Originally published 2020-07-13.

In June 2020 the Trump administration's National Park Service (NPS) finalised a rule that lifted a 2015 ban on several controversial hunting methods in Alaska's national preserves. From 9 July 2020, state-permitted hunters on those lands could again shoot black bears, including cubs and mothers with cubs, at their dens using artificial light; kill wolves and coyotes, pups included, during the denning season; shoot bears attracted to bait; hunt black bears with dogs; and take caribou while they were swimming, including from motorboats. In 2024 the Park Service banned bear baiting again, but most of the other 2020 changes stayed in place.
The story was widely reported at the time as a sweeping "decree" covering all of Alaska. The real picture is narrower and more interesting, and it says a lot about who controls wildlife on federal land.
What the 2020 rule changed
The rule was formally an alignment of federal regulations with the State of Alaska's hunting and trapping regulations. In 2015, under President Barack Obama, the Park Service had prohibited a list of practices in the preserves even where state law allowed them. The 2020 rule removed those federal prohibitions. Practices that became lawful again on preserve land, where state rules permitted them, included:
- taking black bears, including cubs and sows with cubs, at den sites with the help of artificial light
- taking bears at bait stations
- taking wolves and coyotes, including pups, during the denning season
- using dogs to hunt black bears
- taking caribou while they swim, including from a moving motorboat
Some early reports also listed osprey chicks and other species. Those were not part of the rule.
Where it applied, and where it did not
National parks and national preserves are different things. Sport hunting is generally not allowed in Alaska's national parks, but it is permitted in national preserves, which were created under the 1980 Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act (ANILCA) partly to keep hunting, trapping and subsistence traditions alive. The Park Service manages ten preserves in Alaska, covering about 22 million acres, including land next to Denali, Gates of the Arctic and Wrangell-St. Elias.
So the rule did not apply to the whole of Alaska, and it did not change hunting rules anywhere else in the United States. Outside federal preserves, the state's own regulations already governed these methods.
Why the administration made the change
The rollback grew out of 2017 orders by then-Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke and a memorandum that treated states as the lead authorities for managing fish and wildlife. Supporters argued that the 2015 rules were federal overreach. Alaska's congressman, Don Young, called the old restrictions a wrongful federal seizure of the state's authority. Governor Mike Dunleavy welcomed the change, saying in the NPS announcement that "hunting and responsible management of wildlife are an integral part of the Alaskan lifestyle."
Some Alaska Native groups also backed the rollback. The Tanana Chiefs Conference, which represents 42 Interior Alaska tribes, said the 2015 limits threatened traditional ways of life. A 2018 federal environmental assessment suggested the change could increase subsistence harvests of moose and caribou, because fewer predators would compete for them.
Why critics were so angry
Conservation and animal-welfare groups saw the rule as a return to methods that have little to do with fair chase. Defenders of Wildlife called it a new low and described the killing of cubs and pups in dens as barbaric. In a petition, Ben Williamson of World Animal Protection US argued that luring bears with doughnuts and shooting caribou from motorboats "takes no skill or cunning", and urged a shift towards valuing wildlife for viewing rather than killing.
A group of former Park Service managers in Alaska also wrote to the Interior Department opposing the rule. Critics like them made a legal and ecological argument: the Park Service's founding law asks it to conserve natural wildlife populations, not to boost moose and caribou numbers by thinning out bears and wolves, which is what some state predator-control policies aim to do.
What these hunting methods mean
Bear baiting means leaving food such as doughnuts, grease or dog food at a site so bears return there and can be shot. Wildlife managers worry it teaches bears to link people with food. Denning hunts take place in late winter or spring, when bears are hibernating or wolf and coyote pups are still in the den and cannot escape. Taking swimming caribou targets animals that are slow and vulnerable while crossing rivers and lakes on migration.
The 2024 reversal on bear baiting
Under President Joe Biden, the Park Service proposed in January 2023 to restore most of the 2015 prohibitions. The final rule, published on 3 July 2024 and effective on 2 August 2024, was more limited. It reinstated a clear ban: using bait to attract or take bears is prohibited in Alaska's national preserves. The agency said bait created risks for people, bears and property by teaching bears to associate humans with food.
The Park Service decided not to write the rest of the old list back into its regulations for now. It said most of those practices were already restricted under state law and there was little demand for them in the preserves, and it left local superintendents with power to close areas or methods where needed. Proposed provisions on swimming caribou and motorboats were dropped from the final rule. Environmental groups welcomed the baiting ban but criticised the Park Service for leaving the den-hunting changes untouched.
Why this fight keeps coming back
The underlying question is who decides how wildlife is managed on federal land in Alaska: the state, which favours keeping predator numbers down to support hunters and subsistence users, or federal agencies charged with protecting natural ecosystems. Each administration has pulled the rules in its own direction, and several of the changes have ended up in court.
For anyone following the issue, the practical points are these: the rules apply only to national preserves, not all of Alaska; bear baiting in those preserves has been banned again since August 2024; and den hunting of bears and wolves remains a matter of state regulation and local closures rather than a blanket federal ban.
Sources: Anchorage Daily News, 9 June 2020: Trump administration eases hunting and trapping rules in Alaska national preserves; National Park Service, 20 May 2020: NPS aligns regulations with state law for hunting and trapping in Alaska national preserves; E&E News, 1 July 2024: NPS reinstates ban on bear baiting in Alaska's national preserves; Federal Register 2024-14701 (89 FR 55059): 2024 final rule on hunting and trapping in Alaska national preserves.

COMMENTS