Istanbul’s Chora Church Turned Into a Mosque: The 2020 Decree

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2020-08-25.

Istanbul's Chora Church Conversion Order in 2020

On 21 August 2020, Turkey ordered the Chora Church in Istanbul, a Byzantine monument famous for some of the finest medieval mosaics and frescoes in the world, to be handed to the state religious authority and opened as a mosque. The decree, signed by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and published in the official gazette, came barely a month after the far better known Hagia Sophia was turned back into a mosque. The first Muslim prayers at Chora were held on 30 October 2020, and after about four years of restoration it opened for worship as the Kariye Mosque on 6 May 2024.

What the 2020 decree said

The order transferred management of what it called the Kariye Mosque to the Presidency of Religious Affairs, known in Turkey as the Diyanet, and declared it open for worship. Legally, the path had been cleared earlier: in November 2019 Turkey’s Council of State had annulled the 1945 cabinet decision that turned the building into a museum.

The decision, the legal transfer, the first prayers and the full reopening were therefore separate steps spread over several years, not a single event. For most of that time, the building stayed closed for restoration.

Turkish journalist Ragıp Soylu shared photos of the interior on the day of the announcement:

One correction to that tweet: Chora was not built by Justinian I, the emperor behind Hagia Sophia. Its history is older in origin and its famous art much later, as the next section explains.

A short history of Chora

The name comes from the Greek word for “countryside”. A monastery was founded here in the early 4th century, outside the walls of Constantinople. When the Theodosian Walls were built in 413–414, the site ended up inside the city, but the old name stuck.

The church that survives today was largely rebuilt between 1077 and 1081 by Maria Doukaina, mother-in-law of Emperor Alexios I Komnenos. Its glory came two centuries later. Between about 1310 and 1321, the statesman and scholar Theodore Metochites paid for the mosaics and frescoes, and added the side chapel and outer porches. These scenes from the lives of Christ and the Virgin Mary are counted among the greatest works of the so-called Palaeologan Renaissance, the last flowering of Byzantine art. The fresco of the Resurrection in the funeral chapel, showing Christ pulling Adam and Eve from their tombs, is one of the best-known images of Byzantine painting.

From church to mosque to museum, and back

Constantinople fell to the Ottomans in 1453. About fifty years later, Hadım Ali Pasha, grand vizier to Sultan Bayezid II, had Chora converted into a mosque, and its images were covered with plaster or screens. That is partly why so much survived.

In 1945 the young Turkish Republic, under its secular founding principles, turned the building into a museum. From 1948 the Byzantine Institute of America and Dumbarton Oaks, led by Thomas Whittemore and Paul Underwood, carried out a restoration that uncovered and cleaned the artwork. The Kariye Museum opened to the public in 1958 and became one of Istanbul’s most admired sights.

What visitors see today

Since reopening in May 2024, the building has worked as a mosque that also welcomes visitors. According to Hyperallergic, nearly all of the mosaics and frescoes remain visible. The exception is a handful of pieces in the small central nave, now the men’s prayer hall, which is off-limits to non-Muslims and women. Images are covered with curtains during prayer times.

At Hagia Sophia, the arrangement is similar. Reuters reported in 2020 that a curtain had been drawn across the great apse image of the Virgin and Child so that it would not be seen by worshippers during prayers. Visitors planning a trip should check opening times, since access is limited around the five daily prayers and on Fridays.

The politics behind the move

Chora and Hagia Sophia are not the only cases. Many Byzantine churches in Istanbul and elsewhere were converted into mosques after 1453, and several that had become museums in the 20th century have since been returned to use as mosques. Critics, including Orthodox Christian leaders and UNESCO, argued that turning world-famous museums into places of worship sends a message about who the country’s heritage belongs to.

Erdoğan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) draws much of its support from religious conservatives, and many analysts saw the conversions as a way to rally that base while Turkey faced a currency crisis and the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. The government has also been widely criticised for restricting press freedom, especially after the failed coup attempt of 2016; for several years Turkey ranked among the world’s worst jailers of journalists, and many opposition newspapers were closed.

The United States, Greece, Russia and the European Union all voiced concern over the Hagia Sophia decision, and Greece in particular condemned the conversion of Chora as well.

Why Chora matters

Chora’s mosaics show a moment when Byzantine artists were painting with new warmth and movement, shortly before the empire’s final decline. Their survival through five centuries as a mosque, followed by careful restoration, is a story of both loss and preservation. Whatever one thinks of the 2020 decision, the building remains open, and its art can still be seen by anyone who visits Istanbul.

Sources: Chora Church (Wikipedia); Hyperallergic, May 2024: Istanbul church reopens as mosque with medieval mosaics and frescoes intact; Reuters, August 2020; tweet by Ragıp Soylu.

COMMENTS