. For a US company subject to American surveillance law, that was a serious problem.

What Facebook told the Irish court

Because Facebook's European headquarters is in Dublin, its main EU regulator is Ireland's Data Protection Commission (DPC). In late summer 2020, the DPC sent Facebook a preliminary order saying its transfers to the US could not continue under standard contractual clauses. Facebook went to the Irish High Court to challenge the order.

In a sworn statement filed in that case, Yvonne Cunnane, Facebook Ireland's head of data protection and associate general counsel, warned that if transfers were completely suspended, it was unclear how the company "could continue to provide the Facebook and Instagram services in the EU". The filing was reported around the world on 21 and 22 September 2020.

When the story became "Facebook threatens to leave Europe", the company pushed back. A spokesperson said Facebook was not threatening to withdraw and that the filing simply set out how many businesses depend on data moving between the EU and the US.

Nick Clegg's argument

Nick Clegg, the former UK Deputy Prime Minister who was then Facebook's head of global affairs and communications, made the wider case in a public statement. His argument was that the ruling did not only affect large tech firms. If transfers were cut off, he wrote, a small German start-up might no longer be able to rely on a US cloud provider, and European firms with offices or call centres abroad could struggle to operate. He called for clear global rules on data rather than a patchwork of national regimes.

Critics, including Schrems and his non-profit group noyb, saw it differently. In their view, the fix was for the US to reform its surveillance law or for Facebook to store European data in Europe, not for Europe to relax its protections.

Could Facebook really have left the EU?

It was always unlikely. The EU is one of Meta's most valuable advertising markets, with hundreds of millions of users, and simply walking away would have handed that market to competitors. Businesses large and small rely on Facebook and Instagram for advertising and customer contact, and many people use them as a main source of news and a way to stay in touch with family abroad. Pulling out would have caused a political storm on both sides.

Separating European data from the US was technically difficult for a company built around one global social network, but not obviously impossible. The more realistic outcome, which is what happened, was a long legal fight while politicians negotiated a new transatlantic deal.

What happened next: a €1.2 billion fine

Facebook lost its challenge in May 2021, when the Irish High Court rejected its complaints about the DPC's process. The investigation continued, and on 22 May 2023, following a binding decision by the European Data Protection Board, Ireland's DPC fined Meta a record €1.2 billion (about $1.3 billion), the largest penalty yet under the GDPR. Meta was ordered to suspend transfers of EU users' data to the US within five months and to bring data already stored in the US into compliance within six months.

Meta called the decision flawed and said it would appeal, while stressing that there was no immediate disruption to Facebook in Europe. It was rescued, at least for the time being, by politics. In October 2022 President Joe Biden signed Executive Order 14086, adding new limits on US intelligence gathering and creating a Data Protection Review Court where Europeans can file complaints. On 10 July 2023 the European Commission adopted the EU–US Data Privacy Framework, declaring that the US once again offered adequate protection.

Where things stand now

The new framework has so far survived. In September 2025 the EU General Court dismissed a challenge brought by French MP Philippe Latombe, finding that US protections were adequate when the framework was adopted. That ruling can be appealed to the Court of Justice, and noyb has said it intends to challenge the framework as well. Questions have also been raised about the independence of US oversight bodies after President Donald Trump removed Democratic members of the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board in January 2025.

For ordinary users, the practical takeaway is that Facebook and Instagram never stopped working in Europe, and are unlikely to vanish overnight. For businesses that send personal data to the US, the lesson of the Schrems saga is to keep an eye on the framework's legal status and to have contractual safeguards ready, because twice already the court has swept away the rules that everyone relied on.

Sources: Wikipedia: Max Schrems; Wikipedia: EU–US Data Privacy Framework; NPR via WPSU, 22 May 2023: European watchdog fines Meta $1.3 billion; Society for Computers and Law, September 2025: EU General Court rejects challenge to EU-US data framework. Facebook's court filing as reported by The Guardian, 22 September 2020.

COMMENTS