First published July 13, 2020.

In July 2020, Twitter co-founder and then-CEO Jack Dorsey gave $3 million to Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, a new coalition of US mayors who wanted to test whether regular, no-strings cash payments could make life more stable for struggling households. The money came out of the $1 billion he had pledged in April 2020 for coronavirus relief and other causes. It was not a nationwide payment to every American, and it was not strictly "universal basic income". Here is what the donation actually funded, how guaranteed income differs from UBI, and what the early pilots found.
The donation and the coalition behind it
Dorsey announced the gift in a tweet on 9 July 2020. The recipient, Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, had been founded only weeks earlier, in June 2020, by Michael Tubbs, then mayor of Stockton, California. At launch it brought together mayors from more than a dozen cities, including Atlanta, Los Angeles, Seattle, Pittsburgh, Newark in New Jersey and Jackson, Mississippi. Dorsey called guaranteed income "one tool" to close the wealth and income gap.
The coalition grew quickly. By 2022 more than 60 cities had joined, and in December 2020 Dorsey added a much larger gift of $15 million to help fund pilots in additional cities.
A note on the numbers
Some reports at the time suggested the scheme "could involve as many as 7 million people". That figure was closer to the combined population of the member cities. The pilots themselves were small and targeted: each typically enrolled a few hundred or a few thousand selected residents. A $3 million gift spread across many cities cannot pay millions of people; it helps cover research, administration and modest pilot budgets, usually alongside other donors.
Guaranteed income vs universal basic income
The two terms are often used as if they mean the same thing, but they describe different policies.
- Universal basic income (UBI) is a regular cash payment to everyone, regardless of income or work, usually intended to be permanent and large enough to cover basic needs.
- Guaranteed income is a regular cash payment to a targeted group, often low-income households, sometimes for a fixed period, with no conditions on how the money is spent.
The mayors' coalition chose the second model. Its pilots are designed as experiments, often with randomly selected participants and a comparison group, so researchers can see whether the cash changes people's employment, health, stress levels and financial stability.
The US pandemic stimulus checks of 2020 are sometimes described as a UBI. They shared one feature, cash with no strings, but they were one-off or occasional payments, phased out at higher incomes, and not meant to continue indefinitely, so they are better seen as emergency relief.
Stockton's SEED: the pilot that started it
The coalition grew out of the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration (SEED), the first government-led guaranteed income pilot in the United States. Starting in February 2019, it gave 125 randomly selected Stockton residents $500 a month for 18 months, loaded onto prepaid debit cards, with no conditions. It was later extended through January 2021 during the pandemic. The roughly $3 million budget came from private funders, led by $1 million from the Economic Security Project, the group chaired by Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes.
Independent researchers reported in March 2021 that recipients found full-time work at a higher rate than the comparison group and reported less anxiety and depression. Spending records showed most of the money went on food, utilities and household basics. The sample was small, and the pandemic complicated the second year, but the results gave other cities a model to copy.
Why 2020 put the idea back on the agenda
The donation came during the worst US job losses since the Great Depression. Unemployment jumped to around 15% in April 2020, and tens of millions of people saw their income drop or vanish. Existing support systems, built around unemployment insurance and means-tested benefits, struggled with the surge in claims.
The idea also had a high-profile champion in Andrew Yang, the entrepreneur who ran for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination on a promise of a $1,000-a-month "Freedom Dividend" for every adult American. Yang did not win the nomination (he withdrew in February 2020), but his campaign made the phrase "universal basic income" familiar to millions. Tech figures including Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg have also spoken favourably about basic income in the past, often linking it to the risk of jobs lost to automation.
The case for and against
What supporters argue
- Cash lets people decide what they need most, whether that is rent, childcare, a car repair or time to look for a better job.
- A small, reliable income reduces the stress of living one emergency away from crisis, which can affect health and decision-making.
- No-strings payments cut paperwork compared with many welfare programmes.
What critics argue
- Some economists and conservatives worry that unconditional cash could reduce the incentive to work, or that a national scheme would be extremely expensive.
- Some on the left warn that cash payments could become an excuse to cut public services or let employers keep wages low.
- Small pilots may not predict what would happen if a whole country adopted the policy, since prices, wages and behaviour could shift at scale.
The honest answer is that targeted pilots can show how cash affects individual households, but they cannot settle the bigger questions about cost, inflation and labour markets that a national UBI would raise.
What to look for when you read about a pilot
If you come across news about a guaranteed income or UBI experiment, a few questions help you judge it:
- Who gets paid, and how many? A city of a million people may have a pilot of just a few hundred participants.
- How much, and for how long? $500 a month for 18 months is very different from a lifelong basic income.
- Is there a comparison group? Without one, it is hard to know whether changes were caused by the cash.
- Who is paying? Philanthropic money can launch a pilot, but a lasting programme needs public funding.
Dorsey's $3 million was modest by billionaire standards, yet it helped turn a single Stockton experiment into a national network of cities testing the same idea, and that research continues to feed the debate.
Sources: CBS News: Jack Dorsey donates $3 million to guaranteed income programs; Wikipedia: Mayors for a Guaranteed Income.

COMMENTS