Polynesians and Native Americans Met Around AD 1200, DNA Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Genetic Evidence for Early Contact Between Polynesians and Native Americans

Photograph: Jorge Vega/Reuters

Did Polynesians and Native Americans meet before Europeans crossed the Pacific? According to a large genetic study published in Nature on 8 July 2020, the answer is yes. By comparing the DNA of 807 living people, an international team found traces of Native American ancestry in several Polynesian island populations and dated the first mixing to roughly AD 1150–1200, more than three centuries before Columbus reached the Caribbean.

The result settled a long debate in one important respect: contact happened. It also raised new questions about who made the voyage, where they landed and what they brought with them.

What the study found

The research was led by Alexander Ioannidis, then a researcher at Stanford University, and Javier Blanco-Portillo, with Andrés Moreno-Estrada of Mexico's National Laboratory of Genomics for Biodiversity (LANGEBIO) as senior author. The team collected saliva samples from 807 volunteers on 17 Polynesian islands and from 15 Indigenous groups living along the Pacific coast of the Americas, from Mexico down to Chile.

When they analysed the genomes, they found small segments of Native American DNA in people on several eastern Polynesian islands. Using computational methods, they traced the source of that DNA most closely to Indigenous populations in present-day Colombia.

The earliest signal came from Fatu Hiva in the southern Marquesas, where the mixing appears to date to around AD 1150. Statistical modelling pointed to what Ioannidis described as "a single shared contact event," after which the Native American ancestry spread to other islands as Polynesians continued to settle the eastern Pacific.

How DNA can date an ancient meeting

The dating method relies on a simple fact of inheritance. When two populations first have children together, the offspring carry long, unbroken stretches of DNA from each side. With every new generation, recombination chops those stretches into smaller pieces.

By measuring how short the Native American segments in today's Polynesians have become, researchers can estimate how many generations have passed since the mixing began. Multiply that by an average generation length and you get an approximate date. This is why the study could put the contact in the twelfth century even though no written record of it exists.

The method has limits. It gives a range rather than an exact year, it depends on which populations were sampled, and it can only detect encounters that left descendants. A brief trading visit with no children born from it would leave no genetic trace at all.

The sweet potato clue

Long before genetics entered the story, the strongest hint of contact was a vegetable. The sweet potato was domesticated in South and Central America, yet it was already being grown across Polynesia when European sailors arrived.

Language adds to the puzzle. The Polynesian word for the crop, often written kumala or kūmara, closely resembles words used in Quechua, the language family of the Andes. Researchers have argued for decades over whether the plant could have drifted across the ocean on its own, or been carried by birds, or whether people moved it deliberately. Earlier genetic studies of the plant itself were inconclusive.

The human DNA evidence does not prove how the sweet potato travelled, but it shows that people from both regions did meet, which makes a human-carried crop a far more plausible explanation.

Who sailed to whom?

This is the question the genes cannot fully answer. There are two broad possibilities:

  • Polynesians reached South America and returned home with Native American partners, children or crops. Many researchers favour this view because Polynesian navigators are known to have crossed thousands of kilometres of open ocean in double-hulled voyaging canoes, using stars, swells and birds to find land.
  • South Americans reached Polynesia, perhaps on rafts carried by winds and currents, and settled or mixed with islanders already there, or arrived before them.

Ioannidis told reporters that it was more likely Polynesians reached the Americas, given their seafaring skill. Some archaeologists noted, however, that the date and location of the earliest signal fit an alternative scenario. National Geographic quoted the Uppsala University archaeologist Paul Wallin as saying the findings suggest Thor Heyerdahl was "partly right." Heyerdahl's 1947 Kon-Tiki expedition drifted on a balsa raft from Peru to Polynesia to show that such a crossing was possible, although his wider theory that the Pacific was settled from the Americas has been rejected.

Fatu Hiva is farther from South America than Rapa Nui (Easter Island), but favourable winds and currents may have made it easier to reach, which is one reason the location surprised researchers.

How it fits with earlier research

The 2020 paper built on earlier work. A 2014 study of 27 people on Rapa Nui estimated that roughly 8 per cent of their ancestry was Native American and suggested mixing as early as about AD 1340. The new, larger study pushed the earliest contact back by around two centuries and moved its likely location to the Marquesas.

Ancient DNA from skeletal remains had not given a clear answer, partly because few suitable remains survive and partly because the contact signal is small. Studying many living people across a wide area gave the researchers more statistical power.

Common misunderstandings

  • "Nobody had suspected contact before." Not true. Scholars had debated the idea for well over a century, mainly because of the sweet potato and linguistic similarities. The study added strong genetic evidence to an existing question.
  • "There were 800 years of regular travel." The evidence points to an early contact event around 800 years ago, not to a continuous trade network.
  • "It happened when Genghis Khan invaded Europe." A popular comparison, but inaccurate. Genghis Khan died in 1227 and never invaded Europe; the Mongol campaigns into Europe came later, in 1236–1242. The contact date also predates them.
  • "Genetics replaces oral history." Genetic data adds one line of evidence. Archaeology, linguistics, navigation research and the oral traditions of Pacific and South American communities each fill in different parts of the picture.

As Ioannidis put it in Stanford's announcement, genetics and data science can help tell the stories of people who were left out of written records. The meeting between Polynesian and South American communities is one of those stories, and research into it is still continuing.

Sources: Stanford Medicine: Polynesians and Native Americans made early contact (July 2020); National Geographic: DNA reveals contact between Polynesians and Native Americans (July 2020). Study: Ioannidis et al., Nature, 8 July 2020. Photo: Jorge Vega/Reuters.

COMMENTS