New Zealand's Equal Pay Amendment Act: Pay Equity Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published August 6, 2020.

New Zealand's 2020 Equal Pay Amendment Addressed Pay-Equity Claims
Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern speaking to reporters at Parliament in Wellington, 28 January 2020.

On 23 July 2020, New Zealand's Parliament unanimously passed the Equal Pay Amendment Bill. The new law did not simply restate that men and women doing the same job must be paid the same; that had been the law since 1972. Instead it created a clearer, practical route for pay equity claims: claims that work done mostly by women has been undervalued compared with different work, of similar skill and responsibility, done mostly by men. The changes took effect in November 2020. In May 2025 a later government amended the law again and made such claims harder to bring.

This guide explains the difference between equal pay and pay equity, how the 2020 process worked, the court case that led to it, and how the rules have changed since.

Equal pay and pay equity are not the same thing

Equal pay means a woman and a man in the same job, with the same duties, receive the same wage. New Zealand's Equal Pay Act 1972 already required that.

Pay equity goes a step further. It asks whether whole occupations dominated by women, such as caregiving, teacher aides or some clerical work, have been paid less because the work was historically seen as "women's work". To test that, a claim compares the job with different, male-dominated work that needs similar skills, effort and responsibility. If the women's job is shown to be undervalued, pay is raised to correct it.

A common misunderstanding is that the 2020 law made every job pay the same amount. It did not. It set out a fair way to compare jobs and settle claims where sex-based undervaluation is shown.

The court case that set this in motion

The modern push for pay equity in New Zealand came from Kristine Bartlett, a caregiver in an aged-care home who worked for TerraNova Homes and Care. Backed by her union, she argued that she and other care workers were underpaid because their work was done mainly by women. Her case went through the courts in the early 2010s and established that the 1972 Act could apply across different jobs, not only identical ones.

In 2017 the government settled the claim for care and support workers, giving tens of thousands of workers significant pay rises. The settlement confirmed that their work had been undervalued because of systemic gender discrimination. But fighting each claim through the courts was slow and expensive, and that is the gap the 2020 amendment set out to close.

What the 2020 amendment changed

The amendment, which came into force in early November 2020, moved pay equity out of the courtroom and into a bargaining process based on the Employment Relations Act 2000. Its main features were:

  • Direct claims. Unions and individual employees could raise a pay equity claim directly with an employer.
  • An "arguable" threshold. A claim could proceed if it was arguable that work done predominantly by women (roughly 60 percent or more) was, or had been, undervalued. The history of the work, including how its wages were set, could be considered.
  • Comparators. The work was compared with male-dominated roles requiring the same or substantially similar skills, responsibility and experience, with skills such as caring, communication and cultural knowledge given proper weight.
  • Good faith and mediation. Employers, workers and unions had to bargain in good faith, with access to mediation and other dispute resolution services if they could not agree.

The Minister for Women at the time, Julie Anne Genter, described the law as one of the biggest gains for gender equity at work since the original Act almost 50 years earlier.

How political leaders and unions reacted

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern marked the vote on Instagram and in public statements, saying the government had kept its 2017 promise to fix the legislation on historic pay inequality for women. Her post, embedded below, was shared shortly after the bill passed.

A post shared by Jacinda Ardern (@jacindaardern) on

Union leaders welcomed the change as a sustainable way forward. Richard Wagstaff, president of the New Zealand Council of Trade Unions, said:

"The passing of new equal pay law provides structure and support in fixing the systemic problem of paying women less because of their gender."

He pointed out that unions had already won equal pay settlements for almost 80,000 people in the previous four years, including care workers and teacher aides, whose 2020 settlement raised pay by between 23 and 34 percent.

Workplace Relations Minister Andrew Little was more cautious, describing the bill as one step in a long journey toward gender equality.

The 2025 changes

The law did not stay in its 2020 form. In May 2025, the coalition government led by Christopher Luxon passed an Equal Pay Amendment Bill under urgency. It raised the bar for proving that work has been historically undervalued, and 33 pay equity claims already in progress, covering thousands of workers, were cancelled and would have to start again under the new rules.

Workplace Relations Minister Brooke van Velden said she still supported pay equity but that the claims process had become unclear. The government said the change could save billions. All opposition parties voted against it, and critics argued it would make it harder for women in female-dominated jobs to win fair pay. The debate has continued since, so anyone relying on the current rules should check the latest official guidance.

New Zealand's place in the history of women's rights

New Zealand often features in stories about gender equality, and some of its milestones are genuinely world firsts. On 19 September 1893, Governor Lord Glasgow signed the Electoral Act, making New Zealand the first nation in which all women could vote in parliamentary elections. A petition led by campaigners such as Kate Sheppard had gathered nearly 32,000 signatures. Women voted for the first time in the general election of 28 November 1893.

Two popular claims about Ardern and New Zealand's ranking need care. Ardern gave birth in June 2018, not 2019, and she was widely reported as the second elected head of government to give birth in office, after Pakistan's Benazir Bhutto in 1990. Global rankings also move from year to year: New Zealand placed sixth in the World Economic Forum's 2020 Global Gender Gap Report, but that figure changes with each edition.

Why the debate matters beyond New Zealand

Many countries have equal pay laws for identical work, yet a pay gap persists because women are concentrated in lower-paid occupations. New Zealand's 2020 approach became an example of how a country might tackle that second, harder problem through structured bargaining rather than lengthy court cases. Its 2025 reversal shows the other side: such schemes are expensive for governments that fund care and education workers, and their future depends on political choices as much as on legal principles.

For workers, the practical lesson is the same everywhere. Know whether your claim is about equal pay for the same job or pay equity for undervalued work, check the rules that apply now, and seek advice from a union or an employment adviser before you start.

Sources: 1News: Equal Pay Amendment Bill passes unanimously (July 2020); The Spinoff: What the Equal Pay Amendment Bill means for women; SunLive: More pay equity measures come into force (November 2020); 1News: Pay equity amendment bill passes under urgency (May 2025); Wikipedia: Women's suffrage in New Zealand.

COMMENTS