How Self-Respect Earns Real Respect From Others

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-08-01.

Self-Respect, Boundaries, and the Respect We Owe Others

You cannot buy real respect, and you cannot force it out of anyone. What you can do is treat yourself as someone whose time, values and limits matter, treat other people the same way, and refuse to accept being mistreated. That is the heart of self-respect, and it is also the most reliable foundation for being respected by others.

It is not a guarantee. Some people will be rude or unfair whatever you do. But self-respect changes how you act, what you put up with and how you recover when things go wrong, and that shapes how others see you over time.

Two kinds of respect

Part of the confusion around respect comes from using one word for two different things. Philosopher Stephen Darwall drew a famous line between them in 1977.

  • Recognition respect is the basic regard owed to every person simply because they are a person. You do not earn it, and you cannot lose it by failing an exam or losing a job.
  • Appraisal respect is the admiration we feel for someone's character or achievements: thinking highly of a fair boss, a brave friend or a skilled craftsman. That kind is earned, and it varies.

Most of us want both. We want to be treated with basic dignity, and we would also like to be valued for who we are. The trouble starts when we try to get the second kind by chasing status, money or approval, and forget that the first kind is already ours.

Dignity is not for sale

The idea that every person has a worth beyond price has a long history. Immanuel Kant argued in the eighteenth century that people have dignity rather than a price: something with a price can be swapped for something of equal value, but a person cannot. For Kant, that dignity does not depend on rank, merit or success, and it is not lost through bad behaviour.

This matters for everyday life. If your sense of worth depends on a promotion, a relationship or likes on a post, it will rise and fall with every result. If it rests on the simple fact that you are a person who deserves decent treatment, it can survive a bad year.

The same principle works in the other direction. Respect bought with gifts, flattery or favours is not really respect; it lasts as long as the supply does. The respect worth having is the kind someone gives freely, because of how you treat them and how you carry yourself.

What self-respect looks like in practice

Self-respect is less about feeling confident and more about how you behave. It shows up in small, ordinary choices:

  • Keeping your word, including promises you make to yourself.
  • Owning mistakes without collapsing into shame or blaming everyone else.
  • Holding standards you would be uncomfortable falling below, such as honesty or fairness.
  • Saying no to things that go against your values, even when saying yes would be easier.
  • Looking after your body and mind as things worth caring for.

Philosopher Thomas Hill described the opposite of this as servility: treating yourself as a lesser kind of being whose needs and rights count for less than everyone else's. A servile person may be polite and agreeable, but they quietly accept being used, and others learn that they can be.

Importantly, self-respect is not the same as arrogance. A person who respects themselves can admit faults, apologise and learn. Accepting that you are imperfect does not cancel out your worth; it is part of seeing yourself honestly.

Respecting others is part of the deal

One of the clearest signs of real self-respect is how someone treats people who can do nothing for them: the waiter, the cleaner, the new colleague. People who feel secure in their own worth rarely need to put others down to feel bigger.

That is why respecting others and respecting yourself go together. If you believe that every person deserves basic dignity, you have to include yourself in "every person". And if you insist on being treated decently, you have no excuse for treating others badly.

It also explains a hard truth: some people will not respect you no matter what you do. People who are full of envy or anger, or who do not respect themselves, often struggle to respect anyone else. Their behaviour says more about them than about you. You can be fair to them without letting their opinion define you.

Setting boundaries without aggression

Refusing to be mistreated is where many people get stuck. They swing between staying silent and exploding. Psychologists describe a middle path called assertiveness: stating your views and limits clearly and calmly while still respecting the other person's boundaries. Passive communication avoids conflict and lets others take advantage; aggressive communication attacks the person instead of the problem.

A few techniques help:

  • Use "I" statements. "I feel dismissed when my ideas are talked over" is harder to argue with than "You never listen."
  • Repeat calmly. If someone pushes back, restate your limit in the same words without raising your voice.
  • Focus on the behaviour. Address what was done, not what kind of person they are.
  • Decide your next step. If someone keeps crossing a line, you can spend less time with them, change how you work together, or walk away.

Real life is not always so tidy. A job, money or family ties can limit how freely you can respond. Self-respect does not demand that you burn every bridge. It asks that you know where your line is, and that you stop telling yourself mistreatment is fine.

Common myths about respect

"Respect has to be earned." Admiration has to be earned. Basic courtesy and dignity are owed to everyone, including you.

"If people disrespect me, I must have done something wrong." Sometimes you did, and owning that is part of self-respect. Often, though, rudeness reflects the other person's mood, insecurity or habits.

"Self-respect means never compromising." Compromise is a normal part of living with others. The difference is choosing a compromise freely rather than giving in out of fear.

"Being respected means being liked." You can respect people you do not especially like, and be respected by people who disagree with you. Respect is about how you are treated, not whether everyone approves.

Where low self-worth feels heavy or constant, or is tied to anxiety or depression, talking to a doctor or a qualified therapist is a sensible step. For most of us, though, self-respect grows the ordinary way: one honest, decent choice at a time.

Sources: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Respect (Darwall, Kant and Hill on respect and self-respect); Wikipedia: Assertiveness.

COMMENTS