First published June 17, 2020.

A frame from the research camera footage released by the Humane Society of the United States, showing the two men at the den after the shooting.
In April 2018, a Wasilla, Alaska, man and his teenage son shot a hibernating mother bear and her two newborn cubs in their den on Esther Island in Prince William Sound. They did not know that a motion-activated camera, placed outside the den for a state and federal bear study, was recording everything. In January 2019 both pleaded guilty to multiple misdemeanour charges. Andrew Renner, then 41, was ordered to serve three months in jail and pay a $9,000 fine, and lost his hunting licence for ten years; his son Owen, then 18, received a suspended jail sentence.
The video became public again in 2020, when it was widely shared during a debate over hunting rules in Alaska, which is why many readers first saw it that year. Here is what happened, how the case was proven, and why it drew such a strong response.
What happened on Esther Island
Esther Island lies in western Prince William Sound, east of Anchorage. The bear was a female that researchers had fitted with a tracking collar, and the US Forest Service and the Alaska Department of Fish and Game had set up a camera at her den as part of a study of bear populations and denning behaviour.
According to prosecutors, the pair approached the den in early spring while the family was still inside. The son fired into the den and killed the mother. When the cubs began crying, the father shot them too. The men returned two days later to collect the research collar and their spent shell casings and to remove the cubs' bodies, apparently trying to cover their tracks. Troopers identified the animals as a black bear sow and her two cubs.
Investigators said the men also falsely reported the kill. Andrew Renner was found to have falsified documentation and failed to report the number of bears illegally killed. The camera footage made those claims impossible to sustain.
How a research camera solved the case
Wildlife crimes in remote country are notoriously hard to prove. There are rarely witnesses, and the evidence can be carried away or left for scavengers. In this case, the men had no idea that the den was being studied, and the camera captured the shooting, their return visit and their conversation.
The footage reportedly shows the two men celebrating after the killing, and one of them can be heard suggesting that nobody would ever connect it to them. That remark mattered in court because it suggested they knew what they were doing was illegal. The Humane Society of the United States later released a version of the video to draw attention to den hunting.
The case is a good example of how scientific monitoring can protect wildlife in ways it was never designed to. Cameras, collars and long-term field studies give agencies a record of what is happening in places where enforcement officers can rarely be.
The sentences
Both men pleaded guilty to several misdemeanour counts, including the unlawful killing of the bears. The penalties, as reported by the Associated Press and Alaska's News Source, were:
- Andrew Renner (father): five months in jail with two suspended, so three months to serve, and a $20,000 fine with $11,000 suspended, leaving $9,000 to pay; forfeiture of a pickup truck, boat and trailer, weapons, skis and mobile phones, and revocation of his hunting licence for ten years.
- Owen Renner (son): 30 days of suspended jail time, community service, a required hunter safety course, and a two-year suspension of his hunting licence.
- Both: restitution of $1,800 each, the amount set by Alaska law for an illegally killed black bear.
Assistant Attorney General Aaron Peterson, who prosecuted the case for the state, said his office pushed for active jail time because of how serious the crime was. Jail time is unusual in wildlife cases, and he said the public needed to know that Alaska "will not tolerate poaching."
Why the killing was illegal
Black bears are not an endangered species, and bear hunting is legal in much of Alaska under licences and seasons set by the state. That is precisely why the details of a case like this matter. Alaska's hunting regulations generally prohibit killing cubs, or a female accompanied by cubs, in most black bear hunts, and wildlife laws require accurate reporting of every animal taken.
Ethical hunting also rests on the idea of fair chase: the animal should have a reasonable opportunity to escape. A sleeping mother and newborn cubs in a den have none. Many hunters and hunting organisations condemned the Renners' actions as poaching rather than hunting.
The wider debate over den hunting
The footage resurfaced in 2020 because of a separate federal decision. In May 2020 the Interior Department finalised a National Park Service rule that lifted earlier bans on certain hunting practices in Alaska's national preserves, including baiting brown bears, using artificial light to kill black bears and their cubs in dens, and killing wolves and pups during denning season. Supporters said the change brought federal rules in line with state rules and traditional practices; opponents, including many conservation groups, argued that such methods are cruel and undermine wildlife management.
The Renner case was not part of that rule change. It involved conduct that was illegal under the rules in force at the time. But it became a powerful image in the debate because it showed what killing bears in a den can look like.
What the case teaches
- Evidence matters. Without the camera, this would very likely have remained an unsolved and unreported crime.
- Penalties can be serious. Jail time, loss of equipment and long licence bans show that courts can treat poaching as more than a paperwork offence.
- Report what you see. If you suspect a wildlife crime, contact your state or national wildlife agency. In Alaska, the Alaska Wildlife Troopers run a Wildlife Safeguard tip line.
- Research protects animals. Long-term monitoring helps scientists manage populations and, sometimes, holds people to account.
The mother bear and her cubs could not be saved, but the case gave Alaska a clear example of how science, prosecutors and the courts can work together against poaching.
Sources: Associated Press via Juneau Empire: Alaska man, son sentenced; Alaska's News Source: hunter and son sentenced; NPCA: 2020 final hunting rule for Alaska preserves; PETA blog (original reference).

COMMENTS