Originally published 2020-08-07.

David T. Hines, a 29-year-old businessman from Miami, obtained about $3.9 million in Paycheck Protection Program loans in 2020 by claiming payroll his companies did not have, and within days spent around $318,000 of it on a 2020 Lamborghini Huracán. He was arrested in July 2020, pleaded guilty to wire fraud in February 2021, and in May 2021 was sentenced to more than six years in federal prison. He also had to give up the car and the roughly $3.4 million agents had seized from his bank accounts.
The case became one of the best-known examples of pandemic relief fraud because of that yellow-and-black symbol of excess. Below is what Hines did, how he was caught, what happened in court, and what his case shows about the wider problem of fraud in emergency aid programmes.
What the Paycheck Protection Program was for
The Paycheck Protection Program, usually shortened to PPP, was created by the CARES Act in spring 2020, when lockdowns shut shops, restaurants and offices across the United States. The idea was simple: give small businesses fast loans, run through ordinary banks and backed by the Small Business Administration, so they could keep paying staff instead of laying them off.
If a business spent the money mainly on payroll, plus costs such as rent, mortgage interest and utilities, and kept its headcount and wages roughly steady, the loan could be forgiven entirely. Over several rounds of funding the programme grew to about $953 billion.
Speed was the point, and speed was also the weakness. To get money out quickly, lenders relied heavily on what applicants told them about their payroll, with limited checks at the start.
How the Lamborghini scheme worked
According to the Justice Department, Hines sent several PPP applications to an insured bank on behalf of different companies, asking for about $13.5 million in total. The applications described dozens of employees and millions of dollars in monthly wages, supported by false tax forms.
The bank approved and paid out about $3.9 million. In the following weeks, prosecutors said, none of the payroll payments he had described were made. State and bank records showed little or no payroll at the companies in the first quarter of 2020, and the people listed as staff either did not exist or earned far less than he had claimed.
Instead, within days of the money arriving, Hines bought a 2020 Lamborghini Huracán for about $318,000, registering it in his own name and that of one of his companies. He also spent loan money at luxury retailers and resorts in Miami Beach.
Arrest, charges and seizure
Hines was arrested in late July 2020 after an investigation involving the FDIC's Office of Inspector General, the US Postal Inspection Service, IRS Criminal Investigation, the SBA's inspector general and the oversight office for the Federal Reserve and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
At the time of the arrest, agents seized the Lamborghini and about $3.4 million from his bank accounts, so most of the money was recovered. The criminal complaint charged him with bank fraud, making false statements to a financial institution and engaging in transactions with unlawful proceeds. As the Justice Department noted, a complaint is only an allegation until a case is proven.
Guilty plea and prison sentence
The case never went to trial. On 10 February 2021 Hines pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud. On 12 May 2021 the Justice Department announced that a federal judge in Miami had sentenced him to more than six years in prison.
The court ordered him to forfeit the seized $3.4 million and the Lamborghini. Prosecutors also said Hines had helped other people obtain fraudulent PPP loans, which made the case more than a one-man scheme.
Early reports said he had applied for "$13 million" and that "$3 million" was recovered. The official figures are slightly different: about $13.5 million requested, $3.9 million received and $3.4 million seized.
Not the only one: other early PPP fraud cases
Hines was far from the only person to treat the programme as easy money. One of the very first CARES Act fraud cases involved David Adler Staveley, who sought about $544,000 in PPP loans for businesses in Rhode Island and Massachusetts. In May 2020, weeks after his arrest, he cut off his electronic monitoring bracelet and left suicide notes, and his car was found near the sea in Massachusetts. Investigators were not convinced. US Marshals found him alive in Alpharetta, Georgia, on 23 July 2020, and in 2021 he was sentenced to more than four years in prison.
Other cases involved fake farms, invented restaurants and loan money spent on mansions, jewellery, sports cars and even a Pokémon card. By April 2024 the Justice Department had charged more than 3,500 defendants in connection with the PPP and related programmes.
Why pandemic relief attracted so much fraud
Emergency aid creates a hard trade-off. Officials wanted money to reach real businesses within days, which meant fewer checks than a normal loan. Fraudsters, from individuals like Hines to organised groups, exploited that gap with false payroll figures, stolen identities and shell companies.
Relief fraud was only one part of a broader wave of pandemic crime. Police and consumer agencies around the world warned about fake protective equipment, bogus "miracle cures" sold online and scam calls offering government grants. In Italy, investigators and journalists reported that mafia groups tried to win local support by handing out food parcels in poor neighbourhoods during lockdown, raising fears that they would gain recruits and influence.
Lawmakers responded to the scale of PPP fraud. In August 2022 the United States extended the statute of limitations for PPP fraud to ten years, giving investigators until about 2030 to bring cases.
What the case teaches
The Hines case is a reminder that flashy spending is often what gets fraud noticed. A brand-new supercar bought days after an emergency loan landed was exactly the kind of transaction that banks and investigators look for.
For small business owners, the practical lessons are straightforward. Keep payroll records and tax filings accurate, because they are what lenders and auditors will check. Be wary of anyone offering to "help" with relief applications for a fee or a cut of the loan. And if you suspect a business is abusing a government programme, report it to the relevant inspector general or fraud hotline rather than confronting anyone yourself.
Sources: US Department of Justice, 27 July 2020: Florida man who used Covid relief funds to purchase Lamborghini sports car charged; US Department of Justice, 12 May 2021: Florida man sentenced after fraudulently obtaining $3.9 million in PPP loans; Boston.com, 8 October 2021: the Staveley case; Wikipedia: Paycheck Protection Program.

COMMENTS